Eupedia Forums
Site NavigationEupedia Top > Eupedia Forum & Japan Forum

Search:

Type: Posts; User: Aspar

Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.01 seconds.

  1. Replies
    58
    Views
    2,991

    Yes, I am aware of the similarities between...

    Yes, I am aware of the similarities between Albanian and Aromanian. Also as I said already "Dada" and "Ghiush" means Grandmother and Grandfather in Aromanian language. This coupled with the Aromanian...
  2. Replies
    58
    Views
    2,991

    I generally agree with you but I need to give...

    I generally agree with you but I need to give some clarification about some things in your post since you mentioned me indirectly in your post and also about this "serb" guy!

    First, neither me nor...
  3. I think there are many wrong conclusions made out...

    I think there are many wrong conclusions made out in this paper...

    First of all, at first I was happy and thought there will be some new ancient and medieval Balkan samples but there were none and...
  4. Thread: Macedonians

    by Aspar
    Replies
    1,031
    Views
    385,708

    There is no consensus among the historians what...

    There is no consensus among the historians what does the name Makedon mean although many tend to connect everything to Greek...
    Makedon may very well come and be distorted version of the word...
  5. Thread: Macedonians

    by Aspar
    Replies
    1,031
    Views
    385,708

    I have no problem calling an Albanian bro trust...

    I have no problem calling an Albanian bro trust me and I mean it...

    I have met many Albanians and most of them are very loyal and trustworthy and can easily make a business with them without...
  6. Thread: Macedonians

    by Aspar
    Replies
    1,031
    Views
    385,708

    https://i.postimg.cc/ncjgBhZx/Macedonia-ad400.png...

    https://i.postimg.cc/ncjgBhZx/Macedonia-ad400.png

    This is Roman Macedonia 400 AD and by the looks of the map, more than a half of today's North Macedonia belongs to it, mostly in Macedonia...
  7. Thread: Macedonians

    by Aspar
    Replies
    1,031
    Views
    385,708

    I am not willing replying to everything you wrote...

    I am not willing replying to everything you wrote because some of it is a pure propaganda and non important things which have nothing to do with what i wrote previously.



    Well, this is your...
  8. Thread: Macedonians

    by Aspar
    Replies
    1,031
    Views
    385,708

    Any sources for the bolded part? Because from...

    Any sources for the bolded part?

    Because from what I have read from ancient writers, the ancient Macedonians were described as descendants of Brygians, Bryges(Thracians) as per Herodotus...
    ...
  9. Thread: Macedonians

    by Aspar
    Replies
    1,031
    Views
    385,708

    Most Macedonians today have some ancestry from...

    Most Macedonians today have some ancestry from Makedonia which is now in Greece so I don't get what you mean by having a real Makedonian blood or Paeonian...

    These maps represent the real...
  10. Replies
    1,386
    Views
    171,965

    Thanks for your reply! I always value your...

    Thanks for your reply!

    I always value your opinion, either here or on other forums, you seem like a reasonable and smart poster!
    You also got my point which the other users and "experts" failed...
  11. Replies
    1,386
    Views
    171,965

    Why is that when someone who is from a Balkan...

    Why is that when someone who is from a Balkan ethnic background which I already understand isn't very preferable on this forum, gives his view about something, in this case the Peloponnesian paper...
  12. Thread: Macedonians

    by Aspar
    Replies
    1,031
    Views
    385,708

    If the ancient Macedonians were Hellenized, than...

    If the ancient Macedonians were Hellenized, than there is no point of discussing whether they were originally Greeks or not since they became Greeks and were spreading Hellenism!

    Why is that some...
  13. Replies
    1,386
    Views
    171,965

    "There's nothing wrong or shameful in being...

    "There's nothing wrong or shameful in being ignorant of a topic. Everyone is ignorant until they learn, but when there is no attempt to learn the topic, and moreover, ignorant opinions are arrogantly...
  14. Replies
    1,386
    Views
    171,965

    Your arrogance is amazing. Clearly your on...

    Your arrogance is amazing.
    Clearly your on something...
    You still don't get the point, I know that modern Europeans own much of their ancestry to EEF.
    My point is that Mycenaeans are derived from...
  15. Replies
    1,386
    Views
    171,965

    The other issue with Lazaridis paper is that he...

    The other issue with Lazaridis paper is that he leaves space for two different scenarios of Mycenaeans ancestry.
    One is mix between Anatolian Neolithic with Armenian Chalcolithic to Bronze age...
  16. Replies
    1,386
    Views
    171,965

    @post 1248 I don't understand your aggressive...

    @post 1248

    I don't understand your aggressive stance, I have only criticized the approach of the scientists.
    And no, I didn't confuse anything, my first reply was towards another user, who quoted...
  17. Replies
    1,386
    Views
    171,965

    @ post 1245 You seem to have missed my point...

    @ post 1245

    You seem to have missed my point about the conclusion of Lazaridis that modern Greeks are Mycenaean descendants because of around 70% similarity with the Mycenaeans based on imaginary...
  18. Replies
    1,386
    Views
    171,965

    I am afraid that this study is a failure since it...

    I am afraid that this study is a failure since it compares the modern Greeks with populations such as Belorussians, Polish, Ukrainians and Russians to determine how much "ancient Greek" or "Slavic"...
  19. I agree with this... If the Magyar elite could...

    I agree with this...
    If the Magyar elite could have belong to a branch of I-L621, I don't see a reason why the Bulgars wouldn't have been the initiators of this branch in the Balkans.
    There is a...
  20. From the actual study:...

    From the actual study: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/biorxiv/early/2019/04/03/597997.full.pdf



    https://i.postimg.cc/VNqV57tW/L621.png

    As you can see, the elites are I2a-L621 and R1a so the...
  21. The elites were not positive for S17250 as only...

    The elites were not positive for S17250 as only this branch was tested.
    All other branches are dominated by Slavic speakers but Y18331 only which is dominated by Greeks.
    Plus by the time of these...
  22. Indeed, those Magyar conquerors were from the end...

    Indeed, those Magyar conquerors were from the end of the 9th century if I am not mistaken and the whole I2a-Dinaric has a TMRCA of 2200 years if we follow YFULL estimate.
    Therefore, the TMRCA of...
  23. His theory about the Slavs migrating to the...

    His theory about the Slavs migrating to the Balkans in the Medieval been predominantly E-V13 while no mentioning of R1a or I2a1 at all is also very weird...
  24. Thread: Macedonians

    by Aspar
    Replies
    1,031
    Views
    385,708

    I know it's off topic but I have seen some Greeks...

    I know it's off topic but I have seen some Greeks with y-dna R1a-Z93 on some of these forums...
    One of the deep branches I've seen is R-F2935, https://www.yfull.com/tree/R-F2935/
    This is too old to...
  25. Replies
    396
    Views
    33,585

    According to this site:...

    According to this site: https://phylogeographer.com/snp-lookup/
    The migration path of SNP Z17107:

    https://i.postimg.cc/MGTbxx2y/Z17107.png

    According the man who designed this program, he used...
Results 1 to 25 of 103
Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4