Excine
Regular Member
- Messages
- 376
- Reaction score
- 153
- Points
- 43
- Ethnic group
- Albanian
- Y-DNA haplogroup
- E-FT19186
- mtDNA haplogroup
- H2a1c
Hello Hawk,
In your opinion, what is preventing scientists in the Balkans (or anyone else) from finding and examining Ancient Illyrian skeletons to 1) Analyze their DNA 2) Compare to modern populations 3) Close the gaps of historical disagreements through science? Perhaps lack of funding or not enough interest?
I've skimmed over these forums to discover fascinating theories on Illyrians, especially your comments regarding the Albanian ethnogenesis, but I believe nothing will be objectively and undeniably agreed upon unless DNA evidence is brought into the picture. Otherwise, it's the Albanian theory vs Skeptic theory; a never ending (and often volatile) discussion.
For example, two recent studies show that Albanians have some continuity with Thracians and Mycenaeans, which is what we have always known (that Albanians are Paleo-Balkan), but up until then, many historians, especially those from particular countries in Europe, have denied Albanian Paleo-Balkan origins in favour of more pseudoscientific explanations to muddy the waters of history.
For this reason, I would like to know how much credibility the Illyrian theories have, and even better, why not find DNA to solve the discussion once and for all?
Sorry if this is an inappropriate thread to ask or if I've deviated from the rules at all by not opening a new thread.
It's my first time commenting here.
I'm not sure where you saw this or who told you about these "studies" but no such studies exist. This is something which you can spot yourself very easily by checking the distance between Albanians and Mycenaeans.