@sile, are you making multiple lines of blank spaces between every half a sentence just to fill the thread and make unreadable?
Maybe in the hope that people will just read the title from 2013 and leave it at that?
And by the way, you really do care much about making I2a-slav seem more obscure than it is, dont you?
The mysterious thracian haplogroup which somehow slipped into all places which slavs have settled or raided throughout history.
Move on, there is nothing wrong in being wrong sometimes. You learn, and you move on.
I almost believed this fairytale too a couple if years ago when haplogroups were still at an infant stage.
But come on, why would someone who still believes this in 2017 even be at a forum discussing genetics?
Still believing it clearly indicates to me that you are hardheadedly figting the facts which are right in front of you. Who does that unless the facts compromise their motives?
So imo, you are either pushing these speculations through because you have some personal interest, or because you havent read anything about the history and genetics of the balkans and europe.
And Personally i think you guys are wasting your time. You are clearly not commenting to convince me or Trojet or any other of the active posters on this thread, but to trick new members into believing your fairytales.
But listen why you are wasting your time: Anyone who believes in your propaganda does clearly not know much about history and genes. And therefore their opinion will never matter in the academic world.
So for your own sake, just stop. You are not achieving anything. While you are speculating, the biggest slavic country, russia, is working intensively on pan-slavic theories. And as it seems, the western scholars agree with the russians in this aspect.
No serious academics support your claim, neither slavs nor non-slavs.
None of the people you are trying to trick will be able to do anything against the mighty powers like western scholars and russian scholars.
I on the other hand, i am not trying to trick people like you, because most people with a little knowlegde on history know that your claims are absurd, so they dont need me to teach them.
I do it because it makes me angry to see these things and i cant help myself but react.
Sent from my iPhone using
Eupedia Forum