Classify Me/Where can I Pass

I don't think you'd look too out of place in Albania. The brachycephalic head and elongated mid-face section give a pseudo-Balkanoid look.
 
Hmm, another east med guess. Interesting. No east med recent ancestry that I know of.
I made a thread about illustrativedna but some who view this may not have seen it. I'll post my top 5 2-way modern and some ancient 2-way combinations.

Fit: 1.719​

1.​


Irish 70.7%

Italian (Aosta Valley) 29.3%


Fit: 1.734​

2.​


Irish 76.7%

Spanish (Navarre) 23.3%


Fit: 1.746​

3.​


Irish 68.8%

Swiss (French) 31.2%

Fit: 1.747

4.


Scottish 78.6%

Spanish (Navarre) 21.4%

Fit: 1.756

5.


French Occitan (Provence) 27.8%

Irish 72.2%




Iron Age:

Fit: 1.978

1.

91.3% 8.7%

Insular Celt (Parisi)

Archaic Greek (Kastrouli)


Fit: 1.985

2.

89.6% 10.4%

Insular Celt (Brigantes)​

Archaic Greek (Kastrouli)​


Fit: 2.108​

47.​


87.6% 12.4%

Insular Celt (Parisi)​

Latin (Latium)​


Fit: 2.109​

48.​


96.1% 3.9%

Insular Celt (Dobunni)​

Israelite (Megiddo)​



Roman period:

Fit: 2.044​

1.​

37.2% 62.8%

North Rhine (Merovingian Period)​

Insular Celt (Roman Period)​


Fit: 2.049​

2.​

66.6% 33.4%

Insular Celt (Roman Period)​

Gallo-Roman​


Fit: 2.192​

37.​


95.6% 4.4%

Insular Celt (Roman Period)​

Egyptian (Roman Period)​



Fit: 2.199​

38.​

94.3% 5.7%

Insular Celt (Roman Period)​

Imperial Roman (Pompeii)​


4 way:

Insular Celt (AD 100–1000) 80.2%

Germanic (AD 100–630) 9.8%

Roman Anatolia (100 BC–AD 700) 5.6%

Sardinian (AD 770–1000) 4.4%
 
British Italian or British Greek.
That's interesting because that's what 2-way ancient admix calculators like to assign. By now you've probably seen my other posts where I've linked the results in this thread.
 
Dnagenics AI Predicted appearance:

1712096950022.png
1712096978714.png
They should have provided a skin tone pallet for the predicted skin tone. I'm not sure what light olive is. In my mind I can see the range of what olive is though.
 
Last edited:
I would say English, French, or Spanish.
 
With ethnivision ChatGPT let’s see what it says.

Ethnicity predictions?

Based on the image provided, the individual appears to have a light skin tone, which suggests a likely classification as South European or Middle Eastern. The features do not strongly indicate any other specific ethnic background.

What ethnicity am I?

ChatGPT said:​

GPT

Determining your exact ethnicity based solely on appearance is challenging, as physical traits can overlap significantly across different regions due to the complex history of human migration and genetic mixing. However, based on your features as discussed—dark hair, light to medium skin tone, defined facial structure, and Mediterranean traits—you likely have an ancestry that includes one or more of the following regions:

  1. Southern European: Countries like Italy, Greece, Spain, and Portugal, where these traits are commonly observed.
  2. Middle Eastern: This could include countries like Lebanon, Syria, Turkey, and Israel, where Mediterranean and Middle Eastern features blend.
  3. Balkan: Albania, Serbia, and Croatia often share similar features, reflecting a mix of European and Mediterranean influences.
  4. Caucasus Region: Armenia, Georgia, and Azerbaijan, where Mediterranean and Middle Eastern traits frequently overlap.
  5. North African (Coastal): Especially in places like Morocco, Algeria, and Tunisia, where Mediterranean features are common due to historical European and Middle Eastern influences.
  6. Ashkenazi or Sephardic Jewish: These communities often exhibit Mediterranean and Eastern European traits, including those seen in your appearance.
Your ancestry could be a blend of these regions, reflecting the interconnected nature of populations around the Mediterranean and adjacent areas. To pinpoint your exact ethnic background, a detailed family history or genetic testing would provide a more accurate picture, as visual assessment alone can't capture the full complexity of an individual's heritage.

Ancestry guesses?

ChatGPT said:​

GPT

Based on the visual characteristics of the individual, potential ancestry guesses could include a mix of the following:

  1. Southern European Ancestry: Likely from countries such as Italy, Greece, Spain, or Portugal, where the combination of light skin, dark hair, and defined facial features are common.
  2. Balkan Ancestry: Possible links to Albania, Croatia, Serbia, or Bosnia, where similar Mediterranean and South European traits are observed.
  3. Middle Eastern Influence: There could also be a minor Middle Eastern or Eastern Mediterranean influence, particularly from countries like Turkey or Lebanon, where similar facial structures and coloring are often seen.
These guesses reflect the broader genetic diversity found in Southern Europe and the surrounding regions, suggesting a blend rather than a specific pinpointed ancestry.

Expanding further on potential ethnicity guesses, here are some additional possibilities based on the observed features:

  1. Spanish (particularly Basque or Catalan): These regions have distinct facial features that can include a Mediterranean look with light skin and dark hair, fitting the individual’s appearance.
  2. Portuguese: Similar Mediterranean and Atlantic features, common in both northern and southern regions of Portugal, align well with the individual’s look.
  3. Italian (Sicilian or Southern Italy): Sicily and Southern Italy have a rich mix of Mediterranean and Middle Eastern influences, matching the observed features.
  4. Greek (including Crete or other islands): Greece, particularly its islands, exhibits a blend of European and Middle Eastern traits with dark hair and defined features.
  5. Maltese: Malta has a unique mix of Southern European and North African ancestry, leading to Mediterranean features similar to those observed.
  6. Cypriot (Greek Cypriot or Turkish Cypriot): The blend of Mediterranean and Middle Eastern characteristics is common in Cyprus, fitting well with the individual’s appearance.
  7. Levantine Arab (Jordanian, Palestinian, or Syrian): This region often features similar skin tone and facial features, blending Mediterranean and Middle Eastern ancestry.
These additional guesses highlight the shared characteristics across a wide range of regions, reflecting the genetic and cultural diversity of Mediterranean and adjacent areas.

Could the person in the photo be classified as having the gracile Mediterranean phenotype?

ChatGPT said:​

GPT

Yes, the individual in the photo could be classified as having the gracile Mediterranean phenotype. The gracile Mediterranean type is characterized by:

  1. Facial Structure: Typically includes an oval or slightly elongated face with a refined, delicate bone structure and moderate cheekbones. This description aligns well with the individual’s facial shape, which appears balanced and refined.
  2. Nose: A straight or slightly curved nose is common in the gracile Mediterranean phenotype, matching the individual's nasal features observed in the photo.
  3. Skin Tone: Usually ranges from light olive to medium, which fits the observed skin tone of the individual—light but with a hint of warmth that is often seen in Mediterranean populations.
  4. Hair and Eye Color: Dark hair and eyes are typical of this phenotype, which is consistent with the person’s appearance.
  5. Overall Build: The term "gracile" refers to a lighter, more slender build as opposed to more robust or heavyset forms seen in other Mediterranean subtypes.
This phenotype is commonly found in regions surrounding the Mediterranean Sea, including Southern Europe (Italy, Greece, Spain), the Levant (Lebanon, Syria), and North Africa (particularly coastal areas). The features of the individual align well with these traits, supporting the classification within the gracile Mediterranean phenotype.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_2510.jpeg
    IMG_2510.jpeg
    610.3 KB · Views: 14
  • IMG_2065.jpeg
    IMG_2065.jpeg
    90 KB · Views: 12
Last edited:
With ethnivision ChatGPT let’s see what it says.

Ethnicity predictions?

Based on the image provided, the individual appears to have a light skin tone, which suggests a likely classification as South European or Middle Eastern. The features do not strongly indicate any other specific ethnic background.

What ethnicity am I?

ChatGPT said:​

GPT

Determining your exact ethnicity based solely on appearance is challenging, as physical traits can overlap significantly across different regions due to the complex history of human migration and genetic mixing. However, based on your features as discussed—dark hair, light to medium skin tone, defined facial structure, and Mediterranean traits—you likely have an ancestry that includes one or more of the following regions:

  1. Southern European: Countries like Italy, Greece, Spain, and Portugal, where these traits are commonly observed.
  2. Middle Eastern: This could include countries like Lebanon, Syria, Turkey, and Israel, where Mediterranean and Middle Eastern features blend.
  3. Balkan: Albania, Serbia, and Croatia often share similar features, reflecting a mix of European and Mediterranean influences.
  4. Caucasus Region: Armenia, Georgia, and Azerbaijan, where Mediterranean and Middle Eastern traits frequently overlap.
  5. North African (Coastal): Especially in places like Morocco, Algeria, and Tunisia, where Mediterranean features are common due to historical European and Middle Eastern influences.
  6. Ashkenazi or Sephardic Jewish: These communities often exhibit Mediterranean and Eastern European traits, including those seen in your appearance.
Your ancestry could be a blend of these regions, reflecting the interconnected nature of populations around the Mediterranean and adjacent areas. To pinpoint your exact ethnic background, a detailed family history or genetic testing would provide a more accurate picture, as visual assessment alone can't capture the full complexity of an individual's heritage.

Ancestry guesses?

ChatGPT said:​

GPT

Based on the visual characteristics of the individual, potential ancestry guesses could include a mix of the following:

  1. Southern European Ancestry: Likely from countries such as Italy, Greece, Spain, or Portugal, where the combination of light skin, dark hair, and defined facial features are common.
  2. Balkan Ancestry: Possible links to Albania, Croatia, Serbia, or Bosnia, where similar Mediterranean and South European traits are observed.
  3. Middle Eastern Influence: There could also be a minor Middle Eastern or Eastern Mediterranean influence, particularly from countries like Turkey or Lebanon, where similar facial structures and coloring are often seen.
These guesses reflect the broader genetic diversity found in Southern Europe and the surrounding regions, suggesting a blend rather than a specific pinpointed ancestry.

Expanding further on potential ethnicity guesses, here are some additional possibilities based on the observed features:

  1. Spanish (particularly Basque or Catalan): These regions have distinct facial features that can include a Mediterranean look with light skin and dark hair, fitting the individual’s appearance.
  2. Portuguese: Similar Mediterranean and Atlantic features, common in both northern and southern regions of Portugal, align well with the individual’s look.
  3. Italian (Sicilian or Southern Italy): Sicily and Southern Italy have a rich mix of Mediterranean and Middle Eastern influences, matching the observed features.
  4. Greek (including Crete or other islands): Greece, particularly its islands, exhibits a blend of European and Middle Eastern traits with dark hair and defined features.
  5. Maltese: Malta has a unique mix of Southern European and North African ancestry, leading to Mediterranean features similar to those observed.
  6. Cypriot (Greek Cypriot or Turkish Cypriot): The blend of Mediterranean and Middle Eastern characteristics is common in Cyprus, fitting well with the individual’s appearance.
  7. Levantine Arab (Jordanian, Palestinian, or Syrian): This region often features similar skin tone and facial features, blending Mediterranean and Middle Eastern ancestry.
These additional guesses highlight the shared characteristics across a wide range of regions, reflecting the genetic and cultural diversity of Mediterranean and adjacent areas.

Could the person in the photo be classified as having the gracile Mediterranean phenotype?

ChatGPT said:​

GPT

Yes, the individual in the photo could be classified as having the gracile Mediterranean phenotype. The gracile Mediterranean type is characterized by:

  1. Facial Structure: Typically includes an oval or slightly elongated face with a refined, delicate bone structure and moderate cheekbones. This description aligns well with the individual’s facial shape, which appears balanced and refined.
  2. Nose: A straight or slightly curved nose is common in the gracile Mediterranean phenotype, matching the individual's nasal features observed in the photo.
  3. Skin Tone: Usually ranges from light olive to medium, which fits the observed skin tone of the individual—light but with a hint of warmth that is often seen in Mediterranean populations.
  4. Hair and Eye Color: Dark hair and eyes are typical of this phenotype, which is consistent with the person’s appearance.
  5. Overall Build: The term "gracile" refers to a lighter, more slender build as opposed to more robust or heavyset forms seen in other Mediterranean subtypes.
This phenotype is commonly found in regions surrounding the Mediterranean Sea, including Southern Europe (Italy, Greece, Spain), the Levant (Lebanon, Syria), and North Africa (particularly coastal areas). The features of the individual align well with these traits, supporting the classification within the gracile Mediterranean phenotype.
All these vague descriptions added to the real aspect of your face show the little confidence we may have in these pseudo-analysis: the only serious common trait we can find is tied to the concept of 'gracility' but this trait itself has to be put in a context: today (and it began long time ago) there is a trend towards gracility in all types, with a lost of head size particularly. This doesn't erase totally the ancient differences between types but complicate things. Concerning colours and hues, I 'm amazed people don't know we cannot rely on isolated pics!
 
All these vague descriptions added to the real aspect of your face show the little confidence we may have in these pseudo-analysis: the only serious common trait we can find is tied to the concept of 'gracility' but this trait itself has to be put in a context: today (and it began long time ago) there is a trend towards gracility in all types, with a lost of head size particularly. This doesn't erase totally the ancient differences between types but complicate things. Concerning colours and hues, I 'm amazed people don't know we cannot rely on isolated pics!
Those weren't the only two photos that I had it look at. I had it analyze the bottom 2 plus the beginning photos from my original post and the lighting does vary a bit from all of them. I'm not sure if it has the capability to analyze people in video but I suspect it would come to the same conclusions. I pressed it on this and long story short it said European and human genetics in general are complicated. I won't share it unless you all want to see what it says. I wish that it would have gotten into more detail. It's fun little tool to play with when one is bored.

Edit: actually, if you know what questions to ask the ai can get more detailed. If you ask for eye and nose analysis it will provide it.
 
Last edited:
Those weren't the only two photos that I had it look at. I had it analyze the bottom 2 plus the beginning photos from my original post and the lighting does vary a bit from all of them. I'm not sure if it has the capability to analyze people in video but I suspect it would come to the same conclusions. I pressed it on this and long story short it said European and human genetics in general are complicated. I won't share it unless you all want to see what it says. I wish that it would have gotten into more detail. It's fun little tool to play with when one is bored.

Edit: actually, if you know what questions to ask the ai can get more detailed. If you ask for eye and nose analysis it will provide it.
I expressed badly myself. When I wrote isolated pics I want say: pics where a person is alone.
 
I expressed badly myself. When I wrote isolated pics I want say: pics where a person is alone.
I submitted a photo of myself with two other people in the photo. I'm the "person on the left"

what are the ethnicities of the 3 people in the photo?

ChatGPT said:​

GPT

Based on the visual appearance of the three individuals in the photo:

  1. Person on the left: Appears to be South European or Middle Eastern, with light to medium skin tone and dark hair.
  2. Person in the middle: Appears to be Caucasian, with light skin tone, facial hair, and wearing a cap.
  3. Person on the right: Appears to be Caucasian, with light skin tone, and wearing glasses and a cap.
These assessments are based solely on visual cues and may not accurately represent their actual ethnic backgrounds.

ignore the hairstyle, hair color, skin tone and eye color. Still come to southern European or middle eastern guess?

ChatGPT said:​

GPT

Ignoring hairstyle, hair color, skin tone, and eye color, the identification of the person on the left as possibly Southern European or Middle Eastern is still suggested by other facial characteristics and structural elements:

  1. Facial Structure:
    • The person's face exhibits certain sharpness and angularity, with defined cheekbones and a jawline that is slightly pronounced. These features are common among individuals from Southern Europe and the Middle East, where facial bones often present with more pronounced contours.
  2. Nose Shape:
    • The nose appears slightly more defined and prominent, a characteristic often observed in people of Mediterranean and Middle Eastern descent. This trait can differ from the smaller or more delicate nasal shapes commonly seen in Northern European populations.
  3. Eyebrow Shape and Density:
    • Even without considering color, the thickness and arch of the eyebrows suggest Mediterranean influence, where brows are typically fuller and more prominent.
  4. Facial Symmetry and Proportions:
    • The balance between facial features, such as the spacing of the eyes, the width of the face, and the proportional alignment of the nose and mouth, align with Southern European or Middle Eastern phenotypes, which often showcase balanced but slightly wider facial proportions compared to the narrower, more elongated features typical of Northern European ancestry.
  5. Jawline and Chin:
    • His jawline has a slightly rounded yet strong shape, without the squarer, heavier set often seen in Northern Europeans, aligning more with Mediterranean aesthetics.
These combined structural elements still support a Southern European or Middle Eastern guess, independent of hair, skin, or eye color considerations. However, it’s important to note that these are generalized observations and individual variation is always significant.

Eye shape also taken into account?

ChatGPT said:​

GPT

Yes, eye shape is an important feature that can also contribute to the assessment of someone's ethnicity, and it plays a role in identifying possible Southern European or Middle Eastern descent for the person on the left. Here’s how eye shape factors into the analysis:

  1. Almond Shape:
    • The individual’s eyes appear to have an almond shape, which is a common feature among Southern Europeans and Middle Eastern populations. This shape is often characterized by a slightly elongated eye that tapers at the corners, giving a subtle lift or slant that contrasts with the more rounded or deep-set eyes often seen in Northern Europeans.
  2. Eye Position and Set:
    • The eyes seem relatively close-set with a slight tilt upwards or sideways, which is often found in Mediterranean and Middle Eastern individuals. This feature can give the eyes a distinctive, slightly intense or focused look that is less common in other European populations.
  3. Eyelid Structure:
    • The presence of slightly fuller eyelids or less pronounced creases can also be an indicator, as this is more frequently observed in people from Middle Eastern and Mediterranean regions compared to the more pronounced eyelid folds typical of Northern European ancestry.
  4. Overall Eye Expression:
    • The combination of shape, set, and subtle brow structure often gives the eyes an expressive or deep-set appearance that aligns with the ethnic characteristics of Southern Europe and the Middle East.
These aspects of eye shape and positioning contribute to the overall assessment of the person’s possible ethnic background, reinforcing the Southern European or Middle Eastern guess even when ignoring other features like hair color or skin tone.

Nose details?

ChatGPT said:​

GPT

When considering the nose structure of the person on the left, several characteristics can hint towards Southern European or Middle Eastern descent:

  1. Nose Bridge:
    • The nose bridge appears slightly higher and more defined, which is a common trait among individuals of Mediterranean and Middle Eastern descent. This feature contrasts with the flatter nose bridges often seen in Northern and some Western European populations.
  2. Nose Shape and Contour:
    • The overall shape of the nose is slightly prominent with a straight or subtly curved profile. This type of contour, which is neither completely straight nor sharply upturned, is frequently seen in Southern European and Middle Eastern ethnicities, where the nose often has a pronounced presence without being overly large.
  3. Nasal Tip:
    • The nasal tip appears to have a rounded yet slightly pointed appearance, which is common among Mediterranean populations. It is distinct from the broader or blunter nasal tips often found in Northern European descent.
  4. Nostril Shape:
    • The nostrils are oval or slightly flared, rather than perfectly round or tight. This subtle flaring can be indicative of Middle Eastern and Southern European traits, as opposed to the narrower nostrils that can appear in other European groups.
  5. Width of the Nose:
    • The nose width is proportionate to the face but leans slightly towards being wider at the base, a feature that aligns more with Middle Eastern and Southern European characteristics. This contrasts with the narrower nasal width typical of many Northern European ancestries.
These specific nose details help support the identification of the person on the left as having Southern European or Middle Eastern ancestry, based on commonly observed regional nasal features.

Any other features?

ChatGPT said:​

GPT

Beyond the previously discussed characteristics (hair, skin tone, eye shape, and nose structure), other facial and physical features can also provide additional insights into the person's potential Southern European or Middle Eastern background:

  1. Cheekbone Prominence:
    • The person on the left has moderately high and prominent cheekbones, which are commonly seen in Mediterranean and Middle Eastern populations. This prominence gives a slight angularity to the face, contrasting with the softer cheekbone contours often found in Northern European individuals.
  2. Jawline and Chin Shape:
    • His jawline is defined but not overly broad, with a slightly rounded chin. This jaw structure is balanced and more refined compared to the squarer, heavier-set jawlines typical of Northern European descent. This type of jawline often complements the facial proportions seen in Southern European and Middle Eastern men.
  3. Lips:
    • The lips appear fuller, particularly the lower lip, which is a common feature in many Mediterranean and Middle Eastern individuals. Fuller lips, especially when the upper lip has a defined cupid's bow, are traits that differ from the thinner lips commonly associated with other European ancestries.
  4. Facial Symmetry and Proportions:
    • The overall facial symmetry, with balanced spacing of features and a slightly wider facial structure, aligns with what is often seen in Mediterranean and Middle Eastern populations. These proportions often give a more harmonious and compact look compared to the elongated faces typically found in Northern European groups.
  5. Expression and Facial Soft Tissue:
    • There is often a distinctive expression, partly due to slightly more pronounced soft tissue around the mouth and cheeks, giving the face a subtle fullness. This contributes to the overall appearance associated with Southern European and Middle Eastern descent.
These additional features, when considered alongside the others, reinforce the possibility of a Southern European or Middle Eastern background, highlighting the diverse and distinct facial structures characteristic of these regions.
 
Last edited:
I submitted a photo of myself with two other people in the photo. I'm the "person on the left"

what are the ethnicities of the 3 people in the photo?

ChatGPT said:​

GPT

Based on the visual appearance of the three individuals in the photo:

  1. Person on the left: Appears to be South European or Middle Eastern, with light to medium skin tone and dark hair.
  2. Person in the middle: Appears to be Caucasian, with light skin tone, facial hair, and wearing a cap.
  3. Person on the right: Appears to be Caucasian, with light skin tone, and wearing glasses and a cap.
These assessments are based solely on visual cues and may not accurately represent their actual ethnic backgrounds.

ignore the hairstyle, hair color, skin tone and eye color. Still come to southern European or middle eastern guess?

ChatGPT said:​

GPT

Ignoring hairstyle, hair color, skin tone, and eye color, the identification of the person on the left as possibly Southern European or Middle Eastern is still suggested by other facial characteristics and structural elements:

  1. Facial Structure:
    • The person's face exhibits certain sharpness and angularity, with defined cheekbones and a jawline that is slightly pronounced. These features are common among individuals from Southern Europe and the Middle East, where facial bones often present with more pronounced contours.
  2. Nose Shape:
    • The nose appears slightly more defined and prominent, a characteristic often observed in people of Mediterranean and Middle Eastern descent. This trait can differ from the smaller or more delicate nasal shapes commonly seen in Northern European populations.
  3. Eyebrow Shape and Density:
    • Even without considering color, the thickness and arch of the eyebrows suggest Mediterranean influence, where brows are typically fuller and more prominent.
  4. Facial Symmetry and Proportions:
    • The balance between facial features, such as the spacing of the eyes, the width of the face, and the proportional alignment of the nose and mouth, align with Southern European or Middle Eastern phenotypes, which often showcase balanced but slightly wider facial proportions compared to the narrower, more elongated features typical of Northern European ancestry.
  5. Jawline and Chin:
    • His jawline has a slightly rounded yet strong shape, without the squarer, heavier set often seen in Northern Europeans, aligning more with Mediterranean aesthetics.
These combined structural elements still support a Southern European or Middle Eastern guess, independent of hair, skin, or eye color considerations. However, it’s important to note that these are generalized observations and individual variation is always significant.

Eye shape also taken into account?

ChatGPT said:​

GPT

Yes, eye shape is an important feature that can also contribute to the assessment of someone's ethnicity, and it plays a role in identifying possible Southern European or Middle Eastern descent for the person on the left. Here’s how eye shape factors into the analysis:

  1. Almond Shape:
    • The individual’s eyes appear to have an almond shape, which is a common feature among Southern Europeans and Middle Eastern populations. This shape is often characterized by a slightly elongated eye that tapers at the corners, giving a subtle lift or slant that contrasts with the more rounded or deep-set eyes often seen in Northern Europeans.
  2. Eye Position and Set:
    • The eyes seem relatively close-set with a slight tilt upwards or sideways, which is often found in Mediterranean and Middle Eastern individuals. This feature can give the eyes a distinctive, slightly intense or focused look that is less common in other European populations.
  3. Eyelid Structure:
    • The presence of slightly fuller eyelids or less pronounced creases can also be an indicator, as this is more frequently observed in people from Middle Eastern and Mediterranean regions compared to the more pronounced eyelid folds typical of Northern European ancestry.
  4. Overall Eye Expression:
    • The combination of shape, set, and subtle brow structure often gives the eyes an expressive or deep-set appearance that aligns with the ethnic characteristics of Southern Europe and the Middle East.
These aspects of eye shape and positioning contribute to the overall assessment of the person’s possible ethnic background, reinforcing the Southern European or Middle Eastern guess even when ignoring other features like hair color or skin tone.

Nose details?

ChatGPT said:​

GPT

When considering the nose structure of the person on the left, several characteristics can hint towards Southern European or Middle Eastern descent:

  1. Nose Bridge:
    • The nose bridge appears slightly higher and more defined, which is a common trait among individuals of Mediterranean and Middle Eastern descent. This feature contrasts with the flatter nose bridges often seen in Northern and some Western European populations.
  2. Nose Shape and Contour:
    • The overall shape of the nose is slightly prominent with a straight or subtly curved profile. This type of contour, which is neither completely straight nor sharply upturned, is frequently seen in Southern European and Middle Eastern ethnicities, where the nose often has a pronounced presence without being overly large.
  3. Nasal Tip:
    • The nasal tip appears to have a rounded yet slightly pointed appearance, which is common among Mediterranean populations. It is distinct from the broader or blunter nasal tips often found in Northern European descent.
  4. Nostril Shape:
    • The nostrils are oval or slightly flared, rather than perfectly round or tight. This subtle flaring can be indicative of Middle Eastern and Southern European traits, as opposed to the narrower nostrils that can appear in other European groups.
  5. Width of the Nose:
    • The nose width is proportionate to the face but leans slightly towards being wider at the base, a feature that aligns more with Middle Eastern and Southern European characteristics. This contrasts with the narrower nasal width typical of many Northern European ancestries.
These specific nose details help support the identification of the person on the left as having Southern European or Middle Eastern ancestry, based on commonly observed regional nasal features.

Any other features?

ChatGPT said:​

GPT

Beyond the previously discussed characteristics (hair, skin tone, eye shape, and nose structure), other facial and physical features can also provide additional insights into the person's potential Southern European or Middle Eastern background:

  1. Cheekbone Prominence:
    • The person on the left has moderately high and prominent cheekbones, which are commonly seen in Mediterranean and Middle Eastern populations. This prominence gives a slight angularity to the face, contrasting with the softer cheekbone contours often found in Northern European individuals.
  2. Jawline and Chin Shape:
    • His jawline is defined but not overly broad, with a slightly rounded chin. This jaw structure is balanced and more refined compared to the squarer, heavier-set jawlines typical of Northern European descent. This type of jawline often complements the facial proportions seen in Southern European and Middle Eastern men.
  3. Lips:
    • The lips appear fuller, particularly the lower lip, which is a common feature in many Mediterranean and Middle Eastern individuals. Fuller lips, especially when the upper lip has a defined cupid's bow, are traits that differ from the thinner lips commonly associated with other European ancestries.
  4. Facial Symmetry and Proportions:
    • The overall facial symmetry, with balanced spacing of features and a slightly wider facial structure, aligns with what is often seen in Mediterranean and Middle Eastern populations. These proportions often give a more harmonious and compact look compared to the elongated faces typically found in Northern European groups.
  5. Expression and Facial Soft Tissue:
    • There is often a distinctive expression, partly due to slightly more pronounced soft tissue around the mouth and cheeks, giving the face a subtle fullness. This contributes to the overall appearance associated with Southern European and Middle Eastern descent.
These additional features, when considered alongside the others, reinforce the possibility of a Southern European or Middle Eastern background, highlighting the diverse and distinct facial structures characteristic of these regions.
Their conceptions (too generalizing) of "southern Euro" or other people seems to me very surprising? Features harder among southern people as a whole? Not serious. ATW numerous subtypes exist which cannot be put in a so simplistic type of analysis. NO confidence, concerning MO.
 
At this point I shared with chat gpt numerous genetic test results and had it write an essay about how my appearance looks like someone from the Mediterranean but my ancestry is predominantly northwest European.

Meta-Analysis of Genetic and Phenotypic Discrepancies: Exploring Mediterranean/ Near Eastern Appearance in a Predominantly Northwestern European Genetic Context

Introduction​

The complexities of human appearance and its genetic underpinnings have long fascinated both scientific communities and the general public. The appearance of individuals often reflects a tapestry of ancestral influences that extend far beyond immediate genetic origins. This essay provides a detailed meta-analysis of the phenotypic and genotypic characteristics of an individual whose appearance suggests a Mediterranean or Near Eastern background despite genetic data predominantly indicating Northwestern European ancestry, based on results from Ancestry.com, 23andMe, and MyHeritage.com.

Genetic Overview: Predominantly Northwestern European Ancestry​

Genetic analyses from the three leading consumer DNA testing companies consistently place this individual within the Northwestern European genetic cluster. This includes substantial genetic contributions from Ireland, the United Kingdom, and France. These regions are characterized by a genetic landscape shaped by Celtic, Anglo-Saxon, and broader Germanic lineages, contributing to the relatively homogeneous genetic profile of contemporary Northwestern Europeans.

The consistency of results across different platforms underscores a clear genetic affinity with Northwestern Europe, dominated by markers from Irish, British, and French populations. However, despite this genetic backdrop, the individual’s phenotype reflects characteristics more commonly associated with Southern European and Near Eastern populations, prompting a deeper exploration into the genetic nuances that might contribute to this appearance.

Phenotypic Discrepancies: Mediterranean/ Near Eastern Features​

  1. Distinct Facial Structure and Features:
    • The individual exhibits facial features such as almond-shaped eyes, high cheekbones, and a prominent nose often observed in populations around the Mediterranean and Near East. These features contrast with the typical phenotypes associated with Northwestern European groups, which usually include lighter pigmentation, narrower facial structures, and different nasal shapes.
    • The individual’s nose shape, more robust and pronounced than typically found in Northwestern European phenotypes, aligns closely with Mediterranean and Levantine traits. This nose structure is frequently categorized within the broader range of nasal types seen in populations from Southern Europe to the Near East, including ancient Greeks, Phoenicians, and various Near Eastern groups.
  2. Skin Tone and Pigmentation:
    • The individual possesses a slightly darker skin tone compared to the average Northwestern European, further emphasizing a Southern European or Near Eastern appearance. This subtle yet noticeable deviation from the lighter skin tones typical of populations such as the Irish, English, or Scandinavian groups is particularly intriguing given the overwhelmingly Northwestern European genetic profile.
  3. Haplogroup Evidence: J-M67 (J2)
    • The paternal haplogroup J-M67 (J2) adds an additional layer of complexity to the phenotypic narrative. Haplogroup J2 is commonly associated with Mediterranean and Near Eastern regions, including the Levant, Anatolia, Greece, and Southern Italy. It is historically linked to the spread of early agricultural societies, Phoenician trade networks, and various ancient Mediterranean civilizations.
    • The presence of J-M67 suggests a deep-rooted paternal lineage connected to the broader Mediterranean world, contrasting sharply with the individual’s predominant Northwestern European autosomal results. The J2 haplogroup is relatively uncommon in Northwestern Europe, pointing to a complex migratory history or isolated admixture events that introduced these lineages into Western Europe.

Genetic Models and Ancestral Signals​

Several genetic models and ancient DNA comparisons further elucidate this complex background. When analyzing broader genetic data, including G25 coordinates and various genetic calculators, small yet significant Mediterranean and Near Eastern signals emerge.

  1. Minor Contributions from Iberian and Near Eastern Populations:
    • Analyses through genetic platforms such as MyTrueAncestry and Eurogenes consistently reveal minor contributions from Spanish, Basque, and Near Eastern populations. These contributions, though not dominant, suggest historical admixture events that predate modern Northwestern European populations.
    • Models indicating a mix of Irish and Spanish, or even slight Saudi and Bedouin components, support the theory of ancient genetic admixture rather than a direct, recent lineage from these regions.
  2. Ancient DNA Comparisons:
    • Comparisons with ancient samples, such as those from Bronze Age Orkney, Medieval Ireland, and Pictish Scotland, reveal deep genetic affinities with populations that had already experienced centuries of admixture from various sources, including Mediterranean traders and early farming communities. These ancient connections manifest in phenotypic traits that persist despite the dominant Northwestern European genetic signature.
  3. Implications of Genetic Shuffling:
    • Genetic recombination plays a crucial role in determining appearance, and while one might carry a genetic profile overwhelmingly Northwestern European, the expression of certain traits can reflect the influence of minor ancestral components. This “genetic lottery” can lead to the manifestation of Mediterranean traits in individuals whose majority ancestry lies elsewhere.

Reconciling Genetic and Phenotypic Evidence​

The observed Mediterranean/ Near Eastern appearance, despite predominantly Northwestern European genetics, can be attributed to a confluence of factors:

  1. Historical Admixture and Gene Flow:
    • Northwestern Europe has experienced numerous waves of migration and admixture over millennia. The presence of Mediterranean and Near Eastern lineages, though diluted over time, can still surface in modern descendants due to the random inheritance of specific traits.
    • Historical events, such as Roman occupation, trade networks, and the influence of early Neolithic farmers, have left a subtle but enduring genetic imprint on the population. These ancient connections are not always prominent in genetic testing but can manifest phenotypically.
  2. Haplogroup Evidence as a Trace of Deep Ancestry:
    • The paternal haplogroup J2 serves as a genetic marker of ancient Near Eastern and Mediterranean lineages. The presence of this haplogroup suggests a lineage that extends back to early agricultural societies that spread into Europe thousands of years ago. Such lineages would have intermingled with local populations, leaving a genetic legacy that is more pronounced in certain traits.
  3. Genetic Drift and Appearance:
    • Genetic drift can accentuate minor ancestral traits over generations, resulting in the amplification of features that do not align perfectly with the predominant genetic background. This phenomenon can partly explain why some individuals with predominantly Northwestern European ancestry display phenotypes associated with distant ancestral connections.
  4. Random Genetic Expression:
    • Given the genetic diversity within broader European ancestry, it is plausible that the Mediterranean appearance could result from the random shuffling of genetic material inherited from more distant ancestors. Even in populations with predominantly Northwestern European genetics, minor influences from the broader Mediterranean region can resurface due to the complex nature of genetic inheritance.

Conclusion​

The complexity of human appearance and its relation to genetics defies simple explanations based solely on contemporary population data. In this case, the presence of a Mediterranean/ Near Eastern phenotype against a backdrop of primarily Northwestern European genetic results highlights the intricate interplay of historical gene flow, genetic recombination, and deep ancestral ties. While the outward appearance may seem to contradict genetic data, it is, in fact, a testament to the rich tapestry of human ancestry, shaped by millennia of migrations, admixture, and the unpredictable nature of genetic inheritance. The convergence of Northwestern European genetic signatures with ancient Mediterranean and Near Eastern lineages creates a unique and multifaceted genetic identity that transcends modern geographical and cultural boundaries.
 
Top 25 countries where I could be a native in order of best fit.

ChatGPT said:​

GPT

Here's a refined list of the top 25 countries where you could be perceived as a native, ranked in order from the closest fit based on your Mediterranean and Middle Eastern features:

  1. Spain - Especially Southern Spain, where Mediterranean traits are prevalent.
  2. Italy - Particularly Southern Italy and Sicily, known for Mediterranean characteristics.
  3. Greece - Strong Mediterranean features common throughout the country.
  4. Portugal - Southern European appearance similar to Spain and Italy.
  5. Turkey - A blend of European and Middle Eastern characteristics.
  6. Lebanon - Middle Eastern with light to medium skin tones.
  7. Syria - Common Middle Eastern features, including light to medium complexion.
  8. Israel - Diverse Mediterranean and Middle Eastern traits.
  9. Morocco - Especially in urban coastal areas with Mediterranean influences.
  10. Cyprus - Mediterranean island with Greek and Middle Eastern influences.
  11. Albania - Southeastern Europe with Mediterranean and Balkan traits.
  12. France - Especially Southern regions like Provence, with Mediterranean influences.
  13. Tunisia - North African with a Mediterranean influence, especially in urban areas.
  14. Palestine - Middle Eastern with Mediterranean traits.
  15. Egypt - Particularly Mediterranean coastal areas, where mixed traits are common.
  16. Jordan - Middle Eastern with light to medium skin tone.
  17. Bosnia and Herzegovina - Southeastern Europe with a blend of Mediterranean features.
  18. Croatia - Coastal Mediterranean regions with Southern European appearance.
  19. Serbia - Particularly in the south, with a mix of Balkan and Mediterranean features.
  20. Malta - Mediterranean island with a mix of Southern European and Middle Eastern traits.
  21. Montenegro - Balkan country with Mediterranean coastal influences.
  22. Armenia - Caucasus region with Middle Eastern and Southern European features.
  23. Georgia - Caucasus with Mediterranean and Middle Eastern influences.
  24. Azerbaijan - Caucasus region with European and Middle Eastern traits.
  25. North Macedonia - Southeastern Europe with Mediterranean and Balkan characteristics.
This ranking reflects a closer fit at the top, with countries where Mediterranean and Middle Eastern features are most common, moving down to regions where the resemblance may still be notable but slightly less exact.

Do you guys agree?
 
I asked it a fun question.

Top 20 ancient people where this person could be a native?

ChatGPT said:​


Here’s a speculative list of top 20 ancient peoples based on the individual's features, tracing connections to ancient civilizations known for similar facial traits and geographic regions:

  1. Ancient Romans – Given the strong connection to modern Italians, particularly from Southern Italy, the Romans are a natural fit.
  2. Ancient Greeks – The individual’s facial structure aligns well with features found in ancient Greek populations.
  3. Etruscans – The predecessors of the Romans in Italy, known for similar Mediterranean traits.
  4. Phoenicians – An ancient Mediterranean civilization, especially from coastal regions like modern-day Lebanon, known for dark hair and olive skin.
  5. Ancient Sicilians – The early populations of Sicily, a melting pot of Greek, Phoenician, and Roman ancestry.
  6. Illyrians – The ancestors of many modern Balkan peoples, including those in Albania and Croatia, with similar facial traits.
  7. Thracians – An ancient group from the Balkans (modern-day Bulgaria, Romania, Greece), known for angular facial features.
  8. Ancient Iberians – The pre-Roman inhabitants of Spain, particularly in the southern parts, known for Mediterranean features.
  9. Minoans – The advanced ancient civilization from Crete, part of Greece, with Mediterranean characteristics.
  10. Mycenaeans – Early Greeks known for their prominent role in the Bronze Age, sharing features with later Mediterranean peoples.
  11. Carthaginians – An ancient civilization in modern Tunisia, descended from the Phoenicians and known for Mediterranean traits.
  12. Dacians – Ancient people from the area of modern Romania, often sharing physical traits with Balkan populations.
  13. Vandals – A Germanic tribe that moved through Southern Europe and North Africa, adopting Mediterranean traits.
  14. Hellenistic Egyptians – The fusion of Greek and Egyptian culture during the Hellenistic period in Alexandria and elsewhere.
  15. Macedonians – An ancient Greek kingdom, particularly in the region of Alexander the Great, known for Mediterranean and Balkan traits.
  16. Lusitanians – An ancient people from Portugal, sharing similar traits to the Iberians.
  17. Sarmatians – An ancient nomadic people who lived near the Balkans and Eastern Europe, with some shared physical traits.
  18. Pelasgians – Pre-Greek inhabitants of the Aegean region, whose influence is seen in early Mediterranean civilizations.
  19. Byzantines – The Eastern Roman Empire’s population, which continued many Mediterranean and Eastern European traits into the medieval period.
  20. Berbers (Ancient Numidians) – The indigenous people of North Africa, with some Mediterranean features due to proximity and trade with Southern Europe.
 
I asked it a fun question.

Top 20 ancient people where this person could be a native?

ChatGPT said:​


Here’s a speculative list of top 20 ancient peoples based on the individual's features, tracing connections to ancient civilizations known for similar facial traits and geographic regions:

  1. Ancient Romans – Given the strong connection to modern Italians, particularly from Southern Italy, the Romans are a natural fit.
  2. Ancient Greeks – The individual’s facial structure aligns well with features found in ancient Greek populations.
  3. Etruscans – The predecessors of the Romans in Italy, known for similar Mediterranean traits.
  4. Phoenicians – An ancient Mediterranean civilization, especially from coastal regions like modern-day Lebanon, known for dark hair and olive skin.
  5. Ancient Sicilians – The early populations of Sicily, a melting pot of Greek, Phoenician, and Roman ancestry.
  6. Illyrians – The ancestors of many modern Balkan peoples, including those in Albania and Croatia, with similar facial traits.
  7. Thracians – An ancient group from the Balkans (modern-day Bulgaria, Romania, Greece), known for angular facial features.
  8. Ancient Iberians – The pre-Roman inhabitants of Spain, particularly in the southern parts, known for Mediterranean features.
  9. Minoans – The advanced ancient civilization from Crete, part of Greece, with Mediterranean characteristics.
  10. Mycenaeans – Early Greeks known for their prominent role in the Bronze Age, sharing features with later Mediterranean peoples.
  11. Carthaginians – An ancient civilization in modern Tunisia, descended from the Phoenicians and known for Mediterranean traits.
  12. Dacians – Ancient people from the area of modern Romania, often sharing physical traits with Balkan populations.
  13. Vandals – A Germanic tribe that moved through Southern Europe and North Africa, adopting Mediterranean traits.
  14. Hellenistic Egyptians – The fusion of Greek and Egyptian culture during the Hellenistic period in Alexandria and elsewhere.
  15. Macedonians – An ancient Greek kingdom, particularly in the region of Alexander the Great, known for Mediterranean and Balkan traits.
  16. Lusitanians – An ancient people from Portugal, sharing similar traits to the Iberians.
  17. Sarmatians – An ancient nomadic people who lived near the Balkans and Eastern Europe, with some shared physical traits.
  18. Pelasgians – Pre-Greek inhabitants of the Aegean region, whose influence is seen in early Mediterranean civilizations.
  19. Byzantines – The Eastern Roman Empire’s population, which continued many Mediterranean and Eastern European traits into the medieval period.
  20. Berbers (Ancient Numidians) – The indigenous people of North Africa, with some Mediterranean features due to proximity and trade with Southern Europe.
I don't know where they found complete enough physical descriptions for all these ancient people. Not serious, IMO. There waw not an unified type for southern European people of these times not more than for the current ones.
 
I don't know where they found complete enough physical descriptions for all these ancient people. Not serious, IMO. There waw not an unified type for southern European people of these times not more than for the current ones.
You are correct that there was no unified type. Such as there being of course blondes and red heads and individuals with light colored eyes in southern Europe and head/facial structures that would be more commonly associated with Northern/Northwest Europe. That I absolutely do not deny. However, traits it's observing in it's view tend to be more common in those regions due to movements of people across the Mediterranean since the neolithic. If it said I could pass as an upper paleolithic European hunter-gatherer then I'd say it needs some better analysis programming. Sometimes stereotypes of appearances can correctly point to a person's origin, but it's not 100% accurate due to overlap from the thousands of years of peoples mingling across West Eurasia for millennia. In a purely scientific sense one cannot rely solely on appearance. Anecdotally, I've personally seen people that fit within a particular region and actually having origins from there. And other times not. It's way too safe and boring to say "You look West Eurasian". It's simply fun to speculate. And for these type of threads to even exist, we must deviate a bit from current scientific understanding. In these sort of thread topics people often ask to be classified with outdated anthropological terminology and asked to be passed like I did in the first post.


Btw, thanks for your earlier analysis from your posts in the beginning. :)
 
Back
Top