Eupedia Forums
Site NavigationEupedia Top > Eupedia Forum & Japan Forum

Search:

Type: Posts; User: spruithean

Page 1 of 14 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.01 seconds.

  1. Replies
    4
    Views
    273

    The Viking DNA paper found an individual who...

    The Viking DNA paper found an individual who belongs to I-M227:

    "VK50 Gotland_Kopparsvik-53.64 was reported I1a1a1a1a (corresponds to I-M227) in preprint"

    VK50 is an individual from a Viking...
  2. Replies
    38
    Views
    1,349

    I have read them, and they are not evidence. They...

    I have read them, and they are not evidence. They are coincidental, if vaguely similar orthographies for words or terms in different languages. Show me concrete verifiable evidence with supporting...
  3. Replies
    6
    Views
    171

    YFull estimates that IJ formed 47,200 years ago...

    YFull estimates that IJ formed 47,200 years ago and the TMRCA (time to most recent ancestor for both I and J) is estimated to be 42,900 years ago: https://www.yfull.com/tree/IJ/
  4. Replies
    38
    Views
    1,349

    Provide your "hundreds of evidences" that show...

    Provide your "hundreds of evidences" that show they were Germanic (I've requested this a lot).

    Your Russian map appears to be based on the Anatolian hypothesis.
  5. Replies
    1,337
    Views
    170,695

    This exactly.

    This exactly.
  6. Replies
    38
    Views
    1,349

    I'm going to just point out that Cyrus is not a...

    I'm going to just point out that Cyrus is not a sock account, he is not the same person as the one whom Maciamo banned permanently.



    Naw man, no rule. Believe what you want, but know that you...
  7. Au contraire, you misunderstand me. You've...

    Au contraire, you misunderstand me.

    You've repeatedly argued an Iranocentric view in which you've made extravagant claims with no backing evidence outside of orthographic similarities (Saxon,...
  8. I'm not denying that components of Greek ancestry...

    I'm not denying that components of Greek ancestry comes from elsewhere (to the east). However, we need to make the distinction that Iranian-farmer ancestry is not the same as "Iranian" people of...
  9. Replies
    8
    Views
    287

    Very interesting stuff.

    Very interesting stuff.
  10. What words relate to Semitic? No relevant scholar...

    What words relate to Semitic? No relevant scholar takes Vennemann seriously, and even if his theory was correct it would be Punic having an influence on proto-Germanic IN Northern Europe.



    ...
  11. I encourage that you read the studies you linked,...

    I encourage that you read the studies you linked, again they are very specific in laying out that the "Iranian-like" ancestry is agriculturalist or "farmer" ancestry. Which you also highlighted in...
  12. Replies
    35
    Views
    2,176

    This paper was definitely a good haul for...

    This paper was definitely a good haul for Haplogroup I1, lots of subclades (Z59, Z140, Z73, etc) no matter how lacking in depth they may have been. Certainly one of the more interesting pieces (at...
  13. The source you provided on this, when translated...

    The source you provided on this, when translated into English, did not say what you claim. Do you have another source that supports your statements? So far I've not found any sources which make the...
  14. The study this image is from does not make the...

    The study this image is from does not make the same conclusions as you, you continue to misuse data from papers on ancient DNA to fit your narrative.
  15. The proto-Germanic word *kutjaną (or *kuttaną)...

    The proto-Germanic word *kutjaną (or *kuttaną) meaning "to cut" is of an uncertain origin IIRC, and is probably related to proto-Germanic *kwetwą, meaning "meat" or "flesh". The Old Norse descendant...
  16. And those names are? Yeah, modern scholars...

    And those names are?



    Yeah, modern scholars call them Kurgans, using the Turkic word, but that doesn't mean the Kurgans in the context of Bronze Age Europe have anything to do with Turkic...
  17. I'm on my mobile at the moment so I can't quite...

    I'm on my mobile at the moment so I can't quite scrounge for the sources as yet. However, I'll gladly link them when I'm at a desktop.
    Honestly, in my own opinion I would see at as much more likely...
  18. What is your point exactly? What are you claiming?

    What is your point exactly? What are you claiming?
  19. Just for the hell of it, I think Iqaluit (as of 6...

    Just for the hell of it, I think Iqaluit (as of 6 a.m. it is 6°C) has Ardabil beat in terms of temperature in the Northern Hemisphere. :grin:



    Yeah, Indo-Europeans lived in South Asia, but they...
  20. It does seem that the term "Germanic" in this...

    It does seem that the term "Germanic" in this video has been misunderstood as "German". It is no surprise that Anglo-Saxons plot closely with Icelanders they have similar ancestral populations...
  21. Replies
    3
    Views
    626

    Here is the link to study mentioned above:...

    Here is the link to study mentioned above: https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms8152
  22. Replies
    2
    Views
    203

    There is this paper...

    There is this paper, which at this point is a bit obsolete, for example M227's placement in the tree has been fleshed out better since this paper. In fact most of I-M170 subclades are now better...
  23. That is not what either of those papers say at...

    That is not what either of those papers say at all, did you actually read them?

    Abstract from the first link, https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/584714v1.full:



    From the second link,...
  24. I'm aware, however the Rus' Khaganate was set up...

    I'm aware, however the Rus' Khaganate was set up by the Rus' people and the Rus' are described by all contemporary sources as "Norsemen". The Rus' Khaganate is a predecessor to both the Rurikid...
  25. The first study you link refers to the Iranian...

    The first study you link refers to the Iranian ancestry as "Iranian-farmer" ancestry. So this is not in the context of PIE people, second link you provide is discussing the increase in Steppe...
Results 1 to 25 of 329
Page 1 of 14 1 2 3 4