Fire Haired14
Banned
- Messages
- 2,185
- Reaction score
- 583
- Points
- 0
- Y-DNA haplogroup
- R1b DF27*
- mtDNA haplogroup
- U5b2a2b1
Oh my gosh, you guys are so stubborn. I NEVER SAID ALL U5a is EHG!!! Of course it existed in Western Europe before Steppe people arrived. I said it was more popular there, we know it was because of literally over 1000 ancient mtDNA samples. How can you not understand the difference between higher frequency and exclusiveness? U5a was much much more frequent in the Steppe than the rest of Europe but it wasn't exclusive to the Steppe, so a few U5a samples in Neolithic Iberia isn't good evidence the U5a1 in Bell Beaker is native!
Why can't you just admit three U5a1s in a small collection of Spanish Bell Beaker is evidence of Steppe admixture? In an abstract about an upcoming paper with 100s of Bell Beaker genomes they hinted towards everyone in the culture having Steppe admixture.
Why can't you just admit three U5a1s in a small collection of Spanish Bell Beaker is evidence of Steppe admixture? In an abstract about an upcoming paper with 100s of Bell Beaker genomes they hinted towards everyone in the culture having Steppe admixture.