Search:

"t appears that the world of the 4th millennium BC was well-connected long before the major expansion of steppe pastoralist and related groups. In this wide-ranging network of contacts, people not...

Not a good time to play hero and come to the rescue.... Grow up.

Fair enough.
However this image does not make 6900 BP any centrality... but it answers the date figure itself and not 5000BC I give you that. its important to note he published 20 dates, as an...

Yes, that I truly think there is kindof an embargo. Even Wang et al was from 4500BC, weird how Neolithic South Caucasus and extensive 4500BC-3900bC south balkans are being saved for "later" papers....

Indeed. Very precise date. And on top of it, the hypothesis of a south Caucasus migration to Steppe by these dates is called the Iain Mathieson 2018 hypothesis, the same Mathieson that, by the few...

the latest buzz word should really be Honey, Medhu.
University of toronto, which is working in SHulaveri and Gadrachilli, is saying they will publish something later how the shulaveri were...

you're kidding right?

- At the beginning of this thread you have a Map with dates from Johannes krauser, where he even goes as far as writing 6900 years ago instead of 7000 Years ago. Why? -...

MPI SHh is even making maps with dates... And still people "pretend not to see".
Never mind... At the right time they 'knew all along" and "have been saying it since" whatever.

:)

Angela is working her way to ban me infraction after infraction.... Where is maciamo?

Yes. I will still ignore you. Your role and intent is to provoque me in order for that other someone (s) is able to give me an infraction.

Just to make it clear how far Wang et al went in the direction of my shulaverian Hypothesis


This is in accordance with the Neolithization of the Caucasus (ie The Shulaveri-Shomu), which had...

... The published paper is full of novelties over the preprint or added explanation by the authors. however you guys just move over it as if nothing changed. Nothing to see. As long as each of you...

No subclades known?

What I am saying next is just a coincidence, ok? Not intented to mean nothing....
But that place is 13 miles from Tel Tsaf. And tel tsaf is important in the shulaverian...

I get confused, worried, and ? - Read the replies from authors to reviewers!

How they got admixed?


at least as early as by 5500BC some shulaverian were starting to pour into north Caucasus...

Yes. We are back to hordes of amazon women roaming into new lands and having babies with local men. Specially these in particular that manage to cross alone one of the most dificult mountain ranges...

What you don't have is: Caucasus NEOLITHIC - do think that is a coincidence?
The place where Shulaveri lived was a wastland for a couple centuries before you see Sioni arriving. Let alone a...

....
one of replies from the authors to reviewers...

Reply: This statement is based on the hypothesis put forward by Mathieson et al. 2018: “An alternative hypothesis is that the homeland of...

reviewer 2 is brutal...

" It’s good to point out that older Neolithic sites could be found in the northern flanks, but what you’re implying here is that Gorelik was wrong to specify a PPNB...

Those reviewers were delicious...

"Figure 2: On the right side, the color bar graphs for Yamnaya Samara and Yamnaya Kalmyk do not
show any orange color for Anatolian (or Early European) Farmer...

I love the NEW reviewers comments supplement ….


"Lines 442 and 606-608 : The abstract for this paper highlights this finding as one of the principal
discoveries of the project. The Yamnaya...

Pax,
The study keeps referring Goncalves (David) and Pires (Ana)... at the time (2016) I had just finished writing my shulaveri-Shomu hypothesis, but on Fridays my daughter was on Chemotherapy and...

Hi Pip, thank you for your questions. Very good ones really. I don’t think I have ever been asked a set of so acute and disconcerting ones in all these years.
But Remember that I have 10 slides ,...

Guys, apart from the conversation of "priesthood" (its becoming awkward....) what does it mean too early for iberia and being or not an outlier? a couple facts:


Movement of people (see Balkans...

yes, 97% are Mtdna A,B,C.

Portuguese Serra da estrela, Eastern Turkey kangal , spanish galgo and North Africa Aidi are Mtdna HG D...

this is what I was writting in 2015 to Maju....
"II nquire...

ToBeOrNotToBe

A concise explanation for a 50 page hypothesis is hard.
The question is: why the Shulaveri and only the Shulaveri, against what everyone said at the time (2015) … Tmrca, PIE dates,...