Search results

We dont have any context, so we dont know much. We barely have any ancient dna from the prehistoric indian subcontinent. The transmission of solid wheeled chariot to the indian subcontinent dont necessarily imply an invasion, it could be cultural transmission through the middle-east -> iran...

This chariot was a Solid Wheel Chariot, not a Spoked one, so not very reminescent of Sintashta-Andronovo Horizon. I dont really understand the point of this topic. Indo-Europeans dont have the monopoly for Warrior or Chariot. There was Chariots in Europe and Mesopotamia before Sintashta, there...

I'm not talking about IE hypothesis. My point was that Lineage=/=Ancestry. And that J1 being 100% EHG in Eastern Europe, or R1b-V1636 being found without any EHG/Steppe ancestry are to be taking with the same argument. I'm actually not believing CHG came from Eastern Europe, but nothing support...

Aren't you the one bothered? Everything you just wrote about J1 and CHG is your own speculation. You quite dont seem to apply the same rules to yourself whether it's North or South.

How do we know J1 was from the South? Satsurblia? Why a 100% EHG J1 is coming from South, but a non-Steppe R1b-V1636 comes from South too? People have a tendencies to make the Middle-East a center line of Expansion or Absorbtion. We dont know, or dont have a clear cut on the dynamic of those...

I have nothing more precise.

Not sure if i got it right, but my results are only this. 1. Belgic Tribe Nordhouse France (500 BC) ..... 7.327 The number 2 is Hidden. And number 3 is. 3. Unetice Bohemia (1875 BC) ..... 10.09 A slight over 10.

I could be completely off, but i know new samples from Khvalynsk were already leaked. With some R1b,R1a,J1 and others.

It was not, i presume. Indo-Europeans in Middle-East were at last an opportunistic luck. There was many more other ethnics and languages in the near-by.

Wait, sample ALX002 is labeled from Leila-Tepe Culture and is y-dna G1!!! Isn't it the first instance of prehistoric G1 ever? And from Leila-Tepe. Making this culture quite even more interesting now.

I mean... are you not " obsessed " with finding any y-dna E in all new papers? Dont be so prompt to judge other people for what they are interested into. We all are reasoning the same way for the most part.

Middle-East Chalcolithic/Bronze Age probably was a paradise of civilization for Steppe people, or any other foreigners when they came there. Huge cities-states with high structures and sculptures, lots of people, hugh wealth... not that hard to think that any Steppe lineage could have lost...

I think a few unpublished samples of Khvalynsk were labeled P297 but V1636 instead, not sure. I think it's linked with David Anthony works.

You argument dont match because the Progress individuals have nothing of ancestry from this younger Anatolian individual neither. What we could argue with is that wherever it is found, V1636 shows CHG ancestry, wich do not give you it's origin, because of how old this ancestry is. It's not a...

I know it's kinda agreed by the intelligentsia that Steppe Cultures were mainly Patriarcal and Neolithic Cultures mainly Matriarcal, but was it really the case for the later? A cult of pregnant women, fertility dont tell us anything. And just like Steppe cultures, Neolithic Cultures shows...

Interesting post, but this would make inevitably Bell Beakers the putative people of the origin for Western Indo-European languages right?

Dated 178 BC - 2 AD. Cimmerians were long gone, and we dont really have clear clue if they want as far as central-western europe, Scythians-Sarmatians is probably the best choice. Those modern y-dna Q and mtdna C5 are not that strange, and they wouldn't show east asian ancestry if their...

Any clue how sample [ TU905 (X18) mtdna B4c1b2c2 ] could have ended in Iron Age Europe? Scythians or Cimmerians?

Yes, it's interesting to notice that the Indo-European Expansion and Bantou Expansion are dated pretty much from the same time frame. Between -3000 and -1500. Wad there a worldwide climatic change? Or was it motivated because Herding?

Distance to: Halfalp 4.30843359 Swiss__DEU_Anselfingen_FN_MX259 6.62616028 France_IA_COL153A 6.85072259 France_IA_ERS1164 7.02192993 Swiss__DEU_Singen_EBA_MX254_relMX286 7.14354254 France_IA_NOR2B6 7.74472724 France_IA_COL153i 8.92820251 Swiss__CHE_EBA_SX23 9.15642944...