Stop talking out of ignorance and sour grapes. (God, it's like a flu epidemic.) It's not our fault if you didn't have the foresight to read threads and posts on this site over the years. Maciamo has been saying that R1b was south of the Caucasus and went into the steppe from there since
2009. Did you even know about population genetics in 2009?
The thread where Alan and I argued that much of the culture of the steppe Indo-Europeans came from south of the Caucasus or Neolithic Old Europe dates to
2015. Did you notice that? Or did you miss it? We were discussing Ivanov and Grigoriev even before that, as was Dienekes, back in 2013 and 2014. I got into arguments about it, saying it was a possibility, back on dna-forums.
See:
https://www.eupedia.com/forum/threa...nt-in-the-Caucasus?highlight=Ivanov+Grigoriev
I started the above thread in
2014. (You might want to take a look at my comment number 3 for example.) Where were you posting in 2014?
http://dienekes.blogspot.com/2013/05/stanislav-grigorievs-ancient-indo.html
Dienekes was arguing it in 2013, and because of that subject to what can only be called online bullying. It was disgusting, even if he probably didn't give a damn.
As I said, not my fault, or that of Maciamo, if you only read sites where everybody either hued to the "party" line, or they had to get out.
Now, I wouldn't have said it if you didn't write this rude and delusional post, but the only late comer, wanna be here, buddy, is you.