Search results

For now, the most likely option is that I2a branches together with R1a branches form the original White Croats. This is what could be proven historiographically and genetically, but for confirmation we need archaeogenetics. We do not know when R1a came into contact with the I2a group, so it is...

When we talk about millions of Europeans in the E-Z5018 branch, we're actually talking and about Serbs from Kosovo who are in that branch. So there is a possibility that their branches came with the Slavs, however for now we do not see a YFull migration path in branch E-Z5018 that would prove...

That's why I say we have to wait. But if there are Albanians in that branch, we can assume that the Serbs also have something to do with them, given that they live close by. But surely that has yet to be proven.

It is an old colony and there was probably mixing over the years. However, it is possible that there is an I2a or R1a branch among them, which would prove that the people of Dubrovnik, or Croats, also existed there. But I say for any conclusion we have to have something "black on white".

"Haplogroups like E-Z1057 or E-Z5018 mean nothing, they are to general." This is what we have for now, however, there are Albanians in most of these branches, but they are not geographically Serbs from Sweden and Albanians from Kosovo. This is about people who live house to house. Normally...

If in the future some scientific work determine genetics of Croats from Kosovo, then we would have a quality basis for a conclusion. In this way, we cannot know the genetics of Croats from Kosovo because they have not been officially tested. If we assume that E1b, R1b and J1-J2 predominate...

What we officially have is a scientific paper: "Mihajlovic, Milica; Tanasic, Vanja; Markovic, Milica Keckarevic; Kecmanovic, Miljana; Keckarevic, Dusan (2022-11-01). "Distribution of Y-chromosome haplogroups in Serbian population groups originating from historically and geographically...

There is not a single archaeogenetic sample(y dna Indo-European candidate) which would prove migration of someone from the area of Anatolia, whether towards the east or the west, and whose bearers would be speakers or transmitters of Indo-European language. I already mentioned that. " South...

"Thus linguistically speaking Heggarty et al. 2023 claims that the Indo-Iranic/Balto-Slavic node is unlikely." "The closest relatives of Balto-Slavic are Albanian and Indo-Iranian. The large majority of special correspondences between Balto-Slavic and IndoIranian are archaisms, not innovations...

Maybe you're talking about this scientific paper, "An Ancient Harappan Genome Lacks Ancestry from Steppe Pastoralists or Iranian Farmers" https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0092867419309675#bib13 "Our results also have linguistic implications. One theory for the origins of the...

"In summary, we demonstrate a higher proportion of genomic sharing between PNWI populations and ancient EHG and Steppe-related populations than we observe in other South Asians. We report that the Ror are the modern population that is closest to the first prehistorical and early historical South...

Indian geneticists can't prove anything for now because they have no confirmation in archaeogenetics or living YFull genetics. Therefore, what we have now is R1a Z93 direction of migration north of the Caspian Sea. Archaeogenetic evidence, which would indicate closer living of R1a and R1b...

The latest archaeogenetic data must be used and this is not visible on this map. The main R1a Z93 branch archaeogenetically shows migration route north of the Caspian Sea and not directly from Caucasus through Anatolia to India. I think that such an approach is frivolous...

It is a linguistic interpretation. I say what genetics says. Indo-Iranic homeland is basically PIE homeland, yes, and Balto-Slavic homeland is basically PIE homeland. Logically when they are R1a relatives. "According to those studies, haplogroups R1b-M269 and R1a, now the most common in Europe...

As for the Indo-European ancestral homeland, or place where the Proto-Indo-European language starts, for now in my opinion it is difficult to determine the place where it was located. What should be our guide is archaeogenetic place where the older R1a and R1b mutations lived (10,000-7,000...

Where does it say that the PIE homeland is in Anatolia/South-Caucasus, in the context of migration to India? This is what writes in the scientific paper: "Steppe pastoralists of the Yamnaya culture initiated a chain of migrations linking Europe in the west to China and India in the East." That's...

Linguistically, I don't deny peer reviewed work. I am saying that today's genetics refutes migration of R1a and R1b people from Anatolia to India. I don't know who diffused IE, I'm just following the genetics and what we know from scientific papers. So far the Russian Steppe is the source, I...

Linguistics has its own rules and this should be respected, but in the end linguistics will have to be harmonized with genetics and TMRCA of individual Y branches. As for question 1 or 2, I am not an expert on that issue because I follow Croatian migrations more. If we use information from...

Why only R1a? Well, because it has the main frequency in the Slavic peoples. Find another Y candidate and show direction of migration in a wider area, ie with common Europe-India connections. There is also R1b but which R1b carriers have so many similar words with Sanskrit? Otherwise, there is...

At this time, in the year 2024, this is the migration of the R1a. https://cache.eupedia.com/images/content/R1a_migration_map.jpg Therefore, the Lithuanian language has similar words from Sanskrit https://www.reddit.com/media?url=https://i.redd.it/gkh6d11igvi91.png, and their only connection with...