A Stunning Find in Kurdistan

Alan

Elite member
Messages
2,517
Reaction score
450
Points
0
Ethnic group
Kurdish
Y-DNA haplogroup
R1a1a1
mtDNA haplogroup
HV2a1 +G13708A
As Islamic Militants Destroy Iraq Heritage, a Stunning Find in Kurdistan

By Alexandra Di Stefano Pironti yesterday at 06:50

56243Image1.jpg


At the temple, the columns are made of green basalt, and some with sandstone, limestone and marble.
BARCELONA, Spain – While the history of civilization is being demolished by war and religious zealots in the rest of Iraq, in the Kurdistan Region archeologists are marveling at a stunning discovery: the remains of a long-lost temple from the biblical kingdom of Urartu, dating back to the 9th century BC.


Kurdish archaeologist Dlshad Marf Zamua, who has studied the columns and other artifacts at the find, told Rudaw these were unearthed piecemeal over the past four decades by villagers going about their lives, digging for cultivation or construction.


But only recently, after the discovery of life-size human statues and the unearthed columns, Zamua realized that the villagers had stumbled upon the temple of Haldi. That was one of the most important gods of Urartu, an Iron-Age kingdom around Lake Van in the Armenian.


The temple was found in the village of Mdjeser, in the district of Bradost-Sidekan, the most northeastern corner of Iraq and bordering Iran and Turkey.


“The temple was recorded very well in the Assyrian and Urartian inscriptions,” explained Zamua, a doctoral student at Leiden University in the Netherlands who also teaches at Salahaddin University in Erbil.


“One of the reliefs depicts the plunder of the temple by the Assyrian King Sargon II in 714 BC,” said the researcher, who spent from 2005 to 2012 working on the site.


According to historical evidence and the recently uncovered sites, the ancient city of Musasir, located where Mdjeser is today, was home to Haldi’s temple.


Mdjeser was one of more than 4,000 villages destroyed during the Anfal campaign of former Iraqi dictator Saddam Hussein, which especially targeted the Kurds and is gaining international recognition as an act of genocide.


Even now some villagers will not return to rebuild their homes because of the troubles in Iraq, which have made things worse in this border region.


The ancient capital was known as Musasir by the Assyrians and as Ardini by the Urartians themselves. It was among the lands that formed a string of buffer states between the two powers of the time, Assyria and Urartu.


Zamua also studied eleven human-size statues unearthed in the same area, which he believes are from the Scythian state of the 7th-6th century BC. They were originally erected above the graves of chieftains and warrior leaders.


“Most of the uncovered statues at Mdjeser and the neighboring Topzawa Valley have also a typical Scythian iconography,” Zamua said, explaining the figures were shown in real-life situations, such as holding a cup, strapping on a dagger or holding a hatchet, the preferred Scythian weapon.


At the temple, the columns are made of green basalt, and some with sandstone, limestone and marble.


“The importance of my research is that is the first time on the base of archaeological and textual data that we can show the penetration of the Scythians into Kurdistan during the 8th -7th centuries BC,” Zamua said.


“Kurdistan is one of the richest areas in the world in archaeology. There are thousands of archaeological sites -- caves, settlements, cities, citadels, castles, rock reliefs, bridges -- covering almost all the history and the lives of humans on earth from the stone ages to modern times.”


Luckily, the archaeological sites in Brodost-Sidekan are far from the rebellion and war raging across Iraq for more than a month.


Still, being an archeologist in Kurdistan is not easy, Zamua said, listing the dangers to include tens of thousands of unexploded land mines, especially from the 1980-88 Iran-Iraq war.


Other hazards are Iranian shelling of the area, Zamua said, which happened last in June. Turkish jets also have bombed the area several times in the past.


As an archaeologist, Zamua worries about the impact of war and the Islamic State (IS) on sites that are some of the earliest records of civilization.


IS fighters have been destroying historical sites during their military conquests, especially targeting Shiite shrines.


“In this chaotic situation they may loot ancient objects and sell them in the international black market to fund these groups,” Zamua said, voicing a growing concern.


He said that in this regard Kurdistan was acting very responsibly.


“Kurdistan is protecting its borders very well and the directorates of antiquities actively are trying to look at the archaeological sites to protect them,” he said.


He applauded the Kurdistan Regional Government (KRG) for allowing foreign archeologists to work on sites. But he complained that, “there is no special fund for local archaeologists to start big projects.”


http://rudaw.net/english/culture/22072014


So city was Urartain with Scythian settlements under war with the Assyrians on their southern border.
 
Last edited:
So city was Urartain with Scythian settlements under war with the Assyrians on their southern border.
Here we go, this might explain interesting paternal haplogroups among Kurds.
 
“One of the reliefs depicts the plunder of the temple by the Assyrian King Sargon II in 714 BC,” said the researcher, who spent from 2005 to 2012 working on the site."

I'm assuming this is a drawing of the relief:

56243Image1.jpg




 
Urartu was not IE (?)
I guess it descended from Kura-Araxes , which was supposed G2a
But according to the map there is not much G2a in Kurdistan

strange ..
 
So the Kurds are descendants of proto-Armenians?

Despite what Wikipedia says. Urartians are very unlikely proto-Armenians. claiming Urartians to be an ethnicity which didn't even existed so far back is based on chauvinistic viewpoint and has not much to do with science. Urartians are an "isolated group"(or yet unidentified). Armenians probably have some Urartian admixture but a Phrygian origin is allot more likely.
 
Urartu was not IE (?)
I guess it descended from Kura-Araxes , which was supposed G2a
But according to the map there is not much G2a in Kurdistan

strange ..

Is there actually any evidence Kura Araxes was all G2a? I suspect allot of R* too.
Also despite G2a showing strangely weak in Kurds in Eupedia charts this might be coincidence and due to low/local sampling. For example 6% R1b in Turkish Kurdistan thats the weakest frequency I have seen in all of the studies made on this land. Usually Turkish Kurdistan scores in allot of studies 10-20% R1b and G2a reaches average of 8% in Kurdistan. 17-20% of I* is a bit too high too. No doubt that I* exists there cause I have seen individual samples turning out I2*, but I assume that this would also be corrected down to 10% with further sampling.
 
Oh no, not again. Kurds are predominately the Medes. There are still very close genetic ties between the Persians and Kurds, like in the past the Medes and ancient Persians were very close related.

Although it’s true that the Cimmerians and Scythians sacked the Urartu (Hurrian) empire together with the Aryan Medes. But the Medes (ancestors of the Medes) destroyed Scytho-Cimmerian kings and threw out Scythians out of Kurdistan. True, Scythians were in Kurdistan, but Kurds are from the Medes. But I don’t deny that Kurds have some genetic input from the Scythians. And we have also some genetic input from the Urartu and Chaldeans at the time when they were Zoroastrians.
Urartu came originally from the Caucasus mountains. The ancient Assyrians came from the Levant and the Arabian Peninsula.
The Kurds (Matiene/Mitanni,Kassites, Gutians, Medes etc.) are the native inhabitants of Kurdistan (Northern Mesopotamia)!
 
Oh no, not again. Kurds are predominately the Medes. There are still very close genetic ties between the Persians and Kurds, like in the past the Medes and ancient Persians were very close related.

Although it’s true that the Cimmerians and Scythians sacked the Urartu (Hurrian) empire together with the Aryan Medes. But the Medes (ancestors of the Medes) destroyed Scytho-Cimmerian kings and threw out Scythians out of Kurdistan. True, Scythians were in Kurdistan, but Kurds are from the Medes. But I don’t deny that Kurds have some genetic input from the Scythians. And we have also some genetic input from the Urartu and Chaldeans at the time when they were Zoroastrians.
Urartu came originally from the Caucasus mountains. The ancient Assyrians came from the Levant and the Arabian Peninsula.
The Kurds (Matiene/Mitanni,Kassites, Gutians, Medes etc.) are the native inhabitants of Kurdistan (Northern Mesopotamia)!

>>> interesting

How about the Indo-Aryans who ruled the Hurrian Mitanni, what happend to them..
 
Also, how much mongoloid genetics is there in Kurdistan? The Girl here on the right looks Turkic.

6588934289_e156513eb2_z.jpg
 
Is there actually any evidence Kura Araxes was all G2a? I suspect allot of R* too.
Also despite G2a showing strangely weak in Kurds in Eupedia charts this might be coincidence and due to low/local sampling. For example 6% R1b in Turkish Kurdistan thats the weakest frequency I have seen in all of the studies made on this land. Usually Turkish Kurdistan scores in allot of studies 10-20% R1b and G2a reaches average of 8% in Kurdistan. 17-20% of I* is a bit too high too. No doubt that I* exists there cause I have seen individual samples turning out I2*, but I assume that this would also be corrected down to 10% with further sampling.

no evidence for that , but genetically they may be related to the Maykop people , that's why I think G2a
R1* or R1b* I would expect a little further east .. maybe the Gutians
 
Despite what Wikipedia says. Urartians are very unlikely proto-Armenians. claiming Urartians to be an ethnicity which didn't even existed so far back is based on chauvinistic viewpoint and has not much to do with science. Urartians are an "isolated group"(or yet unidentified). Armenians probably have some Urartian admixture but a Phrygian origin is allot more likely.

what language did Urartians speak , anything known about that ?
 
Oh no, not again. Kurds are predominately the Medes. There are still very close genetic ties between the Persians and Kurds, like in the past the Medes and ancient Persians were very close related.

Although it’s true that the Cimmerians and Scythians sacked the Urartu (Hurrian) empire together with the Aryan Medes. But the Medes (ancestors of the Medes) destroyed Scytho-Cimmerian kings and threw out Scythians out of Kurdistan. True, Scythians were in Kurdistan, but Kurds are from the Medes. But I don’t deny that Kurds have some genetic input from the Scythians. And we have also some genetic input from the Urartu and Chaldeans at the time when they were Zoroastrians.
Urartu came originally from the Caucasus mountains. The ancient Assyrians came from the Levant and the Arabian Peninsula.
The Kurds (Matiene/Mitanni,Kassites, Gutians, Medes etc.) are the native inhabitants of Kurdistan (Northern Mesopotamia)!

You are arguing against a Ghost. Who actually claimed here that Medes and their successors the Parthians are not our ancestors, that you felt the need to start all this drama? The thing here is that there are Scythian and Cimmerian settlements throughout Kurdistan. You should know that there is not a single period of time where Medes were ever isolated from Scythian influx. Scythians did not only "raid" Urartu or Media, contrary they settled there and quite some time even ruled it. Urartians, Babylonians, Scythians and Medes united against Assyrians and were befriended quite some time.

If you knew something about medes or Media you would know that it compromised land and people of various background. Heredotus regards to Mitanni as the same as Medes. Cyrus regarded Gutium as part of Media. Thats not all according to Heredotus two of the six founding tribes among Medes are of Scythian background. Medes and Persians are related people so how the heck could you expect anything else than similarities?

However I already once explained you the relatively significant difference between Kurds and Persian on genetic, cultural and historic basis and do not want to role this all up again. Go and read it again on the Kurdish Forum.
 
Last edited:
Also, how much mongoloid genetics is there in Kurdistan? The Girl here on the right looks Turkic.

6588934289_e156513eb2_z.jpg
People of R* Haplogroup generally tend to show East Eurasian affinities in their looks. If you saw me in my child age you would think I have some East Eurasian ancestry but my genetic profile only shows 1% East Eurasian genes while the average Kurd has 1-2%. Interestingly in some calculators where there is an Amerindian component I show almost no Siberian or East Asian but 2.7% Amerindian. It is true that some Turkic groups have been integrated into the Kurdish community but it didn't effect the genetics significantly.
 
Last edited:
what language did Urartians speak , anything known about that ?

Hurro_Urartians spoke a "isolated language", which could simply indiciate that they haven't figured it out yet. But it is believed to show similarities to Northeast Caucasic. And another special thing about Hurro_Urartians is that they show strong Indo_Iranian characteristics. We know that they had a strong connection to Indo_Iranian tribes.
 

This thread has been viewed 18533 times.

Back
Top