Recent content by Malsori

The Bell Beakers who were Middle Eastern invaders were taller than any native European. From tested remains they were R1b carriers and possesed Dinaricized traits. Also, the Sardinians are noted for short height and they possess quite high percentages of Y-DNA I. There isn't any correlation...

I don't know why do you argue with borderline insane yugoslav nationalists. This guys think are the tallest people in the world with an average of 190 cm for their nation, Schwarzenegger-like muscular bodies. I have read how they link Y-DNA I with their tallness, how they think Y-DNA I is...

It's flawed by the sense it doesn't give precise date. It doesn't change the fact highest diversity is in Ukraine and North Romania. Ken Nordvedt is the best possible source for anything related to Y-DNA i subclades. The guy has dedicated a portion of his life studying these subclades. And...

There is no single evidence that I2a is Paleolithic or Mesolithic in origin. We have to wait for aDNA to conclude that. Everything else said is just bollocks. Besides that, how many times we have discussed that I2a among Yugoslavians is exclusively I2a1b1 which is only 2500-2000 years old. It...

I think your logic is flawed. What about the J2a peak among Chechens and other Kavkaz nations? Why they were/are not advanced? Y-DNA doesn't play any role when success or failure on culture/economy comes in hand.

Where did you pull these Pre-Roman Y-DNA frequencies? There is no ancient DNA performed about Venetian remains. It's really amazing how some people on this forum put laughable data and opinions.

According to this study. The Darginians who compose 15% of the population of Dagestan have 56% Y-DNA I. Turks have 26% and Iranians from Teheran 36%. http://www.familytreedna.com/pdf/caucasus.pdf They seem unlikely percentages to me. I have heard before the about the Iranian/Tehran high...

I have never seen any study which implies high frequency of Y-DNA I in Dagestan. Can you post it?

http://mbe.oxfordjournals.org/content/24/6/1300.full.pdf+html

EV-13 together with G2a/G1 could be the truth Middle Eastern haplogroups . They migrated in Southern Europe during Early Neolithic times and in Middle East became extinct due to expansion and conquest of J2 and J1 carrying Kavkaz-like people. According to Cruciani highest diversity and oldest...

So, you are saying that there are other Kelmendis and Highlanders tested and all of them are EV-13?

I2a in Yugoslavia is too young to be associated with PIE inhabitants of Western Balkans and Illyrian invaders from Central Europe. It is probably a East European marker Geto-Dacian, Slavic and such and significantly increased in Balkans with the Slavic invasions. You should not forget the...

Tribes are not formed exclusively from a single haplogroup. I would rather say they are mixed. From where did you conclude that lowlanders are J2b2* highlanders EV-13?

You are right, he is probably an Albanian t r o l l acting as Finn to appear as more objective. He is quite pathetic. But, he is right to some degree. Montenegrins have absorbed some Gheg Albanians. That cannot be declined.

Your haplogroup is a Balkan sub clade with a peak in Kosovo. It's ancestral clade origin is from East Turkey and Northern Iraq region. It is difficult to determine when it came in Balkans but it was probably latter than EV-13. Perhaps they came in group with J2b2* during late Neolithic times...