Distribution of I1 in Italy (Boattini et al.)

[torzio]

Well, first of all thanks a lot. I'm a super beginner in this! Browsing on the raw data.. they are all there... I am not sure if I am making a very stupid statement (such as, of course they're all there but you should check X,Y,Z) but I can say that they're all on the raw data!

PS: yes, I have tested just very recently!

I know nothing about I1 ......but my paternal grandmother ydna side is ...... I1-Y33791
They are from Merlengo and before this Pederobba in Veneto

I do not think I1 ydna is uncommon haplogroup in italy , but unsure

 

[Regio X]

Well, first of all thanks a lot. I'm a super beginner in this! Browsing on the raw data.. they are all there... I am not sure if I am making a very stupid statement (such as, of course they're all there but you should check X,Y,Z) but I can say that they're all on the raw data!

PS: yes, I have tested just very recently!

The results you've sent me are very interesting. As I told you, if they're correct, you'd be either a basal I-Z58 (I-Z58*) or a pre-I-Z139 (Z139+, Z13. Either way, cool!

 

[torzio]

Thanks Torzio. Actually the side of the I1-Z58 YDNA is not from Veneto though.
It's the one supposed to be from Romagna-Marche (tracing back generations).
It's a side on which I don't know much in terms of history (compared to the Venetian line) and I would find super interesting to know if the I1 Y-DNA comes from Germanic people? Maybe from Lombards, Goths? Maybe from the Balkans since my autosomal dna on eurogenics and co keeps associating me to Albanians? Maybe through Bologna? Spoleto? Ravenna? Campobasso? Benevento? Who knows It would be cool if it was through Friuli o Vicenza though, it would reconnect with the pure Venetian side




Thanks a lot because first of all I've learned a lot through a few PMs with you.
Not sure what to do next now :embarassed: BTW below the MorleyDNA prediction based on the 23andme raw data upload.
https: // imgur . com/a/cNtun0c

maybe you are an ostrogoth ......there capital was modern Ravenna ............they where replaced in Italy by the Lombards after losing a war to them

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ostrogoths

or maybe you came via the celtic invasion of lombardy and romagna by the Boii and Semnones group

 

[Regio X]

Thanks a lot because first of all I've learned a lot through a few PMs with you.
Not sure what to do next now :embarassed: BTW below the MorleyDNA prediction based on the 23andme raw data upload.
https: // imgur . com/a/cNtun0c

I'm in agreement with Morley then.
Again, cool results!

 

[Regio X]

Would it make sense to buy the YSEQ I-Z139 test and give it a try? I would assume a negative result would "confirm" basal I-Z58, while a positive... well I don't know considering the negative for I-Z138!

Sure. You could try the SNP Z139, here: https://www.yseq.net/product_info.php?products_id=30239 .