Beginning of Proto-Indo-European Language

[kmak]

What Y DNA is beginning of Proto-Indo-European language? R1a or R1b or R1a and R1b.

 

[bicicleur 2]

Khvalynsk.
Mainly R1b-V1636 and some R1b-P297, R1a, Q1a, I2a2 and J

 

[kmak]

Khvalynsk.
Mainly R1b-V1636 and some R1b-P297, R1a, Q1a, I2a2 and J

PIE is from EHG languages. This making PIE is both R1a and R1b?

 

[Anfänger]

Kmak are you a Troll ? You are asking the same question in all of your posts.