Angela
Elite member
- Messages
- 21,823
- Reaction score
- 12,329
- Points
- 113
- Ethnic group
- Italian
This isn't the first time I've read about this. Maybe there's something to it.
See:
http://arstechnica.com/science/2016...t-antibacterial-soaps-do-more-harm-than-good/
It apparently isn't that these chemicals don't kill microbes, it's that the 30 seconds that we use them isn't long enough to get the benefit, or more of a benefit than hot water and soap without the chemicals.
Also, they do have their downsides, besides just taking in more chemicals.
"There are specific circumstances in which those antimicrobials can be useful, civil engineer Patrick McNamara of Marquette University in Milwaukee told Ars. Triclosan, for instance, may be useful to doctors scrubbing for minutes at a time before a surgery or for hospital patients who can’t necessarily scrub with soap but could soak in a chemical bath. Triclosan and triclocarban do kill off bacteria during long washes. But most people only clean their hands for a few seconds. “There’s evidence that there is no improvement with using soaps that have these chemicals relative to washing your hands under warm water for 30 seconds with soaps without these chemicals,” he said."
"A 2014 study led by microbiologist Blaise Boles of the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor tested 90 adults and found that 41 percent (37 people) had triclosan-laced boogers. Antimicrobial-snot paradoxically doubles your odds of having the potentially-infectious Staphylococcus aureus bacteria up your nose.In rats exposed to triclosan, Dr. Boles and his colleagues found that triclosan exposure made it more difficult, not less, for the rodents to fend off Staph invasions. Triclosan seems to make the bacteria “stickier”—better able to adhere to proteins and surfaces. That stickiness could be why Staph is so good at hunkering down in the schnoz, setting the stage for future infections.
Other researchers have been looking at how triclosan and other antimicrobials may alter microbial communities further down from the nose—in the gut.
Microbiologist Thomas Sharpton of Oregon State University and his colleagues are currently studying triclosan’s effect on the gut microbiomes of zebrafish, a model organism for vertebrate development. Their preliminary data suggest that the antimicrobial causes swift, sweeping changes in the zebrafish gut microbiome, altering both diversity and community structure."
I've been a habitual user of those hand sanitizers they sell, mostly for when I'm out. Using hand rails etc. etc. when using public transportation, or even using public bathrooms skeeves me out, but I guess it's time to go cold turkey and throw it out.
See:
http://arstechnica.com/science/2016...t-antibacterial-soaps-do-more-harm-than-good/
It apparently isn't that these chemicals don't kill microbes, it's that the 30 seconds that we use them isn't long enough to get the benefit, or more of a benefit than hot water and soap without the chemicals.
Also, they do have their downsides, besides just taking in more chemicals.
"There are specific circumstances in which those antimicrobials can be useful, civil engineer Patrick McNamara of Marquette University in Milwaukee told Ars. Triclosan, for instance, may be useful to doctors scrubbing for minutes at a time before a surgery or for hospital patients who can’t necessarily scrub with soap but could soak in a chemical bath. Triclosan and triclocarban do kill off bacteria during long washes. But most people only clean their hands for a few seconds. “There’s evidence that there is no improvement with using soaps that have these chemicals relative to washing your hands under warm water for 30 seconds with soaps without these chemicals,” he said."
"A 2014 study led by microbiologist Blaise Boles of the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor tested 90 adults and found that 41 percent (37 people) had triclosan-laced boogers. Antimicrobial-snot paradoxically doubles your odds of having the potentially-infectious Staphylococcus aureus bacteria up your nose.In rats exposed to triclosan, Dr. Boles and his colleagues found that triclosan exposure made it more difficult, not less, for the rodents to fend off Staph invasions. Triclosan seems to make the bacteria “stickier”—better able to adhere to proteins and surfaces. That stickiness could be why Staph is so good at hunkering down in the schnoz, setting the stage for future infections.
Other researchers have been looking at how triclosan and other antimicrobials may alter microbial communities further down from the nose—in the gut.
Microbiologist Thomas Sharpton of Oregon State University and his colleagues are currently studying triclosan’s effect on the gut microbiomes of zebrafish, a model organism for vertebrate development. Their preliminary data suggest that the antimicrobial causes swift, sweeping changes in the zebrafish gut microbiome, altering both diversity and community structure."
I've been a habitual user of those hand sanitizers they sell, mostly for when I'm out. Using hand rails etc. etc. when using public transportation, or even using public bathrooms skeeves me out, but I guess it's time to go cold turkey and throw it out.