Search results

I have read it several times in recent genetic studies but I see different interpretations of it, is it the same Anatolian-related ancestry which relates to the spread of farming to the west? So why do they call it Iranian related ancestry? Of course haplogroup J2 existed in both in Anatolia and...

I wrote an article about the origin of Indo-Iranian culture: Indo-Iranian culture originated in Indo-Iranian lands (East of Iran, Afghanistan, Pakistan and north of India)

Some people say in the Neolithic and Early Bronze Age, all people of Iran spoke Elamite, so were they these Elamite people who migrated to India and Europe? So why we can't find any element of Elamite culture even in other parts of Iran?

What are these different families of languages? Elamite in the southwest of Iran? Semitic in Mesopotamia and Arabia? Hurro-Urartian in Anatolia and Levant? Kartvelian in the Caucasus? What was the main language of people who lived in Iran? We just know in south of modern Khuzistan province...

Read this section: "A Comment on Recent Genetic Findings and Aryans" About Mallory, also read his recent work which was published this year: "The Impact of Genetics Research on Archaeology and Linguistics in Eurasia" where we read about Indo-European homeland: It seems he is also among...

I asked about your 'assumed' facts, especially those ones which answer this critique: A Vedic Aryan Homeland in the Steppes? A Critique of the Kurgan Hypothesis It is really funny that you think some European archeologists know about Indo-Iranian culture more than Indian and Iranian scholars...

What are these facts, those things which are said by non-scholars who know almost nothing about Indo-Iranian culture?!

According to "Genetic origins of the Minoans and Mycenaeans", before the Bronze Age, Greece and western Anatolia were dominated by Y-chromosome haplogroup G2, as I see there is at least one Minoan sample (#I9130) which has been dated to before 2,000 with haplogroup G2a2b2. There could be...

This is not my hypothesis, I didn't write those articles, the absolute majority of Iranian and Indian scholars never believe the steppe theory of Indo-European origins but everywhere on the internet you just read about this theory, it shows spammers are actually other people.

Please read the second article in my first post, there is really nothing which shows Indian culture originated in the Central Asia, the same thing can be said about Iranian culture but there were certainly strong links between Iranian, Central Asian and Eastern European cultures, the important...

Ok, so those chariot-riding warriors who conquered India had solid wheel chariot but those who invaded several centuries later had spoked wheel chariot, is it true? I think those who invaded later from Central Asia were actually Iranian nomads, like early Indo-Scythians, about the history of...

It doesn't work so, this steppe theory can work when we have chariots in Russia (2000 BC) > Central Asia (1800 BC) > Pakistan (1500 BC) > India (1200 BC), when we know "Chariots were used in Mesopotamia from before 3000 B.C.": http://www.mesopotamia.co.uk/tombs/explore/w_char2.html and Sumerian...

It doesn't talk about aDNA samples but archaeological evidence of horse chariots, those ones which have been found in the north are 300 to 500 years after Sanauli ones, as you see here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chariot this is historical map of the spread of the spoke-wheeled chariot...

Please read the article, it is important to know where Sanauli is located, as you mentioned "Carbon dating marks this site as an earliest history of a warrior tribe in the Indian subcontinent (sic)", in the first article it is questioned: "How come the Indo-Europeans arriving from central Asia...

Yes, this study also says: "We assume that the migration more likely came from the Middle East, rather than a relatively isolated Mediterranean island." In fact Sardinians first came to another land in the Middle East and then people of this land migrated to Armenia.

Carbon Dating Shows UP’s Sanauli Had Chariot-Riding Warriors In 1900 BC, Here’s What It Means For Aryan Invasion Theory Also read this new article: A Vedic Aryan Homeland in the Steppes? A Critique of the Kurgan Hypothesis

Would you please mention some J2 samples in Greece which date back to before 2,000 BC?

R1b-Z2103 is Cimmerian haplogroup, the original land of Cimmerians was in the west of Black sea, about 1,000 BC they migrated to Iran and Anatolia. In the 7th century BC Cimmerians conquered Ellipi kingdom in modern Luristan. If you are interested to know about the history of Iranian...

About Mycenaean Greeks, it seems to be J2a-Z6057: https://www.eupedia.com/forum/threads/39737-Ancient-J2-samples-in-Europe-Pre-Phoenecian But two Minoan samples (I0070 and I0073) are J2a-Y151557, a subclade of J2a-M319, in fact they are from different branches. Mycenaean J2a-Z6057 and Indian...

It is not a complicated issue, some people thought the spread of IE culture relates to steppe-related ancestry, so first they focused on ancient Anatolians, as the earliest known Indo-European people and said steppe-related ancestry moved through southeast Europe into Anatolia, now geneticists...