PDA

View Full Version : Proposed Y-dna marker changes



Sile
08-06-14, 02:31
Is this Legit

Are the R-Ydna group going to be renamed K2b2 ? ..............what no more R1a v R1b issues?


http://dienekes.blogspot.com.au/2014/06/refined-structure-in-haplogroup-k-m526.html

http://forwhattheywereweare.blogspot.com.au/2014/06/y-dna-macro-haplogroup-k-m526.html

Is ms. Karafet, the queen of the K group getting here way again as it was in 2008?
It seems, that K group holds the key to society, before K all was quite, then Bang...K exploded and we have .................

bicicleur
08-06-14, 17:15
it is very interesting, and it was to be expected, once they started analysing full genomes, much more detail is becoming clear, complicating the overall picture

yes K exploded , but so did F and C before
C subclades all have been renamed recently

if you want to rename all K subclades, maybe you should develop some logic that would apply to F as well

Sile
08-06-14, 21:09
it is very interesting, and it was to be expected, once they started analysing full genomes, much more detail is becoming clear, complicating the overall picture

yes K exploded , but so did F and C before
C subclades all have been renamed recently

if you want to rename all K subclades, maybe you should develop some logic that would apply to F as well

The paper seems to want to portray that the K group is the beginning of the spread of man at a faster pace, as I said an explosion of migration , I think these geneticist want to create these new K markers as a base for future data

oriental
08-06-14, 22:21
Maybe it is better this way to show we are all related rather than splitting into subclades as if we are of separate "races".