Y-DNA haplogroups in Macedonia

[Maciamo]

I am currently revising the Y-DNA frequencies in Eastern Europe. The current data for Macedonia includes the following papers: Pericic 2005, Bosch 2006, Noveski 2009 and Trivodalieva 2010.

I have found one more study by Spiroski et al. (2005), which tested 150 samples. Unfortunately they only mention the STR values, not the haplogroups. In the past I have run them for other studies in the haplogroup predictor. But as this is time consuming and I am already quite busy I was wondering if anybody here had calculated the haplogroup frequencies for this study or was willing to do it ? If someone can provide them I will be happy to add it to the data of the four other studies for the Y-DNA tables.

 

[Sile]

I am currently revising the Y-DNA frequencies in Eastern Europe. The current data for Macedonia includes the following papers: Pericic 2005, Bosch 2006, Noveski 2009 and Trivodalieva 2010.

I have found one more study by Spiroski et al. (2005), which tested 150 samples. Unfortunately they only mention the STR values, not the haplogroups. In the past I have run them for other studies in the haplogroup predictor. But as this is time consuming and I am already quite busy I was wondering if anybody here had calculated the haplogroup frequencies for this study or was willing to do it ? If someone can provide them I will be happy to add it to the data of the four other studies for the Y-DNA tables.

If you know a way of putting the data in FTDNA order , it would not take long.
I did 12....results below, top is #1 and next is #2 etc

E1b1b1-M35

I2a-P37.2

R1a1a-M198

R1ab1b2-M269

E-M78

I2a-P37.2

I2a-P37.2

R-M417

I2a-P37.2

I1

E-V13

E-M35

 

[Maciamo]

Thanks. Perhaps other members can each post the next 10 or 12 results. This way we could get the 150 samples uncovered in no time.

 

[matbir]

I have used "predictor ydna ru" (I can not post links)

Haplotype ID	n	comment	Probability	Haplogroup
1	8		53%	E1b1b1a1b-V13
2	3		100%	I2a-P37.2
3	3		53%	R1a1a1*-Unclustered-M417*(xM458,L365)
4	3		100%	R1b1b2-M269
5	3		60%	E1b1b1a1b-V13
6	2		100%	I2a-P37.2
7	2		100%	I2a-P37.2
8	2		97%	I2a-P37.2
9	2		100%	R1a1a-M198
10	2		96%	I1-M253
11	2		94%	E1b1b1a1b-V13
12	2		92%	E1b1b1a1b-V13
13	2		80%	E1b1b1a1b-V13
14	2		65%	E1b1b1a1b-V13
15	1		100%	R1a1a-M198
16	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
17	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
18	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
19	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
20	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
21	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
22	1		52%	I2a-P37.2
23	1		99%	I2a-P37.2
24	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
25	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
26	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
27	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
28	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
29	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
30	1		99%	I2a-P37.2
31	1		96%	I2a-P37.2
32	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
33	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
34	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
35	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
36	1		99%	I2a-P37.2
37	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
38	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
39	1		95%	I2a-P37.2
40	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
41	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
42	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
43	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
44	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
45	1		76%	I2a-P37.2
46	1		100%	R1a1a-M198
47	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
48	1		83%	R1a1a1*-Vikings-M417*(xM458,L365)
49	1		95%	I2a-P37.2
50	1		79%	I1-M253
51	1		82%	I2a-P37.2
52	1		94%	R1a1a1*-388=10-M417*(xM458,L365)
53	1		99%	I2a-P37.2
54	1		97%	I2a-P37.2
55	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
56	1		56%	J2a4-L26
57	1		90%	R1a1a1*-Vikings-M417*(xM458,L365)
58	1		100%	R1a1a-M198
59	1		100%	R1a1a-M198
60	1		77%	E1b1b1a1c-V22
61	1		97%	J1c3-P58
62	1		100%	L1c-M357
63	1	*H M69 65,7%	54%	J2a4-L26
64	1		90%	R1a1a-M198
65	1		97%	R1b1b2-M269
66	1		92%	R1b1b2-M269
67	1		79%	I2a-P37.2
68	1		51%	I2-M438
69	1		74%	G2a-P15
70	1		98%	R1a1a-M198
71	1		96%	J2b2f-L283
72	1		98%	G2a-P15
73	1		97%	I1-M253
74	1		55%	G2a-P15
75	1		97%	J2b2f-L283
76	1		99%	J2b2f-L283
77	1		98%	J2b2f-L283
78	1		100%	J2b2f-L283
79	1	G2a-P15 77,5%	97%	F-M89
80	1		68%	E1b1b1*-M35(xM78,M81,M123)
81	1		89%	E1b1b1*-M35(xM78,M81,M123)
82	1		99%	T1b-L131
83	1		82%	T1a1b-P77
84	1		100%	J2a*-M410(xL26)
85	1		100%	L1b1-M349
86	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
87	1		100%	R1b1b2-M269
88	1		99%	R1b1b2-M269
89	1		100%	R1b1b2-M269
90	1		51%	E1b1b1a1-M78
91	1	J1 99%	50%	_DE-M1
92	1		100%	R1b1b2-M269
93	1		100%	R1b1b2-M269
94	1		100%	R1b1b2-M269
95	1		100%	R1b1b2-M269
96	1		100%	R1b1b2-M269
97	1		100%	R1b1b2-M269
98	1		100%	R1b1b2-M269
99	1		100%	R1b1b2-M269
100	1		87%	J2a*-M410(xL26)
101	1		67%	J1*-M267*(xM365,L136)
102	1		100%	R1b1b2-M269
103	1		100%	R1b1b2-M269
104	1		100%	R1b1b2-M269
105	1		99%	L1b1-M349
106	1		94%	I1-M253
107	1		80%	J2b2f-L283
108	1		99%	I1-M253
109	1	I1 99,2% ; 76%	89%	P-M45
110	1		99%	I1-M253
111	1		100%	E1b1b1-M35
112	1		100%	T1b-L131
113	1		65%	E1b1b1a1-M78
114	1		91%	E1b1b1a1b-V13
115	1		62%	E1b1b1a1b-V13
116	1		73%	E1b1b1a1b-V13
117	1		96%	E1b1b1a1b-V13
118	1		60%	E1b1b1a1b-V13
119	1		84%	E1b1b1a1b-V13
120	1		100%	R1b1b2-M269
121	1		99%	T1b-L131
122	1		85%	E1b1b1a1-M78
123	1		53%	E1b1b1a1-M78
124	1		94%	E1b1b1c-M123
125	1		57%	E1b1b1c-M123
126	1		97%	G2a-P15

For every under 60% probability I have checked results in predictor posted by Maciamo and if it differed it is shown in comments. For #109 I have added to comment probability from Jim Cullen predictor.

Edit: Maciamo if you will be revising Poland I will be glad to share with you data from Wozniak et al.2010.

 

[Sile]

I have used "predictor ydna ru" (I can not post links)

Haplotype ID	n	comment	Probability	Haplogroup
1	8		53%	E1b1b1a1b-V13
2	3		100%	I2a-P37.2
3	3		53%	R1a1a1*-Unclustered-M417*(xM458,L365)
4	3		100%	R1b1b2-M269
5	3		60%	E1b1b1a1b-V13
6	2		100%	I2a-P37.2
7	2		100%	I2a-P37.2
8	2		97%	I2a-P37.2
9	2		100%	R1a1a-M198
10	2		96%	I1-M253
11	2		94%	E1b1b1a1b-V13
12	2		92%	E1b1b1a1b-V13
13	2		80%	E1b1b1a1b-V13
14	2		65%	E1b1b1a1b-V13
15	1		100%	R1a1a-M198
16	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
17	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
18	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
19	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
20	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
21	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
22	1		52%	I2a-P37.2
23	1		99%	I2a-P37.2
24	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
25	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
26	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
27	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
28	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
29	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
30	1		99%	I2a-P37.2
31	1		96%	I2a-P37.2
32	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
33	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
34	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
35	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
36	1		99%	I2a-P37.2
37	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
38	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
39	1		95%	I2a-P37.2
40	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
41	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
42	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
43	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
44	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
45	1		76%	I2a-P37.2
46	1		100%	R1a1a-M198
47	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
48	1		83%	R1a1a1*-Vikings-M417*(xM458,L365)
49	1		95%	I2a-P37.2
50	1		79%	I1-M253
51	1		82%	I2a-P37.2
52	1		94%	R1a1a1*-388=10-M417*(xM458,L365)
53	1		99%	I2a-P37.2
54	1		97%	I2a-P37.2
55	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
56	1		56%	J2a4-L26
57	1		90%	R1a1a1*-Vikings-M417*(xM458,L365)
58	1		100%	R1a1a-M198
59	1		100%	R1a1a-M198
60	1		77%	E1b1b1a1c-V22
61	1		97%	J1c3-P58
62	1		100%	L1c-M357
63	1	*H M69 65,7%	54%	J2a4-L26
64	1		90%	R1a1a-M198
65	1		97%	R1b1b2-M269
66	1		92%	R1b1b2-M269
67	1		79%	I2a-P37.2
68	1		51%	I2-M438
69	1		74%	G2a-P15
70	1		98%	R1a1a-M198
71	1		96%	J2b2f-L283
72	1		98%	G2a-P15
73	1		97%	I1-M253
74	1		55%	G2a-P15
75	1		97%	J2b2f-L283
76	1		99%	J2b2f-L283
77	1		98%	J2b2f-L283
78	1		100%	J2b2f-L283
79	1	G2a-P15 77,5%	97%	F-M89
80	1		68%	E1b1b1*-M35(xM78,M81,M123)
81	1		89%	E1b1b1*-M35(xM78,M81,M123)
82	1		99%	T1b-L131
83	1		82%	T1a1b-P77
84	1		100%	J2a*-M410(xL26)
85	1		100%	L1b1-M349
86	1		100%	I2a-P37.2
87	1		100%	R1b1b2-M269
88	1		99%	R1b1b2-M269
89	1		100%	R1b1b2-M269
90	1		51%	E1b1b1a1-M78
91	1	J1 99%	50%	_DE-M1
92	1		100%	R1b1b2-M269
93	1		100%	R1b1b2-M269
94	1		100%	R1b1b2-M269
95	1		100%	R1b1b2-M269
96	1		100%	R1b1b2-M269
97	1		100%	R1b1b2-M269
98	1		100%	R1b1b2-M269
99	1		100%	R1b1b2-M269
100	1		87%	J2a*-M410(xL26)
101	1		67%	J1*-M267*(xM365,L136)
102	1		100%	R1b1b2-M269
103	1		100%	R1b1b2-M269
104	1		100%	R1b1b2-M269
105	1		99%	L1b1-M349
106	1		94%	I1-M253
107	1		80%	J2b2f-L283
108	1		99%	I1-M253
109	1	I1 99,2% ; 76%	89%	P-M45
110	1		99%	I1-M253
111	1		100%	E1b1b1-M35
112	1		100%	T1b-L131
113	1		65%	E1b1b1a1-M78
114	1		91%	E1b1b1a1b-V13
115	1		62%	E1b1b1a1b-V13
116	1		73%	E1b1b1a1b-V13
117	1		96%	E1b1b1a1b-V13
118	1		60%	E1b1b1a1b-V13
119	1		84%	E1b1b1a1b-V13
120	1		100%	R1b1b2-M269
121	1		99%	T1b-L131
122	1		85%	E1b1b1a1-M78
123	1		53%	E1b1b1a1-M78
124	1		94%	E1b1b1c-M123
125	1		57%	E1b1b1c-M123
126	1		97%	G2a-P15

For every under 60% probability I have checked results in predictor posted by Maciamo and if it differed it is shown in comments. For #109 I have added to comment probability from Jim Cullen predictor.

Edit: Maciamo if you will be revising Poland I will be glad to share with you data from Wozniak et al.2010.

Thanks on info

Breaking up your numbers to a simplified percentage, we have something like this
J1 = 1.3%
J2 = 7.3%
E = 23.3%
I2 = 32.0%
I1 = 5.3%
L = 2.0%
R1a = 9.3%
R1b = 13.3%
T = 2.7%
G = 3.3%

I2 appears again, IMO clearly a pontic steppe and eastern balkan marker.
G, T and L still hovering around together in minor numbers.
R1a and R1b , very low numbers when they have huge numbers elsewhere in Europe.
J1 is very poor...hmm

 

[Milan.M]

Here is some results on most dominant haplogroups among ethnic Macedonians,however i don't know the source
I2a 29.4%
E1b 18%
R1a 14.2%
J2 12.7%
R1b 11.4%
G 3.8%

SIMILARITIES WITH OTHER NATIONS ( Randomly selected)
Aegean Macedonia + Thrace (North Greece): 86.2%
Serbia: 82.4%
Bulgaria: 81.3%
Greece: 73.6%
Macedonian Albanians: 61.5%
Russia: 44.1%
Poland: 43%