Ladies and Gentlemen,
sorry for my bad english, it is a lot text and i used more google as my brain.
But let me say this. I have translate the complete genetic here in this project. A really wonderful work and the most is right. But the interpretation is a bit sparly and more celtic-friendly as correct.
The author seems to have a prejudice against R1a.
the report on the genetics of R1a and R1b seems like a battle for Europe's true origin. One has the impression will be the whole of Europe Celt and even Slavs call themselves pre-Celts.
The Germanic component is actually presented as a marginal steppe people from Siberia.
Is described here in particular, the R1b from the southern or western Black Sea region, R1a but more from the eastern Black Sea region is. That is correct, but It seems more plausible that only by common strains of both the success of the Indo-Germans constituted.
Well, the fact is that in the high mountains south of the Black Sea, a very unfavorable to domesticate place for horses or even to reinvent wheels. Anyone who has even pulled a cart over mountains, know what I'm talking about.
It is also known, that is to reduce the scale deposits of glaciers in the steppes much easier than caves in mountains.
And the floor of the Steppes is much less explored archaeologically as Anatolia.
The work presented in higher level of R1b appears to be more of a prejudice against Germans.
The tip of this iceberg is the appearance of the Germanic languages as a mixture of Celtic and Slavic.
Slavic is a conglomerate of many languages, her sentence structure is closer to Latin than Germanic.
Your letter system is borrowed from the Greek. Slav means "slave". Your writing has evolved from a secret language of the slaves of Rome, they carried on into the Eastern Europe.
Germanic can not be a mixture of Celtic and Slavic, for their runes are found almost all over in Northern- Middle- and Eastern Europe to the Black Sea.
The record layout is very different from Celtic, Roman and Slavic languages.
Germanic has clearly developed from an Indo-European language. It was probably the last tribe from the Indo-European language family.
The enormous spread of R1a in Asia but also to prove, in India, which this nation has expanded much more aggressive than R1a R1b. It must always learn more innovations than it would be safe for R1b and R1b
more attractive to join the strongest brother tribe.
So went R1b not a loser, rather, as a brother in the
R1a strains were, in turn, forced the weak R1b pure strains in the hostile mountains of the Southwest, where they found their way to Europe.
This all fits in the unfavorable position of the capital of the Hittite empire away from each trade route, and its sudden demise.
The departure to the West must therefore have had a solid base and was not in the south but from the east.
When later also penetrated R1a/R1b mixed tribes in the west, they displaced the Celts in particular from these regions. You have to face them so have had an advantage.
Sure had both the proto-Celtic and the proto-Germanic technology already developed further.
Now imagine a scenario that the Proto-Germanic, the proto-Celts would be appreciated for their craftsmanship and thus integrated into their tribes..
That the Germans themselves were limited to North and Eastern Europe uses advance a certain respect for other peoples. They settled either in Western or Southern Europe. Why?
If you look at the German American Nordic religion look closely, there seems an echo of the true story to find. In Germanic mythology the three strains is discussed. Also of 2 divine dynasties, the Aesir and Vanir.
Also know that some parallels to Germanic mythology to Celtic mythology. Tyr and Toutatis, and Taranis Wotan,
Giants, dwarfs, elves, trees, animals and sacred sites but also calendar and festivals.
It almost seems as if the Germans some Celtic gods as Vanir have taken in their own religion, but others replaced with Germanic gods and thus create peace in heaven.
It is interesting in this respect also, that they believed the world would perish in a huge battle (Ragnarok), fight together with Aesir and Vanir against giants and mythical monsters.
The Celts and Germans are mixed at the intersection is completely normal. But the Germans are fighting for the Celts and the Celts for Germans tends to suggest that they are always considered as brother nations, not a Celtic or Germanic.
Likewise, the boundaries were flowing among those Eastern European tribes who were appointed by Rome as the Scythians.
Obviously, the Germans considered both the eastern and the western neighbor nation as a brother nation.
Only the submission of the Celts by Caesar and the development of a Slavic language and the victory in the Varus battle may have changed their view of the world completely.
Rome has thus made the Germans as a people.
It would be, but not a German-Slavic branch, but rather an act originally mixed R1a/R1b Germanic branch.
This is also the mutation of the lactose tolerance to it has 2000-year-old center always in the middle of Germany and its spread significantly in France and Poland are demonstrated.
Finally, slaves brought their secret language deep in the free East, where it developed as an innovation, and finally with Slavic immigrants found their way back to Europe.
The royal families all belong to the R1b is, in turn, to the particular success of West Germans and their convenient location to Scandinavia, France and England.
The Anglo-Saxons established centuries ago the king of England. The sex of the French franc is also the creation or Normans (Norsemen, Vikings) back.
Also the Spanish and Italian race is West Germanic origin. Let us recall because of Alaric and Theodoric.
The Russian family of the Romanov goes back to the Rus, that was the name of the Vikings, from Norway exhibited along the Volga and the Dnieper, the whole nobility of the Russian Empire.
West German table is not only today's High German, but also Dutch, English and Scandinavian languages.
Every German can still understand parts of the Gothic language of 2,000 years ago. He is also capable of Scandinavian and Dutch, with some imagination (ok, really high imagination) to understand.
(Though, some not even understand Frisian or Bavarian.
The English language is a West Germanic base system.
Old English is essentially a development of the Anglo-Saxon from the 5th Century
It still uses a jargon that us more like a
a complicated "Minne Song" in a German dialect spoken north extreme occurs.
From the Latin, the modern English has borrowed mostly neologisms. The English language is that of the world differ in the furthest in writing and pronunciation.
Unfortunately, it is up to date so the world would rather be Celt.
England would never be German manner (Anglo-Saxons). Scandinavians keep the Vikings for Eastern Celts and even the German believe they are actually Celtic. This paper confirms that Impression.
But not only the language, even the lactose tolerance among Caucasians in England, Scandinavia, Netherlands, USA and Australia is a legacy of the good old Germans. And the ancient ancestors were not from Hitler.
Germans, Romans, Celts and Slavs (which in my opinion more
Scythians should be called, are Indo-Europeans.
R1b dominated Western Europe, R1a dominated northern Asia, including Siberia. So who is more successful?
Hitler was not a modern German, and probably had more Jewish ancestors. Even the pedigree of the great Abraham Lincoln has beautiful black branches and Stalin would easily pass as the Vikings. Probably we will find a brother in Gandhi.
Ultimately, we are thus all Africans.
So it is not necessary to make R1b into bright hero.
Have a nice first advent.
greets from the ancient german part.