Eupedia Forums
Site NavigationEupedia Top > Eupedia Forum & Japan Forum

Search:

Type: Posts; User: mount123

Page 1 of 25 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.02 seconds.

  1. Replies
    107
    Views
    11,409

    Well, I get your point and certainly agree since...

    Well, I get your point and certainly agree since that is what the data suggests.

    In regards to Gashi they indeed are diverse and I think with such a group more sampling is needed. I know quite a...
  2. Replies
    3,156
    Views
    215,566

    There are puppet accounts out here really arguing...

    There are puppet accounts out here really arguing that "Zlatan" (interesting name dear "entertain") is a genuine account. Repetitive posts with the same rhetoric from multiple puppet accounts are not...
  3. Replies
    107
    Views
    11,409

    Great to see someone with actual knowledge of...

    Great to see someone with actual knowledge of Albanian tribes (also not blending out the Hoti, Kastrati and Korbi). Albeit, I would make a clear difference in the Gashi since a great part of them in...
  4. Replies
    3,156
    Views
    215,566

    Illyrian IA Glasinac-Mati is one of the major...

    Illyrian IA Glasinac-Mati is one of the major archeological complexes in the territory of Dardania (be it under Roman or Pre-Roman set borders) and I have never seen any academic opposing that....
  5. Replies
    1,733
    Views
    282,272

    There is another basal J2b-L283 Hungarian on...

    There is another basal J2b-L283 Hungarian on YFull id:YF109411 from Fejér.
  6. Replies
    3,156
    Views
    215,566

    By saying „the main and defining paternal line“...

    By saying „the main and defining paternal line“ one does not exclude other paternal lines also being present at low frequencies. The importance of the wording „main and defining“ is that J2b-L283 has...
  7. Replies
    3,156
    Views
    215,566

    There is a fundamental problem I have observed in...

    There is a fundamental problem I have observed in repetitive slogans made by certain users on this and other fora in regards to Albanian or Balkan aDNA related threads:

    The statistics of the...
  8. Replies
    3,156
    Views
    215,566

    That is what most linguists argue about the...

    That is what most linguists argue about the origin of Albanian. They don't argue it is Illyrian or Thracian descended. As I have repeated to some stubborn people who try to apply their modern ethnic...
  9. Replies
    3,156
    Views
    215,566

    Modern Albanians stem from more than one ancient...

    Modern Albanians stem from more than one ancient Balkan group. The Illyrian case is clear cut: Proto-Illyrian EBA (and onwards) Cetina/Dinaric and their successors IA Illyrians, E1b-V13 cannot be...
  10. Replies
    3,156
    Views
    215,566

    The terminology was fabricated during Napoleon's...

    The terminology was fabricated during Napoleon's reign. These are Slavic inhabited vassal states of Napoleonian France. It does not have anything to do with the ancient population of Illyria since...
  11. Zurla is an Ottoman-Persian instrument and...

    Zurla is an Ottoman-Persian instrument and Prizren as a region has insignificant to no J2b-L283 at all, it is mostly R1b-Z2103 and E1b-V13. Not to forget all of the Tallava-Balkan Romany influence in...
  12. Replies
    3,156
    Views
    215,566

    That is not true. And also Shkrel (Shkodra),...

    That is not true. And also Shkrel (Shkodra), Albania, where we got that ID I8471 J2b-L283>>Z615>Z597 (Z609+, Z628+, FT92472-, Z40053-, CTS12554-) dated at ~1788 BCE guy from. The archeological...
  13. Replies
    3,156
    Views
    215,566

    Considering the high number of...

    Considering the high number of Proto-Illyrian/Illyrian samples we have the "theory" that E1b majorly spread with Illyrians or somehow was a major Illyrian haplogroup is totally debunked. No serious...
  14. Replies
    52
    Views
    3,469

    They essentially want to apply their modern...

    They essentially want to apply their modern ethnic identity to one ancient group and want, for all those part of that modern ethnic identity, to stem from that one particular ancient group. It is...
  15. Replies
    3,156
    Views
    215,566

    Using flawed tools such as G25 and quoting...

    Using flawed tools such as G25 and quoting Wikipedia amateur edits is not "proving" anything. That Hungarian sample on a PCA plots far to the East and South from the actual Illyrian core. Why not use...
  16. Replies
    3,156
    Views
    215,566

    FYI: the non radiocarbon dating is not just...

    FYI: the non radiocarbon dating is not just restricted on male samples but also female ones. Apart from seeing amateurs using flawed tools such a G25 and based on that making conclusions, all of the...
  17. Replies
    3,156
    Views
    215,566

    Hence why Pannonians and alike should not be...

    Hence why Pannonians and alike should not be equated with Illyrians in the first place. And I think you have made very clear with your wording that Elena Kocaqi is a pseudo scientist, unlike a...
  18. Replies
    3,156
    Views
    215,566

    Agreed. Apart from the many new ancient samples...

    Agreed. Apart from the many new ancient samples we got from the Reich affiliated papers all of them should have been radiocarbon dated. This is a no go especially coming from people who are putting...
  19. Replies
    3,156
    Views
    215,566

    He is basing it on Katicic and I think given the...

    He is basing it on Katicic and I think given the archeological and genetic landscape that it does not make sense, albeit not entirely. The proposed SE Dalmatian anthroponymy map is a clear...
  20. Replies
    3,156
    Views
    215,566

    That is a distribution proposal of supposedly...

    That is a distribution proposal of supposedly South East Illyrian (SE Dalmatian) anthroponymy based on the reference Matzinger made in the description. Central/Southern Albania was Bryges territory...
  21. Replies
    3,156
    Views
    215,566

    His proposal of a fusion of "proto-Messapians"...

    His proposal of a fusion of "proto-Messapians" and Cetina would need further archaeogenetic attestation, albeit there is evidence at least for a small scale fusion of Illyrians and Paeonians to the...
  22. Pointed this out in post #15 of mine and also...

    Pointed this out in post #15 of mine and also more precisely that 10,000 year old Mesolithic Northern Caucasus sample is Z2453 and that haplogroup is very very rare. And most importantly it is not...
  23. Replies
    52
    Views
    3,469

    Bruzmi is an internet persona with a non academic...

    Bruzmi is an internet persona with a non academic background and all of his posts are narrative based, he is playing a role. He edits as "Maleschreiber" in Wikipedia absolutely pathetic behavior. And...
  24. Replies
    3,156
    Views
    215,566

    Yep. I have some ancestry from Albanians that...

    Yep. I have some ancestry from Albanians that moved from Kotorr to Kosovo hence why I was especially thrilled about all these samples from Kotorr. And looks like there will be more from a near site...
  25. Replies
    3,156
    Views
    215,566

    Yes, the bold part especially. Also, something...

    Yes, the bold part especially. Also, something which does not really ring a bell in some: there was always mobility, trade, expansions, fusions etc. such that the presence of a certain lineage in...
Results 1 to 25 of 604
Page 1 of 25 1 2 3 4