I have added Y-DNA frequencies for almost all autonomous regions of Spain and reworked the haplogroup maps accordingly. I used the data from Flores et al. Adams et al. Maca-Meyer et al. as well as Iberianroots.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature currently requires accessing the site using the built-in Safari browser.
Why don't you use the study of Belaresque et al. for the R1b ? They have 72% of R1b for East Andalusia, 70% for Castille-la-Mancha, etc.I have added Y-DNA frequencies for almost all autonomous regions of Spain and reworked the haplogroup maps accordingly. I used the data from Flores et al. Adams et al. Maca-Meyer et al. as well as Iberianroots.
Catalans are the most similar to Basques on Y-DNA frequencies, interesting. I wonder what Navarrans would look, they sould show more or less the same frequencies. The surprise is that I expected more R1b in Aragón.
Why don't you use the study of Belaresque et al. for the R1b ? They have 72% of R1b for East Andalusia, 70% for Castille-la-Mancha, etc.
Anyways, the R1b map needs an update on Iberia. For example Catalonia has 80% while in the map shows 60-70%.Because data has to be consistent. Balaresque doesn't mention other haplogroups. Besides, I make the total for all the studies by counting samples for each haplogroup (not by averaging percentages, as some studies have much bigger sample sizes than others). My total samples for Andalusia and Castille-la-Mancha are 3 to 4 times larger than the Balaresque et al. study.
Anyways, the R1b map needs an update on Iberia. For example Catalonia has 80% while in the map shows 60-70%.
Anyways, the R1b map needs an update on Iberia. For example Catalonia has 80% while in the map shows 60-70%.
The table of haplogroups show 10% of I2a for Andalusia yet in the map it shows 1-5% ??
I doubled checked, and the reason is that the Y-DNA tables have data for I2* and I2a together in the same column. But most of the I2 in Andalusia is actually I2*. I2* is probably of Anatolian or Caucasian origin. Another place where it is found is Crete. I suppose it came with the Neolithic farmers.
But the map of haplogorup T looks awful for Spain. I mean, at Iberianroots Andalusia has 1% (n=193) yet in the map appears more than 4% ? Or Extremadura 0%, Castile-La-Mancha 0%, Castille León 0%, Argón 0% and they appear in the 3-4% range
Maciamo, did you get the Andalusian Haplogroup I from Flores et al? If so, I think you're misinterpreting it. It only tested SNPs M170 (defines I) and M26 (defines I2a1a). So the part that you're interpreting as "I2*" is probably mostly I2a2a (until recently I2b1, would be I2b in your tables) and I1, with maybe some stray I2a2b's and I2a1b's. I would guess a relatively high amount of I1 due to how coastal Andalusia is, but I'm not sure about that. AFAIK there has yet to be any I2* or I2c found in Spain.
This thread has been viewed 17381 times.