PDA

View Full Version : Greatest Ancient Egyptian contribution(s) to the world



Maciamo
13-10-05, 17:45
Just remaking Zauriel's thread and poll (http://www.eupedia.com/forum/showthread.php?t=19847). :-)

Anchyyy
26-10-05, 20:47
I think the greatest contribution are pyramids. They are full of secrets, with all those mummies and paintings all over the walls. :-)

Kinsao
26-10-05, 22:27
Embalming is pretty important, too, because it's due to good preservation that we can learn a lot about the ancient Egyptian society. :-)

I think papyrus is also very important... except I don't know well my world history... so I don't know where else paper was invented... probably it would have been invented somewhere else if not in Egypt, eventually...

Of course, the calendar is still with us now, and close to everyone in a way that pyramids and mummies aren't... so maybe that is more "important"? It's difficult to say... :clueless:

And the "practical inventions"... well, pulley, sundial, waterclock... I don't know what the others are and I'm sure they're all as important... I can't imagine the world without pulleys, for example, but needs must when the devil drives and I'm sure another nation would have invented the pulley if the Egyptians hadn't... In short, I can't say! :sorry:

Maciamo
27-10-05, 02:36
I voted for papyrus (the ancestor of paper, even if not in direct line), glass making and the 365-day calendar, as they are the only one that have had a lasting effect on modern society. Surveying could be considered, but I think it could have easily developed independently in other cultures (just requires some mathematics, common to all human societies).

gohan93
27-10-05, 04:02
ancient civilizations are kinda fun to learn about... i think that the calendar is the most important.

Sensuikan San
27-10-05, 04:41
I too, voted for the calendar ... but ...

Was it not the Maya who actually nailed it to 365.25 days? (Of course - quite a few years later ....)

Just a thought ...

ジョン

Ma Cherie
27-10-05, 04:56
I too, voted for the calendar ... but ...

Was it not the Maya who actually nailed it to 365.25 days? (Of course - quite a few years later ....)

Just a thought ...

ジョン

I was thinking about that, too. They also had their own pyramids. There's been some speculation because it seems the Maya and ancient Egyptians shared some things in common. But I think it's just a coincidence, though. By the way, the Mayans calendar is still accurate, at least right now it is, becasue they believed the world is coming to an in 2013. :mad:

gohan93
27-10-05, 04:57
i doubt that the world ends in 2013 though...

Ma Cherie
27-10-05, 05:01
i doubt that the world ends in 2013 though...

I do too, but that was something that the Mayans believed when they made their calendar.

nurizeko
27-10-05, 10:51
I voted papyrus, because its just considored the natural forfather of paper, even, as said, not directly.

The carthaginians invented clear glass, while the egyptians only managed coloured, so the carthaginians get the brownie points on that front.

^ lynx ^
29-09-10, 20:42
Papyrus gets my vote.

LeBrok
24-11-10, 06:31
We still use glass, surveying and pulley and in great quantities. They got my vote.

I can't believe though that the calendar is winning, lol. It so irrelevant how you call days of week or measure the year. Any callender we'd use, our lives would be exactly the same.

Wheal
23-10-17, 17:34
I voted for glass making because it affects so many on a daily basis, and maybe because my dad was a glazing contractor

ratchet_fan
15-07-20, 01:16
Is there any truth to the argument that Egypt's culture and accomplishments are derived from Upper Egypt or Nubia? This seems to be the new Afrocentric argument now that the argument that Egyptians were genetic SSA is completely dead.

Philjames100
16-07-20, 13:25
Can you name anything specific which supposedly came from Nubia?

ratchet_fan
16-07-20, 14:18
Can you name anything specific which supposedly came from Nubia?

Supposedly they invented alphabets.


In subsequent centuries, Nubians adopted the Egyptian method of writing but then discarded the cumbersome hieroglyphic system and, in an intellectual achievement rare in human history, invented a more sophisticated way of writing, using an alphabet.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/1995/05/10/the-grandeur-that-was-nubia/c53ae464-68aa-4bdc-88c1-b713816572c0/

This claim is dubious imo. I believe another historian in the article acknowledges that Greek and Phoenecians had alphabets at the same time.

Wikipedia also casts doubt on them having invented an alphabet. It says both Meroitic scripts are derived from Egyptian forms.


The two scripts are Meroitic Cursive derived of Demotic Egyptian (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demotic_Egyptian) and Meroitic Hieroglyphics derived of Egyptian hieroglyphs (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Egyptian_hieroglyphs).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meroitic_script

Philjames100
16-07-20, 15:15
Supposedly they invented alphabets.


https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/1995/05/10/the-grandeur-that-was-nubia/c53ae464-68aa-4bdc-88c1-b713816572c0/

This claim is dubious imo. I believe another historian in the article acknowledges that Greek and Phoenecians had alphabets at the same time.

Wikipedia also casts doubt on them having invented an alphabet. It says both Meroitic scripts are derived from Egyptian forms.


[/FONT][/COLOR]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meroitic_script

The Meroitic script dates from c.300-200 BC, long after the first alphabets, and during the Ptolemaic period when Egypt was under Greek rule. It has nothing to do with 'Egyptian culture and achievements originating from Nubia'.

ratchet_fan
16-07-20, 17:15
The Meroitic script dates from c.300-200 BC, long after the first alphabets, and during the Ptolemaic period when Egypt was under Greek rule. It has nothing to do with 'Egyptian culture and achievements originating from Nubia'.

ok. I'm glad the afrocentrist argument holds no weight.

On a related note is there any truth to the Library of Alexandria holding a lot of lost knowledge before it was destroyed?

Philjames100
16-07-20, 18:50
It seems likely some knowledge was lost, but the Library of Alexandria was created by Greeks.