Eupedia Forums
Site NavigationEupedia Top > Eupedia Forum & Japan Forum

Search:

Type: Posts; User: Northener

Page 1 of 26 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.01 seconds.

  1. Right agree. But when fantasy replaces...

    Right agree. But when fantasy replaces facts.....theory must have a fundament nornosh.


    Sent from my iPad using Eupedia Forum
  2. It was a greeting with a smiley, because I do...

    It was a greeting with a smiley, because I do believe in a gradual development and mixtures but not in whatsoever tribe that brought in a fullgrown ‘Germanic culture’ package that migrated from west...
  3. Ok than greetings to my distant cousin[emoji1309]...

    Ok than greetings to my distant cousin[emoji1309]


    Sent from my iPad using Eupedia Forum
  4. Yes and Spruithean an I partly originated in...

    Yes and Spruithean an I partly originated in exact the same region are in reality hugginn and muginn....they bring the news from the Germanic world ;)
  5. You certainly live in another paradigm than...

    You certainly live in another paradigm than Spruithean or I do. The development of the Germanic language (like Celtic or Slavic) was a gradual development out of in the `german case the TRB and...
  6. First of all the Germans were not 'newborn' in...

    First of all the Germans were not 'newborn' in the iron age/Jastorf. They didn't fall out of space. The 'original' Germans genetic roots lay in the Bronze Age. So did the Germans of the European...
  7. I don't know what's going on here, but this all...

    I don't know what's going on here, but this all makes no sense. No plausible story based on what these gentleman put forward.
    Reasonable replies from for example Spruithaen are replied with another...
  8. @Cyrus your initial question was this: IMO...

    @Cyrus your initial question was this:



    IMO the (Proto) Germanic origin lasy in the Nordic LN-BA. Germanic people of the iron age are a product of a mixture between Funnelbeakers (TRB/ I-M253...
  9. Replies
    26
    Views
    13,883

    I also get often Scandic results. This is IMO the...

    I also get often Scandic results. This is IMO the explanation.

    I think Davidski/Eurogenes has made this clear. Recently he showed that there is some kind of continuity in the Nordic genetic...
  10. @Cyrus reminds me of Huup Huup Barbatruc..... ...

    @Cyrus reminds me of Huup Huup Barbatruc.....

    When i was a child there was some kind of cartoon in which creatures turned into another shape....before that they shouted huup huup barba truc...
  11. and here.... ...

    and here....

    https://www.mupload.nl/img/62q67vo863v.10.25.png

    so you theory is thin air.....
  12. there.... ;) ...

    there.... ;)

    https://www.mupload.nl/img/lh3qa7i.03.09.png
  13. Very distant cousins, very different branches. So...

    Very distant cousins, very different branches. So no direct connection Iran and Germanic.


    Sent from my iPad using Eupedia Forum
  14. Corded Ware. ...

    Corded Ware.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corded_Ware_culture
  15. What does genetics say about the origin of Germanic people?

    Cyrus, I think there is some common ground in mythology and some distant genetic relationship. That’s all. Tribes that bring direct the Germanic culture to NW Europe from Iran is a fairy tale.

    But...
  16. And as if there are no sources, no records, no...

    And as if there are no sources, no records, no books of that period, everyone can project it's own pet theory on it. Of course there will be some or more than some Indo-European influences, but that...
  17. You talk about language but your 'evidence' is...

    You talk about language but your 'evidence' is mythology. As said there is some Indo-European mythological (and genetic) connection. But loose not 1:1 as you seem to suppose.

    Germanic (just like...
  18. When you want to look at the Indo-European...

    When you want to look at the Indo-European component in the Germanic culture initially brought in by Corded Ware (Single Grave Culture) people than Davidski has made this connection....not exactly...
  19. What does genetics say about the origin of Germanic people?

    Looks nonsens to me. The Germanic culture was not ready made imported from Iran.
    It evolved in the first place, like for the most parts of Europe, out of HG, EEF and Steppe pastoralist. In the...
  20. So in fact I'm an Iranian in disguise?

    So in fact I'm an Iranian in disguise?
  21. There could indeed be a certain Hallstatt...

    There could indeed be a certain Hallstatt influence, but I'm of North Dutch descent and I plot right into the Nordic LNBA cluster. There was some Saxon influx (Jastorf-heirs) but they didn't replace...
  22. Read this blog of Davidski, it's very clear that...

    Read this blog of Davidski, it's very clear that the genetic profile of Nordic Bronze (LNBA) is basically the cluster (=origin) that formed the Germans of the Iron Age and later.
    ...
  23. Replies
    5
    Views
    2,490

    I have responded your PM!!! Did you get it?

    I have responded your PM!!! Did you get it?
  24. Replies
    5
    Views
    2,490

    Only passive! you can drop a line in PM....

    Only passive! you can drop a line in PM....
  25. Replies
    2
    Views
    354

    Thanks for the advice Ygorcs! The idea is that...

    Thanks for the advice Ygorcs!

    The idea is that TRB is originated in the SW Baltics, the oldest traces are found in Sarnowo, NE Poland.

    And taken your advice in account Narva Estonia stays...
Results 1 to 25 of 632
Page 1 of 26 1 2 3 4