Leopoldo Leone
Regular Member
- Messages
- 269
- Reaction score
- 207
- Points
- 43
LOL, it was found in every single Levantine civilization and Egypt not only Phoenicians. So it can be Phoenician, Jewish, Syrian, Assyrian, Edomite, Egyptian, Amorite, Aramean, etc...
The Scandinivan, the Indian and the Central Asian ones all have an ancestor who belonged to one of those mentioned groups, again this is a fact and facts don't care about your feelings.
Yes, how convenient it is to postulate that it was some Semitic-speaking groups travelling all the way there and settling down instead of taking as the most plausible explanation that it was spread by Iran_N or CHG lineages that are known to have contributed to all groups living in those areas? Again, I have been waiting for some sources, but you just pointed that "the oldest samples that have it are from the Levant, so it must be Levantine", although the fact there is no historical evidence of any possible Egyptian or Levantine sources reaching as far, and that the age of the J2-M205 subclade is compatible with much older movements, https://haplogroup.org/ystory/j-m205/.
We have discussed for some length about this clade, but you have shown to build your "arguments" by wishful thinking, weak evidence and overlooking of contrary evidence, so I do not expect anything different about any eventual discussion about the other clades.