Alan
Elite member
- Messages
- 2,517
- Reaction score
- 450
- Points
- 0
- Ethnic group
- Kurdish
- Y-DNA haplogroup
- R1a1a1
- mtDNA haplogroup
- HV2a1 +G13708A
I don't understand how people can connect every expansion of genetic populations such as CHG/Iran_Meso, EHG, WHG to a single language family.
Like for real those components are as far as of mesolithic age!
That means some parts of the Near East could be full of non-IE-CHG population but still live just few hundred miles next to IE-speaking CHG folks.
The same with EHG groups. EHG could be very much the major component among Finno_Ugric, IE and god knows what else kind of people.
I have to roll with my eyes every time I hear that freakn argument "but but but, the region was full of non-IE pred. CHG populations such as Hurrians(while the origin of Hurrians is still on debate) how can CHG be PIE?" Like seriously? We are talking about Mesolithic time components, thats roughly 12000 years of time people.
Like for real those components are as far as of mesolithic age!
That means some parts of the Near East could be full of non-IE-CHG population but still live just few hundred miles next to IE-speaking CHG folks.
The same with EHG groups. EHG could be very much the major component among Finno_Ugric, IE and god knows what else kind of people.
I have to roll with my eyes every time I hear that freakn argument "but but but, the region was full of non-IE pred. CHG populations such as Hurrians(while the origin of Hurrians is still on debate) how can CHG be PIE?" Like seriously? We are talking about Mesolithic time components, thats roughly 12000 years of time people.
Last edited: