For Albanians it is clear that E-V13 and J2 are not speakers of Proto Albanian. Speakers of Proto Albanian didn't live in the Balkans. It is not tabu, and we can speak about it, and it is linked with the thread.
Don't you have anything better to do besides trashing Albanian threads in here, because that's all I have seen some of you guys do here at Eupedia. Sometimes I can't stop laughing at your ridiculous arguments.
Nobody knows what these members of haplogroups spoke in the Neolithic and who spoke proto Albanian. It doesn't even matter. All we know for sure is that the Albanian language is estimated to be 5000 years old by some estimates, and that the ancestors of Albanians have been in the Balkans since at least the Bronze age (proven by genetics).
Here is another source by the New York Times stating that Albanian arose in southern Balkans some 5000 years ago:
http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2012/08/24/science/0824-origins.html
All some of you guys on Eupedia do is cherry pick vague arguments and try to make Albanians to be some kind of "recent arrivals" from the middle east or who knows from where, maybe you will suggest mars next time. When time and time again you are proven wrong, not just by me, but by other members as well. I would be ashamed.
Last edited: