Search results

Maybe Roma ancestry.

I agree with you, I don't think religion has much correlation. I've always noticed that mountainous highlands might seem to correlate with increased J-L283. This of course being a common trend when populations get pushed back to the highlands from foreign invaders, the same trend happens in the...

Why are so many of your theories vague and based on the concept of luck and not specific factors or events that might have resulted in them?

Map is due for an update

You should compare this poll with the "What is your Y haplogroup? poll" to determine proportional outliers.

I see statements like this in the forum all of the time. Gyms is clearly not familiar with the common phrase "correlation does not imply causation". He incorrectly assumed that Canada is choosing immigration through race based on the statistics. But he does not realize that the Canada selects...

Do you guys think the Teutoberg forest Roman samples will ever be tested, bound to be lots J-L283. And are there any new news or J-L283 theories?

I think that vegans and vegetarians only truly care for their individual moral dilemmas against eating meat and killing animals, and they simply use so-called "environmental concerns" caused by the industry (which is equal to if not less than, virtually every industry there is in regard to...

If your a utilitarian then you will see that the amount of deaths caused by the nukes was significantly less then what would have been expected to be lost on both sides of the war if the US had to land invade Japan or prolong the war for more fighting.

The original map image can no longer be seen?

I think these maps are due for an update, we've gotten much more samples since then.

I have come to understand the potential bias and political incentives behind much of the haplogroup and genetic arguing that goes on in these types of forums. This of course happens very commonly between Balkan nations like Serbia and Albania for obvious political reasons. However, I don't...

From what I've seen, his paternal line has been traced to Phillipe Bieber (born 1856) Zilling, Alsace-Lorraine. This is a region very close to the Rhine J-L283 hot spots and the city of Strasbourg, correlating with the Roman Rhine Lime and henceforth likely implying Roman mediated migration...

Why is there a DNA study for only Viminacium, but there is yet to be any from The Battle of Teutoburg site in Germany, which could potentially yield an estimated 15,000 - 20,000 Y DNA samples from the mass Roman graves?

Yes, I think I've seen some of Trojet's posts, but I don't recall any specifics regarding tribes. I'll check search Eupedia J-L283 and look out for Aspurg and Trojet's posts. And I too have also noticed that most of the Illyrain discussions on genetic forums end up in strange arguments. Is...

Thank you for the response. I was considering getting on the Y full tree, but I am a college student living with parents during Covid, so I don't have that kind of money. I suppose I did make an error with the I2 being mixed up with R1B z2103, I just thought I saw some stats somewhere that...

I agree with the German Roman mediated spread, but what do you guys think about the Czech Republic hot spot that existed far from the Roman border? Also, I think your Rhaetion theory is interesting, however there doesn't appear to be many samples from the Alps outside of Switzerland. And...

I've only done 23andme and it assigned me J-Z631. I agree with your suggestions of Roman/Balkan legionnaires or people migrating via the Danube from the Balkans. However, I have another question. I've been reading through many threads, and I've seen many arguments regarding whether this was...

What is the general consensus for the high rate of J-L283 in Wurttemberg Germany displayed on the phylogeographer heat map? Is it all just assumed to be Roman derived via settlements or forts, or a founder effect like in Russia?