ROFL
don't know what you are upset about......just supplying historical fact
your an afghan.....what do you know !!!
Historical facts state there were Illyrians in modern Albania.
But thanks for exposing yourself for what you are..
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature currently requires accessing the site using the built-in Safari browser.
ROFL
don't know what you are upset about......just supplying historical fact
your an afghan.....what do you know !!!
what are you talking about......i asked him for more informationHistorical facts state there were Illyrians in modern Albania.
But thanks for exposing yourself for what you are..
Considering the high number of Proto-Illyrian/Illyrian samples we have the "theory" that E1b majorly spread with Illyrians or somehow was a major Illyrian haplogroup is totally debunked. No serious persona continues to claim such a thing except for the Maleschreiber/Bruzmi Wikipedia internet enthusiast. The phylogeny of the Albanian E1b clades does not support such a scenario either. You've made your repetitive "points", you can move on now.In any case, it is unnecessary to address E-V13 in such broad terms. We will determine the location of the Albanian clades. Most likely among Illyrians, like the Dardanians, but we'll see. I feel that southern Illyrians should also have E-V13 haplogroup, as it is just as Proto-Albanian as the other haplogroups found among Proto-Albanians, as per SA.
Dardania (Kosovo, S. Serbia, N. Macedonia), & Bosnia, which are Illyrian, haven't been tested yet, so the theory isn't "totally debunked". Both areas are near the Danube, near the Morava, Sava, and Drina rivers, which all lead into Albanian territory. Those regions need to be tested and then we'll see. We don't have enough samples of E-V13 in general either, once we get some samples from these regions which are close to today's Albania, we'll probably see some E-V13 clades that match with Albanians. Like how there was E-V13 in Croatia, maybe there will be in Bosnia or Dardania. If some Thracians joined the Illyrians in these areas, maybe they were buried in a mound instead of cremated, etc, there's many possibilities, the theory is still open until we get more samples.Considering the high number of Proto-Illyrian/Illyrian samples we have the "theory" that E1b majorly spread with Illyrians or somehow was a major Illyrian haplogroup is totally debunked. No serious persona continues to claim such a thing except for the Maleschreiber/Bruzmi Wikipedia internet enthusiast. The phylogeny of the Albanian E1b clades does not support such a scenario either. You've made your repetitive "points", you can move on now.
Dardania (Kosovo, S. Serbia, N. Macedonia), & Bosnia, which are Illyrian
Thracian -para possibly related to Albanian. farë which is cognate with Greek. spore, the loss of the s in /sp/ was part of the transition to -> /f/ as in "fjalë", cognate with English. spell. /sp/ became /f/ in Albanian.
Thracian -para could have therefore originally meant clan (seed to clan/tribe) and come to mean settlement.
For example of this semantic transition, Albanian. vis (settlement, area) compared to cognate "Aryan Vissa" in Sanskrit (which means Aryan Clans).
Bessapara (Besë+fara)
Buiapara (Buaj + fara) (compare Bua tribe in Albanian)
Dardapara (Dardhë + fara) (two such settlements)
Brentopara (Brina + fara)
Briparon (Bri + fara)
Drusipara (Dru + fara)
Busipara (Buzë + fara)
-deva possibly related to an inflection of Albanian. dhe meaning settlement/village? Compare Atdheu (fatherland).
Murideva (Mur + dheu)
Burrideva (Burrë + dheu)
Perburridava (Për + Burrë + dheu)
Burri tribe cognate with Albanian. Burrë
There is the Thracian and Dacian name Diegis connection to Albanian. Djeg
There is the Thracian name Drenis connection to Albanian. Dren
Dacian. Amalusta (camomile) Albanian. Ambël
Dacian. Drubetis cognate with Albanian. Dru
Dacian. Karpates cognate with Albanian. Karpë
Dacian. Zermi-sirga cognate with Albanian. Zjerm
Dacian. Mantua (mulberry) cognate with Albanian. man (mulberry)
Dacian. Maluensis cognate with Albanian. Mal
Dacian. Patavissa cognate with Albanin. vis
Dacian. Polondova which later became Pelendova matches proto-Albanian. pol-na which became Albanian. pelë
There is the Dacian god: Vet-sopios, Ouet-sopios, the first part is cognate with Albanian. vetë, translation of Greek. Auto+hyppos
Wow, we don't have a single Thracian text and yet so many Albanian cognates appear among the Thracians and Dacians, this must mean that Albanian is Thracian.
But actually, since Albanian shares the most exclusive words with Baltic only and no other IE language, this must actually mean that the Baltic language is Albanian.
I hope my point has been made. Language descendance is not established by cognates, since Thracian also has cognates with Albanian, but by phonology.
Matzinger himself openly makes comparisons between Illyrian and Albanian as is shown in the case of Dimale, Dallendyshe, etc, but he is still arguing that the phonological system of Albanian and Illyrian are of two different languages.
Also, it is easy to cherry pick some names and torture a comparison with Albanian out of them, but there are countless Illyrian names which have no Albanian etymology:
Skerdilaidas
Clevatus
Longarus
Abozika
Adana
Birkenna
Plator
Koreta
Etleva
Ettuta
Ettritos
Glavus
Grabos
Grabon
Langaros
Laudos
Lydra
Madena
Mallika
Mannikos
Monounios
Pinnes
Pleuratos
Preurat/dos
Skeneta
Temus
Titos
Trauzos
Trauzina
Verzan
Verzas
Khortas
Zaimina
Zaimios
Thracian -para possibly related to Albanian. farë which is cognate with Greek. spore, the loss of the s in /sp/ was part of the transition to -> /f/ as in "fjalë", cognate with English. spell. /sp/ became /f/ in Albanian.
Thracian -para could have therefore originally meant clan (seed to clan/tribe) and come to mean settlement.
For example of this semantic transition, Albanian. vis (settlement, area) compared to cognate "Aryan Vissa" in Sanskrit (which means Aryan Clans).
Bessapara (Besë+fara)
Buiapara (Buaj + fara) (compare Bua tribe in Albanian)
Dardapara (Dardhë + fara) (two such settlements)
Brentopara (Brina + fara)
Briparon (Bri + fara)
Drusipara (Dru + fara)
Busipara (Buzë + fara)
-deva possibly related to an inflection of Albanian. dhe meaning settlement/village? Compare Atdheu (fatherland).
Murideva (Mur + dheu)
Burrideva (Burrë + dheu)
Perburridava (Për + Burrë + dheu)
Burri tribe cognate with Albanian. Burrë
There is the Thracian and Dacian name Diegis connection to Albanian. Djeg
There is the Thracian name Drenis connection to Albanian. Dren
Dacian. Amalusta (camomile) Albanian. Ambël
Dacian. Drubetis cognate with Albanian. Dru
Dacian. Karpates cognate with Albanian. Karpë
Dacian. Zermi-sirga cognate with Albanian. Zjerm
Dacian. Mantua (mulberry) cognate with Albanian. man (mulberry)
Dacian. Maluensis cognate with Albanian. Mal
Dacian. Patavissa cognate with Albanin. vis
Dacian. Polondova which later became Pelendova matches proto-Albanian. pol-na which became Albanian. pelë
There is the Dacian god: Vet-sopios, Ouet-sopios, the first part is cognate with Albanian. vetë, translation of Greek. Auto+hyppos
Wow, we don't have a single Thracian text and yet so many Albanian cognates appear among the Thracians and Dacians, this must mean that Albanian is Thracian.
But actually, since Albanian shares the most exclusive words with Baltic only and no other IE language, this must actually mean that the Baltic language is Albanian.
I hope my point has been made. Language descendance is not established by cognates, since Thracian also has cognates with Albanian, but by phonology.
Matzinger himself openly makes comparisons between Illyrian and Albanian as is shown in the case of Dimale, Dallendyshe, etc, but he is still arguing that the phonological system of Albanian and Illyrian are of two different languages.
Also, it is easy to cherry pick some names and torture a comparison with Albanian out of them, but there are countless Illyrian names which have no Albanian etymology:
Skerdilaidas
Clevatus
Longarus
Abozika
Adana
Birkenna
Plator
Koreta
Etleva
Ettuta
Ettritos
Glavus
Grabos
Grabon
Langaros
Laudos
Lydra
Madena
Mallika
Mannikos
Monounios
Pinnes
Pleuratos
Preurat/dos
Skeneta
Temus
Titos
Trauzos
Trauzina
Verzan
Verzas
Khortas
Zaimina
Zaimios
If we compare the evolution of Albanian farë (seed) we see a stage where it is at "phara".
If we imagine Thracian having a common ancestor that shared this path to a point, the semantic and phonetic transformation for the -para suffix might be possible
PAlb. *sparā > *psarā >*pharā> farë
Considering the high number of Proto-Illyrian/Illyrian samples we have the "theory" that E1b majorly spread with Illyrians or somehow was a major Illyrian haplogroup is totally debunked. No serious persona continues to claim such a thing except for the Maleschreiber/Bruzmi Wikipedia internet enthusiast. The phylogeny of the Albanian E1b clades does not support such a scenario either. You've made your repetitive "points", you can move on now.
Some Illyrian names might not have any known Albanian etymology but I personally do not see how -para -dava etc have Albanian etymology ... Bessapara means nothing in Albanian which was a Thracian placename called 'Fort of the Bessi' or something like 'Petersborough' .
Also Bulgaria Iron Age is way more Southern shifted
Nice try! -para in Thracian is the equivalent of -polis in Greek. Fara is the tribe, the clan. From what we know about Thracians they never had the close, endogamous clans of the Albanians. There was plenty of land to be had so they did not have to safeguard it so close.
Some of these names including the ones Johane Derite listed can actually be explained in Albanian but of course it would only be speculation such as the name 'Bindus' 'Binhdo' from Albanian ''Bindur' 'Bind' which means 'Convince / Convinced' .
The semantic transformation from tribe to settlement exists. Albanian. vis (settlement) [compare Dacian patavissa] and Arya Vissa from rigveda meaning "Aryan Clans".
This thread has been viewed 598163 times.