Recent content by Bosniak

So.. what conclusions can we draw from that study? According to that presentation the tribes Autariatae and Delmatae are mostly of I1b genetic. Is it correct to say that the Bosnians and Dalmatians are the descedents of those tribes?

Well, believe me when I say it. There is no doubt that I would go back to my country of origin which is Bosnia. But the problem is that non-Muslims (which is in this case the Catholic Croats and Orthodox Serbs, then also Greeks and others) tried to not only destroy my country, but they also...

Okay. But am not sure if I got you right. Did you mean the hapolgroup I2a1b is Illyrian when you said I2a2b or did you mean that the I2a2b is a seperate one?

What makes you think that the Illyrians were genetically celtic (R1b) ?

Sandzak has never been Albanian. The Muslim population of Sandzak are definitely of Bosniak roots. Sure I don't deny that there lived some Albanians but they were not in majority. I have Bosniak friends who are from Kosovo and they can speak Albanian perfectly but they are way more Bosniak...

When I say pre-Slavic I mean that they settled in the [Balkan] before Slavs. But okay. I don't agree with you totally but am willing to hear yours, and of course others theories. And I say theories because non of us can really say that it's either this way or that way. I just read that...

So you think that the I2a1b is a pre-Slavic haplogroup in Balkan?

Wouldn't Illyrian R1b genes then become the dominant one until the arrival of the Slavs? I mean I know there is a theory about Illyrianization but that happend before their arravial in the west Balkan. But after 1300 years the R1b gene would be probably much higher then the E-V13. And logically...

No, not the one you must be thinking on. Am not sure if I did understood you. What do you mean "Illyrians genes survived under the form of E-V13" ? Do you mean that the Illyrian genes are E-v13?

I do, because if the Illyrian genes would be R1b then logically it would be the second highest genetic among Bosnians. But it isn't, it barely exist in Bosnia. What doesn't make any sense is how could J2 and E-V13 (which is aboriginal) higher then the Illyrian genes when we know that the...

That is a good theory because both Illyrians and Celts came from Hallstatt culture, the Celts lived in the west and Illyrians in the east. But your theory dosen't make any sense and that's because of the low R1b % within Bosnia which is only 4%. Even the E-V13(14,5%) and J2(6%) is heigher in...

This is going to be intressting. So according to you what genetics did the Illyrians belong to?

What is your proof for that?

When we are talking about the Balkans and invading Slavs from 6-8 century, then yes haplogroup I2a1b is pre-Slavic.

Exuse me? Dalmatians are Croats? According to who? You? ( Genetically speaking ) According to the I genetic map the highest I2a1b is in Bosnia and Dalmatia. Dalmatians thanks to their 50+ I2a1b % are genetically closer to the Catholic & Muslim Bosnians then to the Croatians. If we take...