Archaeology as a political weapon

Completely agreed. But when you are searching for certain information and all you see is nationalistic topics on that subject, maybe... just maybe... you decide to make a comment just to either
a) help you understand that mindset (should a reasonable answer come along)
or
b) maybe make people understand how ridiculous (IMO) they are to pollute a forum designed for genetic research with insignificant opinions regarding man-made phenomena.

I have always viewed nationalism as a weakness. The need to be a part of something bigger without really having direct impact. We all have our weaknesses. But thankfully that is one I do not have. Thanks for your analysis. Am I free to assume you are not a professional in that area?

It’s basic Common sense, a Fancy Degree is not Needed to recognize when somebody is urging for a confrontation instigating a response.
I’m done with this.
 
There is absolutely nothing wrong with being proud of the achievements of one's ancestors, and being attached to the language, culture, and way of life they produced. I'm damn proud of my people, whose strength and resilience in the face of unimaginable hardship is the reason I'm here and breathing, and those people's genes are in my body and help to make me who I am. I guess you're not proud of the hard work and dedication of your parents either, or of your children? You didn't do it, after all.

The only problem arises when that sense of identity, that pride, morphs into a belief not only that your "group" is superior to others, but that this gives you the right to oppress or demean other groups and treat them as "less" human.

This sense of pride need not even derive from membership in a group through blood. I'm damn proud of my adoptive country as well. Does it do everything right? Obviously not. All things created by man are flawed. (Sometimes, Catholic theology is still helpful.) I swell with pride when I read the founding documents of this country, the Declaration of Independence, the writings of Washington, the Federalist papers, the speeches of Abraham Lincoln. Were they perfect men? No, they weren't. Did they deal correctly with slavery? No, they didn't, and the country had to pay the price by fighting a bloody war to settle it. The fact remains that these are milestones in human political development, and anyone should be proud to belong to the group which created them and tries to live up to them. Heck, I'm proud of the work of the various charities I belong to, and not just for the work done under my aegis, but for good work going back decades.

I find this virtue signaling about being part of this post-modern, I'm a citizen of the world, and not some right wing, nationalist extremely unattractive. Some people think being proud of one's country means you disparage others and find that verboten, but have no difficulty disparaging people who are proud of their nationality. If some of you don't feel any attachment to being American, for example, how about you renounce your citizenship and go elsewhere? See if you like it better somewhere else. I had to swear to defend this country and its founding documents to become a citizen. Maybe native born citizens should be required to do the same to renew their citizenship. Imo, this is just more of the I want all the benefits but none of the responsibility attitude that is so pervasive in this post modern world. (I feel the same way about Italian citizenship, btw. All this bunk about it's enough to have some measure of Italian blood is ridiculous. You swear to defend it, or forget about getting the benefits of citizenship.)

As for being a moderator, to my knowledge no one volunteers. One is asked. No one is paid.

Ygorcs is a moderator for a few weeks. He apparently doesn't know yet that it's not necessarily a bed of roses. I've been called every conceivable, vile, pornographic name in the book, a few times in the public section but mostly by pm, by various racist, lunatics drawn to this "hobby", sometimes American, often Balkan or Eastern European. I've been threatened with physical harm, but not to the extent that another moderator had to endure. A certain "member" found this moderator's name and address and threatened him in his home, and also threatened some major event. One nut job had to be referred to the FBI. Our identities are now more shielded.

So, no, not always fun.
I'm also sure that Ygorcs doesn't mean to imply that he doesn't take being a moderator seriously.

Now, enough of this, and back to the topic.

@Firetown,
Looking down on people whom you assume aren't as educated as you are, Firetown? Very unattractive. I thought everyone was supposed to be equal and treated with respect? Or does that only apply to people with whom you agree?

If you're going to play that game, do you want to question my degrees or intellect?

Do not ridicule other members again. Am I clear?
 
It’s basic Common sense, a Fancy Degree is not Needed to recognize when somebody is urging for a confrontation instigating a response.
I’m done with this.
Good. I was done way before you until you instigated a response. And thank you for the negative rep on my reply.
 
@Firetown,
Looking down on people whom you assume aren't as educated as you are, Firetown? Very unattractive. I thought everyone was supposed to be equal and treated with respect? Or does that only apply to people with whom you agree?

If you're going to play that game, do you want to question my degrees or intellect?

Do not ridicule other members again. Am I clear?

Am I clear about what exactly?
 
Good. I was done way before you until you instigated a response. And thank you for the negative rep on my reply.

I don’t remember down voting your post. Probably. Don’t Assume.
People detected Contempt in the way you wrote.
You were also ridiculing the response related to “What a Sense of Belonging Means to Them”!
So be it.
We’ve been warned already to stay on topic.
Forget about it.
 
Thanks and you know what? I often like to keep things simple and say we're all African. Humanity started in Africa, not in Eurasia or anywhere else. I also believe that the true Europeans are the (non human) animal and plant species that originated there. Crazy as it sounds, this makes more sense to me.

"Indo-European" simply means that members of the language (not racial) family spread to India, in the east, and to Europe in the west, that Sanskrit and English, for instance, are kindred languages.
 
I don’t remember down voting your post. Probably. Don’t Assume.
Sorry about that, but someone keeps downvoting my post daily. All is well. I hope that people here understand this is a research based forum. Not an opinion based one.
 
"Indo-European" simply means that members of the language (not racial) family spread to India, in the east, and to Europe in the west, that Sanskrit and English, for instance, are kindred languages.
That is a very simplistic way to put it. Language has something to do with it. But language gets altered. y-DNA and mtDNA pass along differently and more scientifically. As do blood type frequencies.

Added: Sorry again for taking a goof as a serious inquiry.
 
And moderators should not complain about not getting paid. Even though they deleted their posts. If they accept the position, don't complain to regular posters about it, Angela. I have kept the screenshot of what you have posted previously.
 
If you're going to play that game, do you want to question my degrees or intellect?
I do. You never read or examine actual studies. But you fight opinions on what you didn't even examine. Formed based on whatever your mind pre-conceives. Am I clear?
 
I do. You never read or examine actual studies. But you fight opinions on what you didn't even examine. Formed based on whatever your mind pre-conceives. Am I clear?

You better get back on topic, and stop provoking moderators, or I will give you another infraction.
 
You better get back on topic, and stop provoking moderators, or I will give you another infraction.
I was on topic. Until you people threatened to use powers Maciamo once gave you. Don't use that language against me. NO matter how protected you feel here.
 
I was on topic. Until you people threatened to use powers Maciamo once gave you. Don't use that language against me. NO matter how protected you feel here.

If you continue to be disruptive, and harassing, I will have to give you another infraction appropriate for the offense.
 
Stop it right now, or you will rightly receive another infraction. Moderators have been patient, indulgent and even willing to compromise in this topic, so don't play the victim card. You're making no solid argument nor adding anything to the discussion, not even to this off-topic matter. So, I'm pretty sure you will lose nothing if you just cease to post empty ad hominem comments. You've already been warned, you're now just repeating the criticisms you already posted, so what else do you want? To have the last word and get out of this quarrel produly? Okay, then we'll just end this right now and pretend that you had the last word. Case closed. Now back to the topic.
 
What's particularly strange about those Nordicisists is that the vast majority of those I meet are not Russians or Ukrainians from the steppe, but Scandinavians, Germans, Hungarians, even Britons

I've never met a Nordicist in my life, other than those speaking/acting ironically.

Scandinavians also seem pretty normal in that regard.

I find that it's mostly people from states like Latvia and Estonia, perhaps because a) they come from countries which are historically fairly irrelevant, and b) their own culture/history has been distorted or destroyed by years of Communist rule
 
I've never met a Nordicist in my life, other than those speaking/acting ironically.

Scandinavians also seem pretty normal in that regard.

I find that it's mostly people from states like Latvia and Estonia, perhaps because a) they come from countries which are historically fairly irrelevant, and b) their own culture/history has been distorted or destroyed by years of Communist rule

I can't say I have met them personally, but I've seen their comments and "ideas" in forums and comment boards of videos. However, what you say may be true, especially because it seems to me that the traumatic communist experience also meant that such countries didn't have to make much of an "inner social reflection" about those outdated ideologies related to 19th century-style nationalism, ethnic chauvinism or even downright racism. They were preoccupied with a whole new, revolutionary ideology, and didn't go through the same social/cultural dynamics, questionings and eventually a new moral/cultural synthesis that happened in the "West". However, I'll be honest and say that, in fact, it seems to me that, in proportional terms, the largest number of staunch "nordicisists" (which is actually mostly just a disguise for white supremacism in this case, something much more racial than ethnic/cultural), probably comes from North America.
 
^^There are also numerous people of Eastern European extraction, i.e. Russia, Poland, even if they actually come from places as far afield as Australia. We also once had a large contingent of Iberian stormfronters infecting this site, and you get some Italians as well.

I think both Ygorcs and Alcuin's explanations are right on.
 
Archeology is definitely political. In the intro to Arthur Evans' book "Illyria" its mentioned that there are photographs he took of some roman inscriptions in Kosova that Serbia later destroyed once it got power. Arthur Evans for those who dont know is the
discoverer of Knossos:

5VeFFmP.png
 

This thread has been viewed 30080 times.

Back
Top