Eupedia Forums
Site NavigationEupedia Top > Eupedia Forum & Japan Forum

Search:

Type: Posts; User: Saetrus

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3

Search: Search took 0.00 seconds.

  1. Replies
    75
    Views
    15,295

    I'm not sure why there are people still...

    I'm not sure why there are people still struggling to understand that even after the big South Asia paper has shown R1a-Z93 had nothing to do with Indo-Iranians.

    https://i.imgur.com/pBI2jB1.jpg
    ...
  2. Replies
    93
    Views
    5,538

    Why would they have Turkic Y-DNA? As the south...

    Why would they have Turkic Y-DNA? As the south central Asia paper has shown there was no R1a in Indo-Iranian territory until 500BC when the Turkic invasions begin.

    On the other hand aDNA on...
  3. Replies
    10
    Views
    900

    J2 is a major Indo-European marker

    https://i.imgur.com/Q73pSNH.jpg

    -Both Mycenaean and Classical Greeks were heavily J2
    -Anatolians the oldest branch of IE were J2
    -Illyrian sample we have shared the exact same J2 as a bronze age...
  4. And it's been confirmed by leaks of the upcoming...

    And it's been confirmed by leaks of the upcoming ancient Italy paper:
    https://i.imgur.com/UhpcwYM.png

    Etruscans were R1b and Bell Beaker derived, Romans were like ancient Greeks and the other...
  5. Replies
    338
    Views
    17,226

    What data have you seen? Hovhannisyan et al 2014...

    What data have you seen? Hovhannisyan et al 2014 shows M269 STR variance is highest in eastern Anatolia and lowest in eastern Europe.
    https://i.imgur.com/pI8HVF7.jpg
    Herrera et al. 2012 shows L23...
  6. Just sort the populations of central Asia by R1a...

    Just sort the populations of central Asia by R1a
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Y-DNA_haplogroups_in_populations_of_Central_and_North_Asia
    You'll get dozens of Turkic groups at the top from all over...
  7. They didn't, only clueless amateurs are still...

    They didn't, only clueless amateurs are still saying R1a had anything to do with the spread of IE languages. No R1a has ever been found in any ancient IE population. Not Anatolians, not Greeks. not...
  8. We have an Iron Age sample from Iran:...

    We have an Iron Age sample from Iran:
    https://i.imgur.com/XJ156CG.png
  9. Ancient DNA shows that from Bactria to Italy the...

    Ancient DNA shows that from Bactria to Italy the Indo-European world used to be a genetic continuum centered around the south Caucasus
    https://i.imgur.com/wvfUR2h.png

    Only the most fringe...
  10. The why is because Gray published this study with...

    The why is because Gray published this study with that exact same date in 2003:
    https://i.imgur.com/cidHbPe.jpg

    Was he also copying you back then?
  11. Wang et. al: Reply: We’re afraid that this...

    Wang et. al:

    Reply: We’re afraid that this might be a misunderstanding. There is indeed very limited gene flow between the Caucasus and the steppe groups (apart from the examples highlighted)....
  12. You're just misinterpreting what they're showing.

    You're just misinterpreting what they're showing.
  13. They have a very similar understanding of the...

    They have a very similar understanding of the issue as my own, so what don't you understand? They're not saying it spread with early farmers they're saying it spread with CHG mountain herders.
  14. What did you say when I said that Romans would be...

    What did you say when I said that Romans would be like those very southern Collegno samples? That I should go read a book?
  15. We have a PCA from Ávila-Arcos et al. showing...

    We have a PCA from Ávila-Arcos et al. showing Etruscans as more northern than modern Tuscans
    https://i.imgur.com/UozlgX3.jpg

    So considering the two populations didn't mingle that much and Romans...
  16. How are they invisible? Etruscans are clearly a...

    How are they invisible? Etruscans are clearly a Bell Beaker derived R1b people who adapted to local languages like Vasconics and Iberians.


    https://i.imgur.com/1ZvLB70.jpg


    Should be easy...
  17. Replies
    316
    Views
    18,698

    The very study same Chiang study....

    The very study same Chiang study.
    https://i.imgur.com/ec37jXo.jpg
    Zero of the eastern European purple component in all Sardinian samples.
  18. Replies
    316
    Views
    18,698

    Sardinians only show "Steppe" when you're forcing...

    Sardinians only show "Steppe" when you're forcing Sardinians to pick from LBK EN, Loschbour and Yamnaya as if they were the only components that existed, in unsupervised mode ADMIXTURE shows no...
  19. Replies
    79
    Views
    14,616

    Except for the Indo-European samples we have so...

    Except for the Indo-European samples we have so far, right? Anatolian Indo-Europeans were J2, G, J1, Mycenaean Greeks were J2, Thracians were J2, E1b-V13 with the J2 one being an elite aristocratic...
  20. Replies
    316
    Views
    18,698

    Did it jump Greece to reach Italy? Samples from...

    Did it jump Greece to reach Italy? Samples from 2500BC-1900BC:

    Sicilian Bell Beaker
    European_Early_Farmers 49.61
    Caucasian 41.06
    South_Central_Asian 5.16


    North Italian Bell Beaker I1979...
  21. Replies
    79
    Views
    14,616

    https://i.imgur.com/ylijAP8.jpg There is still...

    https://i.imgur.com/ylijAP8.jpg

    There is still plenty of Iranic Y-DNA in that region, Kura-Araxes didn't have only R1b.





    The Ararat Valley has the highest variance of L23 in the world by...
  22. Replies
    79
    Views
    14,616

    There is no R1a in Kura-Araxes the PIE culture so...

    There is no R1a in Kura-Araxes the PIE culture so people should start considering the language family they really spoke. Sredny Stog and R1a-M417 are strongly related to one group of people and it's...
  23. Have you ever seen a portrait of an ancient Roman...

    Have you ever seen a portrait of an ancient Roman with blue eyes? Were blue eyes extremely rare or am I missing something here?
    ...
  24. No, not really. Indo-Europeans were a mountain...

    No, not really. Indo-Europeans were a mountain people who generally preferred to stick to the mountains, this is the main component and Y-DNA profile associated with them:...
  25. Kura-Araxes works perfectly fine for me, very...

    Kura-Araxes works perfectly fine for me, very much in line with what I've said Indo-Europeans were both in terms of autosomal and Y-DNA.

    K-A Y-DNA available so far:

    Kura-Araxes ARM002 Y-HG G2b...
Results 1 to 25 of 70
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3