Search results

By that reasoning and logic, albeit may be true, all that has been said so far about any ancient dna can be false and falsified. All samples up to date can be a far way guy or group of guys travelling or kidnapped girls or just a set of different people....you name it. Most derived inferences...

Special pleading. Using that logic almost all conclusions from adna can be ignored. Actually by some fluke of universe all the samples that do not support my claims are in fact born out of far away kidnapped girls by adventurous guys the brought those girls to be slaves. ...are you saying there...

hummm. Fed up with David Anthony to tell you the truth. a. Boian and Gulmelnita (around 4600bc and related to Kum6) , rapidly mixed with Hamangia culture (from 5000bc) which was a related Anatolia people, as a differentiation of the others around and northwestern LBK, Starcevo type of people...

Apart from Genetics. (note: you do realize that for all the 3 main labs to have changed their mind and making a bullseye in the Shulaveri land it’s because they know what as not been published, right?) First, I need to write an entry on Kickedoutdogs (https://r1b2westerneurope.blogs.sapo.pt/)...

Kid, grow up.

Don't hold to strickly to that. If today I would have written it very differently. ;)

What is negative writing?

Time to remember me in 2015. "“Shulaveri-Shomu is the birth of the R1b expansion!por Olympus Mons, em 09.01.16 *the European dominance of Y-dna Haplogroup R1b had its origin in a very specific culture of the Caucasus the Shulaveri-Shomu, Not Yamna, nor Maikop, nor Kura arexes… no! Places like...

I always said: There will be a day when everybody "knew all along" that the Shulaveri where it! Marvelous human brain. :)

One thing missing on that Map arrows, shades and formats. Kristiansen, like all others keep missing a huge chunk that is so obvious... they are so hooked to steppe that they dont register that if PIE was following that CHG admix... then the line to Anatolia must not stop there. Actually the...

Well... You know I all about Shulaveri for so long and fought such hard fights that I will always instinctively say it has to be them. However, don't give up on your theory. Halaf is troublesome. because they can be so many different things. Even R1b mixing up with J2 all over south caucasus...

Me, Me, Me....Shulaveri Shomu, Shulaveri-Shomu, Shulaveri-Shomu, Shulaveri-Shomu, Shulaveri-Shomu!

L and J where not the earliest PIE speakers. R1b and J2 yes. L is incoming population after 4900bc! PIE originals were already gone. *L is incoming population from either a. beyond Kopet Dag, most likely very close to Jeitun Culture... b. an Iran south population moving up by zagros mountains...

What?!! - Who were? Shulaveri -Shomu. and they were the same people. Actually shy people that "landed" in that dotted circle you see in the picture and developed spectacularly. Reason for sucess? Luck and annoying people, because everybody seems to kicked them out!

Dear friend... and who lived in the exact place of that doted circle?

This is sort of misleading. The same way the "steppe" could have picked up EEF, so could the EEF have picked up "Steppe" as those are seen quite early on places like Romania. Actually you have a Romania HG by 7000bc which is 80% EHG. you have 4000 BC CHG pouring into balkans. so lets be...

you seem to forget that until "recent", the british isle were "3 herder and 10 goats"! - so whats up with the Britain fixation? :) a. check any youtube video of European population overtime and and you will notice how scarce were population in northern, and northeastern not say eastern...

Can you elaborate?

Hi. Not bold at all. :) The reason why reich changed is view must be because they found L23 and probably Z2103 in transcaucasia. Remember, afaik the only L23 without subclades found thus far is a guy who lives in Erzurum in armenia/turkey. So. a. If am right about Boian...

Halfalp... I don't know if you are just very young or is something else. But you seem to have grave problems with more elaborate concepts and models. You seem to want to play Warlord and that is not going to take you very far. a. J1 and J2 means nothing! those are so old in the region that...