could the source of the J in EHG be their WHG?

[Freb]

The WHG component in the EHG seems to be unsampled. I say, if we do find the source of the WHG component. We might find a huge vault of J and probably some I1/I2.

 

[WHGuy]

Have we found J amongst WHG? I believe the hgs found have been I, C, and R-V88.

 

[Rethel]

The WHG component in the EHG seems to be unsampled. I say, if we do find the source of the WHG component.

You will not find, because WHG is a hybrid of CM and EHG.

 

[Freb]

You will not find, because WHG is a hybrid of CM and EHG.

The 1990s called, they said they want their low quality admix tools back.

 

[Freb]

Have we found J amongst WHG? I believe the hgs found have been I, C, and R-V88.

There is IJ in WHG. One of those IJs if I recall correctly had an upstream clade closer to J than to I.

 

[Miguel]

WHG in EHG is U5, and more precisely, just U5b1

I've also thought it was rare that IJ weren't closer, but you have to bear in mind they exist since 45000 years ago.
Even though haplogroup I didn't become ubiquitous until the end of the Ice Age (15-12000).