Aberdeen
Regular Member
- Messages
- 1,835
- Reaction score
- 380
- Points
- 0
- Ethnic group
- Scottish, English and German
- Y-DNA haplogroup
- I1
- mtDNA haplogroup
- H4
There should have been at least some, perhaps even reaching 1% of the tombs with swords, but I haven't found any example (except one from the Przeworsk culture). So can you provide examples?
As far as texts are concerned, I don't remember so many texts with women fighting with swords, here alsoperhaps reaching 0,1% of the texts mentioning fighting men(I know a few texts indicating women fighting, but I don't remember that these texts were indicating they were fighting with swords)? Can you also provide examples?
However, coming back to the Celtic tomb of Lavau, the only reason why all the articles say it is the tomb of a prince is the presence of a sword, which indicates it's very probably a man.
I was attending a conference by Stéphane Verger about this Celtic tomb last week, and when he said that the DNA tests had not been yet done, somebody asked: "So how do we know it's not a princess?", he answered; "thanks to the sword".
I'm sure he is familiar enough with the Celtic culture and archaeology to be almost certain he is right...
I don't have time to educate someone who seems to lack a basic knowledge of Celtic culture, but here's a website that will get you started on the role of women in Celtic culture, including the role of Celtic women rulers and warriors, both historical figures such as Boudicca and Cartimandua, and mythological figures such as Medb and Scatlach.
www.celtlearn.org/pdfs/women.pdf
Many Roman writers referred to women warriors using shields. In describing a battle between Romans and Celts in 102 BC, Plutarch talked about Celtic women charging with swords and axes. While this current grave find is most likely male, one can't just assume that.
I looked up your Stephane Verger and he seems to specialize in Greek and Anatolian archeology, not Continental Celtic. But this has gone too far off topic. This latest find is interesting because it relates to a pivotal period in Celtic prehistory.