So my family is mixed between bosnian and north east europe. Here is my K13 and MDLP 22 did not use eurogenes as saw that there were no bosnian groups in the spreadsheet. So not sure how accurate the puntdnal is but it seems to be more accurate for me then eurogene.
Using 1 population approximation:
1 Croatian @ 3.083339
2 German_South @ 3.913435
3 Hungarian @ 4.167964
4 Belgian @ 5.040628
5 Slovene @ 5.241418
6 Bosnian @ 5.416361
7 English @ 5.712161
8 French @ 6.094639
9 Scottish @ 6.790706
10 Slovak @ 7.166856
11 Moldavian @ 7.185848
12 Orcadian @ 7.257998
13 Serbian @ 7.567864
14 Irish @ 7.652881
15 Utahn_European @ 7.904158
16 German_North @ 9.735929
17 Montenegrin @ 10.588071
18 Romanian @ 12.450385
19 Ukrainian @ 12.457264
20 Macedonian @ 12.637722
Using 2 populations approximation:
1 50% Serbian +50% Utahn_European @ 2.091444
Using 3 populations approximation:
1 50% Irish +25% Italian_Tuscan +25% Slovak @ 1.783508
Using 4 populations approximation:
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
1 Italian_Tuscan + Orcadian + Slovak + Utahn_European @ 1.598939
2 Italian_Tuscan + Scottish + Slovak + Utahn_European @ 1.603395
3 Irish + Italian_Tuscan + Slovak + Utahn_European @ 1.609640
4 English + Italian_Tuscan + Slovak + Utahn_European @ 1.623394
5 Italian_Tuscan + Slovak + Utahn_European + Utahn_European @ 1.648376
6 English + Greek_Thessaly + Utahn_European + Utahn_European @ 1.666144
7 Greek_Thessaly + Scottish + Utahn_European + Utahn_European @ 1.696199
8 Irish + Italian_Tuscan + Slovene + Utahn_European @ 1.705875
9 Albanian + English + Utahn_European + Utahn_European @ 1.708756
10 Italian_Tuscan + Slovene + Utahn_European + Utahn_European @ 1.723197
11 Greek_Thessaly + Utahn_European + Utahn_European + Utahn_European @ 1.723991
12 Italian_Tuscan + Orcadian + Slovene + Utahn_European @ 1.732955
13 Italian_Abruzzo + Norwegian + Utahn_European + Utahn_European @ 1.735682
14 English + Kosovar + Utahn_European + Utahn_European @ 1.737673
15 Albanian + Scottish + Utahn_European + Utahn_European @ 1.737853
16 Greek_Thessaly + Orcadian + Utahn_European + Utahn_European @ 1.737853
17 Greek_Thessaly + Irish + Utahn_European + Utahn_European @ 1.741802
18 Italian_Abruzzo + Norwegian + Orcadian + Utahn_European @ 1.750558
19 Kosovar + Slovene + Utahn_European + Utahn_European @ 1.753423
20 Irish + Italian_Abruzzo + Norwegian + Utahn_European @ 1.754478
Done.
k13 ^
MDLP 22
Least-squares method.
Using 1 population approximation:
1 Bosnian @ 1.893893
2 Croatian @ 3.238915
3 Serbian @ 3.897576
4 Hungarian @ 4.964888
5 Austrian @ 5.532423
6 German-South @ 6.171086
7 German_V @ 6.606912
8 Montenegrin @ 7.006940
9 Slovenian @ 7.017377
10 Macedonian @ 7.465717
11 CEU_V @ 8.640939
12 CEU @ 9.445596
13 Croatian_V @ 9.523872
14 Swiss @ 9.540670
15 British @ 9.776437
16 Czech @ 10.105633
17 Bulgarian @ 10.298981
18 Welsh @ 10.463217
19 German @ 10.543423
20 Orcadian @ 10.734235
Using 2 populations approximation:
1 50% Serbian +50% Croatian @ 0.785756
Using 3 populations approximation:
1 50% German-North +25% Austrian +25% Italian-Center @ 0.721736
Using 4 populations approximation:
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
1 German-North + Swedish + Italian-Center + Croatian @ 0.595666
2 Italian-Center + Croatian + Orcadian + Sorb @ 0.635601
3 Bosnian + Montenegrin + Croatian + Croatian @ 0.649036
4 German-North + Swedish + Greek_East + Croatian @ 0.657119
5 German-North + Macedonian + Macedonian + Croatian @ 0.663759
6 Belarusian_V + Italian-Center + Croatian + British @ 0.693628
7 Greek_East + Croatian + Orcadian + Sorb @ 0.695655
8 Belarusian_V + Italian-Center + Croatian + Orcadian @ 0.704216
9 Polish_V + Italian-Center + Croatian + British @ 0.713017
10 German-North + Montenegrin + Macedonian + Croatian @ 0.717714
11 German-North + Czech + Italian-Center + German_V @ 0.719413
12 German-North + German-North + Austrian + Italian-Center @ 0.721736
13 Bosnian + Swedish + Swedish + Greek_East @ 0.738103
14 German-North + Bulgarian + Serbian + Croatian @ 0.738281
15 German-North + German-South + Italian-Center + Sorb @ 0.740712
16 Italian-Center + Sorb + German_V + German_V @ 0.744632
17 German-North + Russian_South + French + Italian-Center @ 0.751699
18 Bosnian + Polish_V + Italian-Center + Orcadian @ 0.753465
19 Austrian + Italian-Center + Sorb + German_V @ 0.757491
20 Bosnian + Bulgarian + Kosovar + Lithuanian @ 0.761873
Done.
Using 1 population approximation:
1 Serbian_derived @ 4.449430
2 German-South_derived @ 5.660327
3 Montenegrin_derived @ 5.857263
4 Macedonian_derived @ 7.011053
5 German_V_derived @ 7.938296
6 Austrian_derived @ 8.103458
7 Bosnian_derived @ 9.077869
8 Hungarian_derived @ 9.235787
9 CEU_derived @ 9.302048
10 CEU_V_derived @ 9.508316
11 Bulgarian_derived @ 9.566237
12 British_derived @ 9.909520
13 Croatian_derived @ 10.040890
14 Swiss_derived @ 10.095490
15 Welsh_derived @ 10.634524
16 French_derived @ 11.582043
17 Orcadian_derived @ 11.612833
18 Romania_derived @ 11.782521
19 Slovenian_derived @ 11.959985
20 Norwegian_V_derived @ 12.221622
Using 2 populations approximation:
1 50% German_derived +50% Italian_North_derived @ 1.761907
Using 3 populations approximation:
1 50% British_derived +25% Sicilian_derived +25% Ukrainian-East_derived @ 0.845483
Using 4 populations approximation:
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
1 French_derived + Italian-Center_derived + Swedish_derived + Ukrainian-West_derived @ 0.596434
2 CEU_V_derived + French_derived + Italian-Center_derived + Russian_V_derived @ 0.714931
3 German-South_derived + Italian-Center_derived + Orcadian_derived + Russian_V_derived @ 0.721766
4 British_derived + German-South_derived + Italian-Center_derived + Russian_V_derived @ 0.740130
5 British_derived + German-North_derived + Sicilian_derived + Slovakian_derived @ 0.748457
6 German-South_derived + Italian-Center_derived + Slovakian_derived + Swedish_derived @ 0.751785
7 French_derived + Italian-Center_derived + Swedish_derived + Ukrainian_V_derived @ 0.766463
8 German-South_derived + Italian-South_derived + Orcadian_derived + Russian_V_derived @ 0.767993
9 Greek_Center_derived + Norwegian_V_derived + Polish_derived + Provancestralal_derived @ 0.787832
10 Italian-North_derived + Macedonian_derived + Norwegian_V_derived + Slovakian_derived @ 0.807775
11 CEU_derived + Sicilian_derived + Ukrainian-West_derived + Welsh_derived @ 0.813111
12 German_derived + Italian-North_derived + Macedonian_derived + Swedish_derived @ 0.818515
13 Belarusian_V_derived + Italian-Center_derived + Provancestralal_derived + Swedish_V_derived @ 0.832687
14 French_derived + Italian-South_derived + Swedish_derived + Ukrainian-Center_derived @ 0.835050
15 Italian-North_derived + Latvian_V_derived + Provancestralal_derived + Swedish_V_derived @ 0.837814
16 Greek_North_derived + Norwegian_V_derived + Russian_South_derived + Spaniard_derived @ 0.839637
17 Ashkenazim_V_derived + German-North_derived + German-South_derived + German_V_derived @ 0.840837
18 French_derived + Italian-Center_derived + Norwegian_V_derived + Ukrainian_derived @ 0.843200
19 French_derived + Italian-Center_derived + Russian_V_derived + Welsh_derived @ 0.843489
20 Greek_North_derived + Provancestralal_derived + Slovakian_derived + Swedish_V_derived @ 0.844747
These seem to work better for me then the eurogenes but this is what I have noticed maybe I am not doing this right. If you can share your results also that would help.
Using 1 population approximation:
1 Croatian @ 3.083339
2 German_South @ 3.913435
3 Hungarian @ 4.167964
4 Belgian @ 5.040628
5 Slovene @ 5.241418
6 Bosnian @ 5.416361
7 English @ 5.712161
8 French @ 6.094639
9 Scottish @ 6.790706
10 Slovak @ 7.166856
11 Moldavian @ 7.185848
12 Orcadian @ 7.257998
13 Serbian @ 7.567864
14 Irish @ 7.652881
15 Utahn_European @ 7.904158
16 German_North @ 9.735929
17 Montenegrin @ 10.588071
18 Romanian @ 12.450385
19 Ukrainian @ 12.457264
20 Macedonian @ 12.637722
Using 2 populations approximation:
1 50% Serbian +50% Utahn_European @ 2.091444
Using 3 populations approximation:
1 50% Irish +25% Italian_Tuscan +25% Slovak @ 1.783508
Using 4 populations approximation:
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
1 Italian_Tuscan + Orcadian + Slovak + Utahn_European @ 1.598939
2 Italian_Tuscan + Scottish + Slovak + Utahn_European @ 1.603395
3 Irish + Italian_Tuscan + Slovak + Utahn_European @ 1.609640
4 English + Italian_Tuscan + Slovak + Utahn_European @ 1.623394
5 Italian_Tuscan + Slovak + Utahn_European + Utahn_European @ 1.648376
6 English + Greek_Thessaly + Utahn_European + Utahn_European @ 1.666144
7 Greek_Thessaly + Scottish + Utahn_European + Utahn_European @ 1.696199
8 Irish + Italian_Tuscan + Slovene + Utahn_European @ 1.705875
9 Albanian + English + Utahn_European + Utahn_European @ 1.708756
10 Italian_Tuscan + Slovene + Utahn_European + Utahn_European @ 1.723197
11 Greek_Thessaly + Utahn_European + Utahn_European + Utahn_European @ 1.723991
12 Italian_Tuscan + Orcadian + Slovene + Utahn_European @ 1.732955
13 Italian_Abruzzo + Norwegian + Utahn_European + Utahn_European @ 1.735682
14 English + Kosovar + Utahn_European + Utahn_European @ 1.737673
15 Albanian + Scottish + Utahn_European + Utahn_European @ 1.737853
16 Greek_Thessaly + Orcadian + Utahn_European + Utahn_European @ 1.737853
17 Greek_Thessaly + Irish + Utahn_European + Utahn_European @ 1.741802
18 Italian_Abruzzo + Norwegian + Orcadian + Utahn_European @ 1.750558
19 Kosovar + Slovene + Utahn_European + Utahn_European @ 1.753423
20 Irish + Italian_Abruzzo + Norwegian + Utahn_European @ 1.754478
Done.
k13 ^
MDLP 22
Least-squares method.
Using 1 population approximation:
1 Bosnian @ 1.893893
2 Croatian @ 3.238915
3 Serbian @ 3.897576
4 Hungarian @ 4.964888
5 Austrian @ 5.532423
6 German-South @ 6.171086
7 German_V @ 6.606912
8 Montenegrin @ 7.006940
9 Slovenian @ 7.017377
10 Macedonian @ 7.465717
11 CEU_V @ 8.640939
12 CEU @ 9.445596
13 Croatian_V @ 9.523872
14 Swiss @ 9.540670
15 British @ 9.776437
16 Czech @ 10.105633
17 Bulgarian @ 10.298981
18 Welsh @ 10.463217
19 German @ 10.543423
20 Orcadian @ 10.734235
Using 2 populations approximation:
1 50% Serbian +50% Croatian @ 0.785756
Using 3 populations approximation:
1 50% German-North +25% Austrian +25% Italian-Center @ 0.721736
Using 4 populations approximation:
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
1 German-North + Swedish + Italian-Center + Croatian @ 0.595666
2 Italian-Center + Croatian + Orcadian + Sorb @ 0.635601
3 Bosnian + Montenegrin + Croatian + Croatian @ 0.649036
4 German-North + Swedish + Greek_East + Croatian @ 0.657119
5 German-North + Macedonian + Macedonian + Croatian @ 0.663759
6 Belarusian_V + Italian-Center + Croatian + British @ 0.693628
7 Greek_East + Croatian + Orcadian + Sorb @ 0.695655
8 Belarusian_V + Italian-Center + Croatian + Orcadian @ 0.704216
9 Polish_V + Italian-Center + Croatian + British @ 0.713017
10 German-North + Montenegrin + Macedonian + Croatian @ 0.717714
11 German-North + Czech + Italian-Center + German_V @ 0.719413
12 German-North + German-North + Austrian + Italian-Center @ 0.721736
13 Bosnian + Swedish + Swedish + Greek_East @ 0.738103
14 German-North + Bulgarian + Serbian + Croatian @ 0.738281
15 German-North + German-South + Italian-Center + Sorb @ 0.740712
16 Italian-Center + Sorb + German_V + German_V @ 0.744632
17 German-North + Russian_South + French + Italian-Center @ 0.751699
18 Bosnian + Polish_V + Italian-Center + Orcadian @ 0.753465
19 Austrian + Italian-Center + Sorb + German_V @ 0.757491
20 Bosnian + Bulgarian + Kosovar + Lithuanian @ 0.761873
Done.
Using 1 population approximation:
1 Serbian_derived @ 4.449430
2 German-South_derived @ 5.660327
3 Montenegrin_derived @ 5.857263
4 Macedonian_derived @ 7.011053
5 German_V_derived @ 7.938296
6 Austrian_derived @ 8.103458
7 Bosnian_derived @ 9.077869
8 Hungarian_derived @ 9.235787
9 CEU_derived @ 9.302048
10 CEU_V_derived @ 9.508316
11 Bulgarian_derived @ 9.566237
12 British_derived @ 9.909520
13 Croatian_derived @ 10.040890
14 Swiss_derived @ 10.095490
15 Welsh_derived @ 10.634524
16 French_derived @ 11.582043
17 Orcadian_derived @ 11.612833
18 Romania_derived @ 11.782521
19 Slovenian_derived @ 11.959985
20 Norwegian_V_derived @ 12.221622
Using 2 populations approximation:
1 50% German_derived +50% Italian_North_derived @ 1.761907
Using 3 populations approximation:
1 50% British_derived +25% Sicilian_derived +25% Ukrainian-East_derived @ 0.845483
Using 4 populations approximation:
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
1 French_derived + Italian-Center_derived + Swedish_derived + Ukrainian-West_derived @ 0.596434
2 CEU_V_derived + French_derived + Italian-Center_derived + Russian_V_derived @ 0.714931
3 German-South_derived + Italian-Center_derived + Orcadian_derived + Russian_V_derived @ 0.721766
4 British_derived + German-South_derived + Italian-Center_derived + Russian_V_derived @ 0.740130
5 British_derived + German-North_derived + Sicilian_derived + Slovakian_derived @ 0.748457
6 German-South_derived + Italian-Center_derived + Slovakian_derived + Swedish_derived @ 0.751785
7 French_derived + Italian-Center_derived + Swedish_derived + Ukrainian_V_derived @ 0.766463
8 German-South_derived + Italian-South_derived + Orcadian_derived + Russian_V_derived @ 0.767993
9 Greek_Center_derived + Norwegian_V_derived + Polish_derived + Provancestralal_derived @ 0.787832
10 Italian-North_derived + Macedonian_derived + Norwegian_V_derived + Slovakian_derived @ 0.807775
11 CEU_derived + Sicilian_derived + Ukrainian-West_derived + Welsh_derived @ 0.813111
12 German_derived + Italian-North_derived + Macedonian_derived + Swedish_derived @ 0.818515
13 Belarusian_V_derived + Italian-Center_derived + Provancestralal_derived + Swedish_V_derived @ 0.832687
14 French_derived + Italian-South_derived + Swedish_derived + Ukrainian-Center_derived @ 0.835050
15 Italian-North_derived + Latvian_V_derived + Provancestralal_derived + Swedish_V_derived @ 0.837814
16 Greek_North_derived + Norwegian_V_derived + Russian_South_derived + Spaniard_derived @ 0.839637
17 Ashkenazim_V_derived + German-North_derived + German-South_derived + German_V_derived @ 0.840837
18 French_derived + Italian-Center_derived + Norwegian_V_derived + Ukrainian_derived @ 0.843200
19 French_derived + Italian-Center_derived + Russian_V_derived + Welsh_derived @ 0.843489
20 Greek_North_derived + Provancestralal_derived + Slovakian_derived + Swedish_V_derived @ 0.844747
These seem to work better for me then the eurogenes but this is what I have noticed maybe I am not doing this right. If you can share your results also that would help.