Hello bigsnake49
You said you took the autosomal test on MyHeritage. This company tests several Y chromosome SNPs. Just unzip the excel spreadsheet from the .zip (raw data) file and at the end of the excel spreadsheet unziped you will see that several Y chromosome SNPs have been tested.
You can try do the test manually. Look at this example of mine through messages exchanged in another thread with the member Regio X and see that, precisely, I was able (and you can too) to determine that my basal haplogroup is R-P310.
Big hug
Thanks.
Unfortunately, it seems MyHeritage doesn't test for R1b1a1b1 nor R1b1a1b2. If I understand him right, he would have tested positive for L23, and again, MyHeritage wouldn't test the subclades R1b1a1b1a nor R1b1a1b1b. So I guess it remains only P310 for him to check using MyHeritage data.
The problem with LivingDNA is that they list only the SNPs for which the member tested positive, i.e., we don't know what SNPs were tested exactly, which would allow us to infer results. And that's not the only problem, 'cause sometimes their assignments are not the best, either because there's an error of phylogeny or due to another unkwnon reason. For example, LivingDNA says he's R1b-M269, but the very LivingDNA data would suggest he's also R1b-L23, according to Bigsnake himself. And there are more examples. I know of two guys who were assigned as G-Z1817 by LivingDNA, while their list of SNPs did include the downstream Z727. For a moment I thought they belonged to a relatively rare sister clade of G-Z727, but then I realized it was not the case.
LivingDNA should report relevant negative results as well, or at least provide a Raw Data with Y-DNA info. Pity.
Bigsnake could search the following SNPs in LivingDNA list of positive results (still, we couldn't infer results through negative results for downstream SNPs, because the negative are not listed AFAIK) :
R1b1a1b1 --->
L23/PF6534/S141, L478/PF6403, PF6404
R1b1a1b1a --->
L51/M412/PF6536/S167, CTS8595/YSC0001291
R1b1a1b1b --->
CTS1078/Z2103, CTS7340/Z2107, M12149/Y4371/Z8128, M12132/Z8127, CTS9416, PF7575/Z2104, PF7585, S20902, Z2105
R1b1a1b2 --->
PF7558, BY856/GG490/Y19696, BY1713/FGC31957/GG731/Z29759, BY2098/FGC31966/GG815/Z29761, FGC31927/GG428, FGC31931/GG483/V2381, GG439/PF7562, GG572/PH1631/V2850, PH134
The source is ISOGG 2019. I haven't checked YFull.