Eupedia Forums
Site NavigationEupedia Top > Eupedia Forum & Japan Forum

Search:

Type: Posts; User: bicicleur 2

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.01 seconds.

  1. I think the origin of Semitic is interesting as...

    I think the origin of Semitic is interesting as well.

    It is an Afroasiatic language, which associated with Natufian Levant in origin,
    but semitic itself is associated with CHG/Iran Neo and haplo...
  2. indeed, it has been told before : Dzudzuana =...

    indeed, it has been told before : Dzudzuana = pré-WHG (Villabruna) + Basal Eurasian
    and CHG = Dzudzuana + ANE, while EHG is on a cline between CHG and ANE
    ...
  3. I'm not convinced by the video you post on...

    I'm not convinced by the video you post on semitic.
    Their proto-semitic is projected on the fact that first semitic writing was attested in northern Levant
    But proto-semitic could as well have...
  4. neolithic greece is all anatolian neolithic ...

    neolithic greece is all anatolian neolithic

    the Cycladic is shifted toward CHG
    my interpretation is an arrival of CHG males who take local wives when arriving in the Aegean or maybe already...
  5. I guess the 8,5 ka gradient is about the...

    I guess the 8,5 ka gradient is about the Tepecik-Ciftlik obsidian trade.
    The Semitic expansion is probably associated with bronze.
    I see EBA Cycladic is dated 5,2 ka. Could Minoans have spoken a...
  6. ok, interesting, can you give a link to the...

    ok, interesting, can you give a link to the papers where thes were published?
    which was the Allentoft paper? the one on the Lech Valley?
  7. when would these neolithic migrations from...

    when would these neolithic migrations from Iberia/Southern France have happened?
    the thing is neolithic Sardegna, Iberia and S France were quite similar autosomal, so you need uniparentals to detect...
  8. Did the original story specify Mount Ararat, or...

    Did the original story specify Mount Ararat, or is this a consensus amongst later 'researchers'?

    I think the EBA dispersion of CHG and hap J was from Kura-Araxes area after the collapse of the...
  9. what DNA do we have from Unetice? we have Y-DNA...

    what DNA do we have from Unetice?
    we have Y-DNA I2 but not R1b-P312
    I suspect they had some steppe DNA like Bell Beakers, but do we have autosomal Unetice?

    my guess is that R1b-P312 expanded...
  10. obviuosly, this is all you have to conclude there...

    obviuosly, this is all you have to conclude there was a violent invasion massive enough to create large destructions, and they were probably accompanied with diseases from the steppe
    without them...
  11. the papers don't provide any proof, not even a...

    the papers don't provide any proof, not even a claim

    they say the destructions are traditionaly associated with invading steppe people

    they don't endorse this claim themselves

    and nothing...
  12. maybe we should stick to the facts of the thread...

    maybe we should stick to the facts of the thread and stop phantasising about those brute herders from the steppe with all kinds of diseases

    you're highjacking the thread
  13. traditionally associated with : meaning : we have...

    traditionally associated with : meaning : we have no proof but people like you always blaim the steppe people

    do you have more details : when exactly and in what parts of Greece did the...
  14. first of all you're twisting my words and...

    first of all you're twisting my words and changing the subject, this way can go on and on and on

    second you told just 1 or 2 days ago that everyone within the whole Roman empire was a Roman
    and...
  15. I think you're right. The ability to learn from...

    I think you're right.
    The ability to learn from others and adapt.
    Otherwise they couldn't survive.
    They did more than just survive.
  16. What has Rome to do with the subject? I ask you...

    What has Rome to do with the subject?
    I ask you to substantiate your claim about destruction of EBA Greece by invading steppe people, probably accompanied by diseases?
    You say I'm embarrasing...
  17. you don't answer the question

    you don't answer the question
  18. Well, well Angela, all this because I questioned...

    Well, well Angela, all this because I questioned your claim :
    ...
  19. My dear Angela, I can't prove you wrong. Because...

    My dear Angela, I can't prove you wrong.
    Because in your mind the steppe and Nordic people are the plague in person.
    Your aversion is so strong, you can't keep it for yourself.
    From time to time I...
  20. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/335367505...

    https://www.researchgate.net/publication/335367505_Neolithic_population_crash_in_northwest_Europe_associated_with_agricultural_crisis
    ...
  21. history is not a straight line and often it makes...

    history is not a straight line and often it makes a strange turn
    we're the result of many events and mixtures and we should get rid of stereotypes
    more than 99 % of the human DNA is the same...
  22. you mention David Anthony yes the IE did have a...

    you mention David Anthony
    yes the IE did have a warrior culture
    but maybe you should reread the last chapters
    how the BMAC cities lost their influence
    no destruction, the BMAC elite remained in...
  23. when there is environmental stress it comes down...

    when there is environmental stress it comes down to survival of the fittest
    not only on the steppe, it is like this worldwide
    the palatial dynasties were just not fit enough, just like the...
  24. My dear Angela, where did I say they were...

    My dear Angela,
    where did I say they were peaceful?
    I merely pointed out some circumstances which may have triggered the EBA-MBA transition and you accuse me of being biased.
    I obviously said...
  25. Replies
    877
    Views
    168,548

    the origin of the urnfield is not northern...

    the origin of the urnfield is not northern europe, the carpathian basin is more likely
Results 1 to 25 of 91
Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4