I was not talking about the origin of Hamangia ( anatolian origin? just as likely as an autochthonous one).....just try to remind everybody of the deep cultural influence of Old europe on the steppe cultural ethnogenesis.....every time I posted quoting Manzura on various blogs that was often met with mockery and derision.
By the way you are aware that WHG had a deep impact in Anatolia to form the ANF?
I didn't say it was a certainty that Hamangia was very influenced by Anatolia, but there are certainly very good indications of it.
No, WHG didn't have a deep impact in Anatolia. First of all, it wasn't precisely WHG, but an UHG similar to WHG, and second of all, it was a minor part of their ancestry. The technology also spread from Anatolia into Europe, not the other way around.
These things are all well known.
You are, however, making my point for me. You can trace parts of every culture back to other cultures. So what? It is the particulars of each separate case which must be examined as objectively as possible.
You're talking about a very specific time and place.
The archaeology and genetics are clear. Yes, steppe people borrowed a great deal culturally from the cultures around them, both those in "Old Europe" and those from south of the Caucasus.
Yes, there are indications from archaeology of the movement of people from "Old Europe" onto the western steppe. However, we know from genetics that the autosomal impact was small. We also know the yline impact was small.
The question then becomes, how likely is it that such a small movement of people, even if they were an elite group, could effectuate language change. The answer is that it's possible but rather unlikely.
It becomes even more unlikely because the earliest reconstructed Indo-European vocabulary doesn't contain words for agriculture, and the people of Old Europe were totally dependent on it, and their ancestors, in fact, brought it to Europe.
Given all of this, I'm not surprised that your "theory" has not been accepted by other people. Of course, that doesn't excuse any incivility that you were shown.