Eupedia Forums
Site NavigationEupedia Top > Eupedia Forum & Japan Forum

Search:

Type: Posts; User: spruithean

Page 1 of 14 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.01 seconds.

  1. Ugh. The constant attempts to convince people...

    Ugh. The constant attempts to convince people that his theory has any merit is so mind-numbing. I see in many of his "answers" he blatantly cherry-picks or ignores certain data to fit his nonsense....
  2. You're serious? Thankfully, anyone worth their...

    You're serious?

    Thankfully, anyone worth their salt will see his theory is simply his own wishful thinking and complete hogwash.
  3. It's possible it existed at one point but like...

    It's possible it existed at one point but like many lineages that have ever existed it died out. This probably applies to every haplogroup at some point.
  4. Exactly. It just feels like the OP of this...

    Exactly.

    It just feels like the OP of this thread is continuing down the path of his preferred pet theory. I would love to see some legitimate peer review process of the articles in the original...
  5. But the real question is, where is the legitimate...

    But the real question is, where is the legitimate evidence of his theory? I've not seen any corroborating activity of others discussing "Linear Elamite" or as OP calls it, "Linear Gutian". Where is...
  6. Those words you cite are merely similar in...

    Those words you cite are merely similar in "spelling" and are not a strong argument in your favour.
    Unfortunately I cannot read Persian and I feel a large amount of potential review of your work by...
  7. Sure, that's the important thing to most...

    Sure, that's the important thing to most historians, but misrepresenting genetic data to try and support ones theory is just bad practice. The Goths and Gutians are most certainly different people. I...
  8. I'm referring to your citation of the artifacts...

    I'm referring to your citation of the artifacts from Luristan and the perceived similarity to artifacts found in Scandinavia. You still haven't confirmed any connection between Gutians and Goths, and...
  9. You are still using the same sources which were...

    You are still using the same sources which were proved to be nonsense to you on not only this forum but elsewhere as well. This just screams of academic dishonesty. Where is your actual evidence....
  10. It is unlikely that they all came as full tribes...

    It is unlikely that they all came as full tribes to the entirety of England. The history of this period is much more complex than you seem to be making it out to be.
  11. The difference is not that pronounced, all...

    The difference is not that pronounced, all British Isles populations share some common ancestry.

    FYI Normans are not Vikings. Not even close. Part of Normandy saw Scandinavian settlement, but...
  12. So he's still pushing the same hogwash. Using the...

    So he's still pushing the same hogwash. Using the same outdated sources and the same mental gymnastics to prove a bizarre theory.

    Still with complete misrepresentation of current scientific work...
  13. I had a feeling just reading the title of this...

    I had a feeling just reading the title of this thread.
  14. Replies
    19
    Views
    1,601

    It's a good find, and certainly a good sign for...

    It's a good find, and certainly a good sign for several origin theories of modern I1. It's taken a long time to find a relevant I1 in the Scandinavian Late Neolithic/Nordic Bronze Age range. Whether...
  15. Not really. That is something far more dynamic...

    Not really. That is something far more dynamic than haplogroups IMO. If you are referring to specific family groups being determined through Y-DNA then sure, this has been shown in many surname DNA...
  16. Replies
    19
    Views
    1,601

    Some users from Anthrogenica have analyzed the...

    Some users from Anthrogenica have analyzed the BAMs of these specific samples and these are the results:


    ...
  17. Replies
    8
    Views
    700

    Z93 did not directly originate in M513, M513 is...

    Z93 did not directly originate in M513, M513 is phyloequivalent to L62, L63, L120, M420, M449, M511 all of which define R1a. R-Z93 is downstream of Z645 which is downstream of M417 which is...
  18. Replies
    8
    Views
    700

    R-Z93 is downstream of R-M459>M198>M417>Z645, ...

    R-Z93 is downstream of R-M459>M198>M417>Z645,

    The quote you provided says "mutations understood to be equivalent to M420" which in other words they are phyloequivalent; meaning they define this...
  19. Replies
    59
    Views
    3,340

    So why do we find seaxes in Anglo-Saxon graves...

    So why do we find seaxes in Anglo-Saxon graves within England? Why do we find seaxes among related Germanic people (Longobards - who had Saxon contact and brought Saxons to Italy with them), Franks...
  20. Replies
    2
    Views
    380

    Perhaps you descend from Varangians or Normans?

    Perhaps you descend from Varangians or Normans?
  21. Replies
    5
    Views
    661

    The Viking DNA paper found an individual who...

    The Viking DNA paper found an individual who belongs to I-M227:

    "VK50 Gotland_Kopparsvik-53.64 was reported I1a1a1a1a (corresponds to I-M227) in preprint"

    VK50 is an individual from a Viking...
  22. Replies
    56
    Views
    4,997

    I have read them, and they are not evidence. They...

    I have read them, and they are not evidence. They are coincidental, if vaguely similar orthographies for words or terms in different languages. Show me concrete verifiable evidence with supporting...
  23. Replies
    7
    Views
    596

    YFull estimates that IJ formed 47,200 years ago...

    YFull estimates that IJ formed 47,200 years ago and the TMRCA (time to most recent ancestor for both I and J) is estimated to be 42,900 years ago: https://www.yfull.com/tree/IJ/
  24. Replies
    56
    Views
    4,997

    Provide your "hundreds of evidences" that show...

    Provide your "hundreds of evidences" that show they were Germanic (I've requested this a lot).

    Your Russian map appears to be based on the Anatolian hypothesis.
  25. Replies
    1,776
    Views
    212,141

    This exactly.

    This exactly.
Results 1 to 25 of 349
Page 1 of 14 1 2 3 4