Search results

  1. М

    Slavic homeland and ethnogenesis

    You are welcome,i wrote them words to show that some dialects had more contact with other languages not about Slavic in particular,i give Taranis reputation he certainly know his job and theory he stay behind,i just researched some words in free time apart i like history.
  2. М

    Slavic homeland and ethnogenesis

    Now we should move the time a bit that Christianity spread in the 12th century because words from Paleo-Mythology are simple the same,borrowings?while trough the migration period,Slavonic migration in particular Roman empire was already Christian,from whom they "borrowed" them some "Romanized"...
  3. М

    Slavic homeland and ethnogenesis

    Some are found in all,some in South Slavic and East Slavic,South Slavic and West Slavic and some that i put are just in the Southern most dialects bordering Greek see there the exchangings,borrowings are highest which is to be expected,i can not say the first apparition for most,we can only...
  4. М

    Slavic homeland and ethnogenesis

    Don't know whether anyone was using the Slav in self designation i never noticed.Basil who found the Macedonian dynasty of Roman(Byzantine) empire maybe Armenian or Armeno-Slavonic or Slavonic speakers was simple using "Basil the Macedonian" due to the region(theme) he is coming from,did he come...
  5. М

    Slavic homeland and ethnogenesis

    I do agree on that,i also ask myself that question,what would be the difference between Iberian peninsula,Gaul and the Balkans when it comes to language and the Roman empire,i should first give my opinion on the migration cause you say i deny it, i just think it is inappropriate term to use,will...
  6. М

    Slavic homeland and ethnogenesis

    You can anyway delete this thread,do me a favor.
  7. М

    Slavic homeland and ethnogenesis

    Yes indeed imagine that,they were Roman emperors but from Thraco-Illyrian origin,one should even study identity transformation,need recomendation?
  8. М

    Slavic homeland and ethnogenesis

    How can one understand people that doesn't understand how to separate language from genetics.
  9. М

    Slavic homeland and ethnogenesis

    Latinizied and Hellenized that idea is bit doubtfull,but many were in fact Roman allies of those people and some helped that empire to be established,we had many of them emperors of Thraco-Illyrian origin,while others didn't submit to the Romans,some even migrated North,just one being...
  10. М

    Slavic homeland and ethnogenesis

    Because you said that bosnia is more right like being more Slavic of them all,so i ask kind question,by what we determine who is more Slavic than other to you?
  11. М

    Slavic homeland and ethnogenesis

    So according to you and what you are trying to convince me is that some Slavs emerged and Slavicized the Thraco-Illyrians the Scytho-Sarmatians,the Goths,will expell the Germans from elsewhere and in just 100 and so years,but the groups you mentioned needed much more time,how can this theory...
  12. М

    Slavic homeland and ethnogenesis

    I already gave my opinion or is more opinion of others,in my first post i name them Oleg Trubachov,Johanna Nichols,Horace Lunt,all of them being Slavists and with similar opinion choose the Danube region,the spread of Balto-Slavic was roughly perhaps in same places like today and i stand behind...
  13. М

    Slavic homeland and ethnogenesis

    By what token we declare one being more Slavic over other?by R1a haplogroup or one being from Poland?that is more then a bias to say if we think that way,if we talk first and foremost for linguistic group later for the rest,in our knowledge we know the Sclavenes and Antes if both of them we...
  14. М

    Slavic homeland and ethnogenesis

    I never said such thing,nor i will ever say they had contacts,i just don't know why you think that way,just said maybe a cognate,those "cognates" were put by others not myself but they wrote compare instead,my bad should have wrote the Latin cognates only because you misunderstand me. From...
  15. М

    Slavic homeland and ethnogenesis

    Slavic-Latin and maybe even Akkadian and Classical Hebrew cognates upon "Axe" Slavic (sekira, "axe")Latin (secūris , “axe”). Compare Akkadian ‎(šukurru, “axe”), Classical Hebrew ‎(šegōr, “axe”). Latin and Slavic forms are derived from the PIE root *sek-(to cut) thus Old.Ch.Slav(seko) Latin...
  16. М

    Slavic homeland and ethnogenesis

    What Orthodoxy has to do with what we were talking,im not religious if you want to debate those things,Great Moravia didn't survived to became anything let alone 'Orthodox' it was destroyed,why the Greek alphabet was adopted from Phoenican and Latin from Greek,yet were waging wars on Carthage,we...
  17. М

    Slavic homeland and ethnogenesis

    There was Great Moravia before Bohemia and Poland,Ss Cyril and Methodius went there first on the mission,at that time Cyrillic wasnt yet in use but Glagolithic alphabet and it was much more complex in that period of time instead only adopting some form of Christianity,those alphabets especialy...
  18. М

    Slavic homeland and ethnogenesis

    Because Old Church Slavonic is the oldest written Slavic language and not only it was language that influenced almost all Slavic languages which we know today,it was language on which Slavonic alphabets were made,so we can not look other way arround,borrowings as much as culture vary from region...
  19. М

    Slavic homeland and ethnogenesis

    Some common Slavic-Latin-Ancient Greek words,some are only distributed among Souther Slavic area. Old.Ch.Slav ‎(ognĭ) Latin(ignis) Eng(flame,fire) Old.Ch.Slav-bones ‎(kostĭ) Latin-rib (costa) Slav (Kit) Anc.Greek (ketos) Eng(whale) Ketos sea monster in Greek mythology.Probably pre-Greek word...
  20. М

    Slavic homeland and ethnogenesis

    Taranis here are some common Slavic-Latin words that i collect today,might you can explain wheter they were borrowings,proto-indo european,cause some are find in ancient Greek. Lat (domi) Slav (doma) Eng (home) Lat (ros) Slav (rosa) Eng(dew) Lat(oves) Slav(ovca) Eng(sheep) Lat (balnea)...
Back
Top