Goga
Banned
- Messages
- 2,651
- Reaction score
- 152
- Points
- 0
- Y-DNA haplogroup
- R1a*
- mtDNA haplogroup
- HV1b2
I don't want anything. The only thing I want is a free Kurdistan right NOW.Then why hasn't N1c been found in Mesolithic Russia, why is it all R1a1, R1b1, J, and Q1a? And it unlogical to put personalities to prehistoric people groups. You're treating N1c1, etc. as better than other Euro haplogroups and giving it an image of the original the native. It's not that simple.
Anyways, the reason you say N1c1 is the only original Y DNA of NE Europe, is because you don't want anything in West Asia to have a European origin. You want Europeans to either be innocent natives who never migrated out of Europe or from West Asians. Everything doesn't go from West Asia>Europe. And all early human technological achievements didn't come from West Asia.
West Asia isn't the source of everything. In the past no one had world maps and when they gradually moved from one location to another(there was very rarelly ever transcontinental migrations), they could potentially go in any direction, Europe doesn't always have to be on the receiving end. There's European ancestry in West and SC Asia. Actually Bronze age East Europeans fit as the best West Eurasian proxy ancestors for SC Asians.
I can tell you're taking Pre-History genetics to a personal level. That's normal I used to do it. I wanted everything to be from Germany(inclu. IEs) at first and tricked myself into thinking that. And you need to grow up like I did. It doesn't make your people(Kurds) inferior if they have European ancestry or if their language is ultimately from Europe. No one was raciest in the Bronze age. They had a small world view, restricted to their small regions. Indo Iranians were already heavily admixed by the time they made it to Iran and Iraq anyways.
I'm just a history geek and love the ancient times. I'm a romantic who wants to understand the present. To understand the present you need to know the past. And all the things I read on internet I don't agree with it. And that's why I try to give a different voice be real and not parroting the nonsense of others with hidden agendas.
Many people on internet are not really smart and are very manipulative and believe others with hidden agenda to get rid of their insecurity and to boost their ego.
But this is not how history works. You can't change history. It is what it is.
Russia is a huge country if they look long and good enough they will find enough archaic N1c1 there. Even in Scandinavia, Saami ancestral homeland, they will find ancient N1c1.
East Euro auDNA component is not fully Caucasoid. It's heavily mixed with Mongoloid, Uralic and Finno-Ugric races. That's why we see that component everywhere in the Northern and Eastern areas of Eurasia. It's where Caucasoid and Mongoloid people met with each other and heavily mixed with each other and from the romantic times Eastern Euro (EHG) component was born. Part of East-Euro folks is related to folks like Eskimos, Saami, Amerindian folks..
EHG = Caucasoid + Mongoloid/Uralic/Finno-Ugric races
I'm a true Iranid person. All my ancestors were Iranid. My culture is Iranic, my native religion is West Iranic and my language is West Iranic.
I think that proto-Iranid folks, my direct ancestors, were fully Caucasoid and has NOTHING to do with EHG. It doesn't make any sense if they were party Mongoloid/EHG
They were Caucaso-Gedrosian (mixture of ANE and EEF), nothing Mongoloid/EHG in them. I will never believe in this nonsense and will always fight against this nonsens!
So, R1a-M198 was not Mongoloid/EHG, but fully Caucasoid (Caucaso-Gedrosian/EEF+ANE)
When people speak about Indo-Iranians and spread lies, they spread lies about my ancestry, about my roots. I take this somehow very personal. Of course when I don't agree with them, I always want to make my case more clear.
For me it's all about the truth and nothing but the truth.