Aspurg
Banned
- Messages
- 661
- Reaction score
- 233
- Points
- 0
- Ethnic group
- Bædzænæg
- Y-DNA haplogroup
- E-A24070
- mtDNA haplogroup
- I1a1a
Literally 90 % of content in these forum debates regarding the Y-DNA and autosomal admixture is made from the perspective of posters ethnicity, then also hg's etc.
So Shamiri, a Persian, is trying to appropriate J2a for his own ethnicity/civilisation. So J2a in Greeks is not Minoan related but rather should have arrived to there with some Persian-like proto-IE group. Has it occurred to Shamiri that proto-Persians are just an offshoot of Central Asian Nomadic proto-Iranics who invaded the Iranian Plateau 3000-3500 years ago, settled and mixed with the J2a carrying and other natives. Persians carry a minority autosomal Steppe Iranic/Andronovo element, mostly represented by Persian R1a Z93 clades.
J2a clades already diversified 15 k + years ago, and it's clear that vast majority of Greek J2a has no relation to IE's, but it does to Minoan, and other movements.
Though as there are so many J2a clades, some of them had different paths such has one Turkic/nomadic clade.
Minoans had J-M319 for ex., I believe there are modern Cretans who are at least predicted as M319+. M319 itself is pretty old.
So Shamiri, a Persian, is trying to appropriate J2a for his own ethnicity/civilisation. So J2a in Greeks is not Minoan related but rather should have arrived to there with some Persian-like proto-IE group. Has it occurred to Shamiri that proto-Persians are just an offshoot of Central Asian Nomadic proto-Iranics who invaded the Iranian Plateau 3000-3500 years ago, settled and mixed with the J2a carrying and other natives. Persians carry a minority autosomal Steppe Iranic/Andronovo element, mostly represented by Persian R1a Z93 clades.
J2a clades already diversified 15 k + years ago, and it's clear that vast majority of Greek J2a has no relation to IE's, but it does to Minoan, and other movements.
Though as there are so many J2a clades, some of them had different paths such has one Turkic/nomadic clade.
Minoans had J-M319 for ex., I believe there are modern Cretans who are at least predicted as M319+. M319 itself is pretty old.