• Don't want to see ads? Install an adblocker like uBlock Origin or use a Europe-based privacy-friendly browser like Vivaldi or Mullvad.

Search results

  1. A

    Genetic study Punic people were genetically diverse with almost no Levantine ancestors

    There is also the issue if all the sites are correctly labeled and based on what I have seen in many cases I doubt it.
  2. A

    Why I Can’t Stay Silent: The Narrative Around Ancient Civilizations Is Upside Down

    The Egyptian Dynasties had diverse origins. E.g. the Hyksos for example, according to the more modern mainstream view are supposed to have been Semitic although imho they had a Semitic element and a Aegean / Greek-related element. They also had horses and chariots but they are clearly...
  3. A

    Italian surnames inherited from ancient Romans

    A Greek politician, doctor, and former basketball player has the surname Kikilias which imho is somehow related to plebeian gens Caecilia. Coincidentally his mother is a professor of Latin.
  4. A

    Genetic study The Genetic Origin of the Indo-Europeans

    I wasn't paying attention when they published it. I'm posting a comment I made on the 'CLV cline' on YT: Ridiculous Some of the linguists, anthropologists and whatnot they cite have speculated that Maykop could have been NW Caucasian. Even if Yamnaya and Sredny Stog were PIE a movement from...
  5. A

    The genetic history of some J2 branches

    Quite bad and useless. Better just list the samples.
  6. A

    Catacomb Culture as source of Greek, Albanian, Armenian

    I am a native Greek speaker and I am not pro-Albanian at all on most issues. The truth is you don't know anything on the subject. The only thing you can do is parrot things other people have said so I will ignore you from now on.
  7. A

    Catacomb Culture as source of Greek, Albanian, Armenian

    Can you make a list of the Albanian maritime termsyou have in mind? Then we can compare it with what happens in a well attested language.
  8. A

    Catacomb Culture as source of Greek, Albanian, Armenian

    In modern Greek we use many Romance maritime terms too. I think most of them are non-Greek. That must mean Ancient Greeks didn't have a navy. Also the word for the meaning 'home' is from Latin. That must mean we didn't have homes either. The argument 'Albanian doesn't have native maritime...
  9. A

    Comparing modern Greek/Balkan populations to Classical/Hellenistic sample from Macedonia.

    Arvanites and Vlachs kept their languages and identities until recently. Assimilated early Slavs are more likely to have made an impact but not necessarily that big. Those who have Arvanite ancestry usually know it. E.g. my father is from Epirus and as far as I know we don't have known...
  10. A

    Phenotypes of the Portuguese

    Most of the colors in Von Luschan scale don't really exist.
  11. A

    Genetic study The Genetic Origin of the Indo-Europeans

    I have seen red ochre even in Paleolithic Cyclades. But they should consider it was used as body paint. There are neolithic figurines with red painted patterns. I assume scholars think they were decorative but in my opinion they may point to the use of body paint.
  12. A

    Admixture history and endogamy in the prehistoric Aegean

    I have evidence (internal evidence from the script itself) that those who created Linear B (and thus probably Linear A) were speaking an IE language. Not Greek though. For example 'wheel' could have been something like 'kaklas', 'kakra' etc. Theoretically dialects of Greek had retained the so...
  13. A

    DNA study shows Greeks clustering with Africans.

    This is Spanish science. At least Ancient Greeks believed Nubians were good-looking though. Our gods liked them too.
  14. A

    "Croatian-like" Genetics in Southwestern Ukraine and Southeastern Poland

    The Croatian translation is a bad translation. I will not post about it again because I don't really care. First of all you should take into account why the term white was used. If it referred to cardinal directions, which is what makes the most sense, 'White Croatia' could have meant either...
  15. A

    "Croatian-like" Genetics in Southwestern Ukraine and Southeastern Poland

    Ok. This is almost true. I did not remember it. The river is called Visla in the text. Also the Zachlumi do not appear as Croats proper. He says: The are 'Serbloi'. The source you use is weird because it changes the names. The names should be transcribed as they are. And then attempt to...
  16. A

    "Croatian-like" Genetics in Southwestern Ukraine and Southeastern Poland

    You can believe whatever you want but the statement 'DAI clearly says that the rurler of Zachlumia is from the Vistula' seems false to me. What is your source?
  17. A

    "Croatian-like" Genetics in Southwestern Ukraine and Southeastern Poland

    I have read it many times. Maybe they had something to do with the Prague culture. A more eastern location for the population of the origin myth is incompatible with the source in my opinion. Maybe there were 'Eastern Croats' too but that doesn't mean that they were the ones who moved to...
  18. A

    "Croatian-like" Genetics in Southwestern Ukraine and Southeastern Poland

    If we follow the Greek sources, the Croats who moved to Croatia were probably from the N/NW of modern day Croatia, 'near Bavaria'. Maybe north of Bavaria.
  19. A

    "Croatian-like" Genetics in Southwestern Ukraine and Southeastern Poland

    Can you use Sorbs as one source and different southeastern populations as another one?
  20. A

    Language trees support hybrid model for origin of Indo-European languages

    My personal view is there was at least one Anatolian-related IE language (which is something some scholars have supported at least) and there are some toponyms and theonyms that can be explained as descending from a third language, more closely related to 'nuclear IE' but different from Greek...
Back
Top