Illyrians were on a cline from IA Croatia to IA Albania. The distance is much smaller than the distances observed in smaller regions. A part of IA North Macedonia overlaps with IA Albania which is...
Forum | Europe Travel Guide | Ecology | Facts & Trivia | Genetics | History | Linguistics |
Austria | France | Germany | Ireland | Italy | Portugal | Spain | Switzerland |
![]() |
Type: Posts; User: Excine
Illyrians were on a cline from IA Croatia to IA Albania. The distance is much smaller than the distances observed in smaller regions. A part of IA North Macedonia overlaps with IA Albania which is...
I'm not sure that you understand how south of northern Illyrians, Mycenaeans are. Mycenaeans are to "the south" of Illyrians in the same sense that .... BA Cypriots are to the south of northern...
https://i.ibb.co/Gd85VJW/pca2.png
As everyone can see on any PCA, the position of southern Illyrians which will be just south of northern Illyrians from IA Croatia is not even remotely close to...
Albanians don't need any BGR_IA source. We already saw in the study about Serbia that the closest IA population to Albanians is IA Albania, not the Aegean-shifted or even 100% Aegean BGR_IA cluster....
It's truly incredible how medieval and modern toponyms which obviously exist in eastern Serbia and northwestern Bulgaria because of Vlachs and maybe Albanians who moved there in the late medieval and...
Ngl I scoffed a bit, kinda true hahaha
A lot more users are being able to gain access, us who don't, should have access soon as well.
Maybe servers are down for a few regions, perhaps an update? Who knows,
A lot of important threads in AG, I hope it can be recovered or come back up ASAP.
Makes sense, from what I can remember, it's been down for nearly 24 hours. I hope it comes back up soon, or atleast make an announcement somewhere about it's website status.
I believe in that region or near by lived a large amount of Vlachs
It's still down for me, very strange. @Riverman, are you able to use AG? I'm in US, maybe that's why.
It's still down for me.
It's down, same here.
Indeed, the paper itself discusses the relationship of other IE languages and Albanian, it's not of course the end all be all of the origin of the Albanian language, but gives an interesting insight...
It's not me who just thinks Albanian is apart of the Illyric branch, the same view is going to be shown by Hyllested and Joseph once the paper comes out.
To suppress what? You're the one who's taking Matzinger out of context. Matzinger says that Albanian doesn't have a linear origin from Illyrian and that they are two independent languages. He doesn't...
It's increasingly obvious that Johane Derite / Alb History (the one who cried wolf on anthrogenica) is throwing yet again another emotional tantrum. Why? Who knows, could be a personal thing he's...
1) From page 24 of 'The Reflection of Personal and Collective Tragedies in Ancient Sources: 1. Personal Tragedies in Roman Epigraphy' published in the Journal of Ancient History and Archaeology...
What bothers mount123 is that he's not making the absurd claim that Proto-Illyrians were just J-L283. That's the problem for mount123 and that's why he launches these weird comments. For mount123...
If E-V13 shows up among Iapygians, then it means that E-V13 was present in Proto-Illyrians and Illyrians either in Cetina or in Glasinac-Mati. It also means that there's no way that E-V13 became...
Read again:
Matzinger dates the specific Proto-Albanian language or "dialect" around 1000-800 BCE and Adam & Hyllested (2022) place Albanian and Messapic under an Illyric branch.
Albanian...
Samples will, hopefully be coming much sooner than that. I wouldn't bother to even check this forum in 2 years. Maybe take your own advice and take it easy on the poorly hidden insults :)
More manipulation.
You posted a source which says nothing Gava migrations in Albania or Kosova. It's blatant misinformation.
Its author clearly says that Gava pottery even in the areas...
I asked him for a source and because no such source exists he posted an irrelevant one and threw in an insult for good measure.
The source which he posted says nothing at all about Gava culture...