Search results

do not write about genetics if you have no clue what those maps are.... look at this website (not forum) for some initial explanation about genetics...

intuition is also kind of logic... if you are not able to feel the difference between art of different cultures than perhaps you are missing something in your education and logic... oh, come on... grow up...don't be such a 19th century historian... Tacitus explains his methodology for...

let's take a look at match of culture spreads to spread of haplogroups http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jastorf_culture Early Iron Age: dark green: Nordic Bronze Age dark red: Jastorf culture yellow: Harpstedt-Nienburg group orange: Celtic groups olive: Pomeranian culture green: House urns...

I try also to follow intuition in things like this.... so, I looked in what was Pomeranian culture... this does not feel as germanic sensibility for art... besides Germanic people are mostly too practical for art anyway... it can easily be proto-Slavic... or Baltic....or Finish...

yes, that's what I meant... made lapsus... Slavic language may have developed recently by east Germanic or Celtic people merging their language with the language of iranian Sarmatians... but I think Slavic language is much older than the time it is attested... Pomeranian culture and...

hm, wonder whether there was really clear difference between west germanic and east Slavic.... tacitus clearly uses living in houses versus living nomad lifestyle to classify Vistula Veneti in Germanic people... could Lugians/Luiggi be same is Lyakhs from text bellow...

in serbian: "Tiberije Velianac salu čuveno/slavno darivaše" would mean Tiberius from Wellia(n) has given gift to hall/chamber in glorious way (gloriously). -ac is in Serbia e.g. John Britanac = John from Britain Iranac = man from Iran Avganistanac = man from Afghanistan man from Velia (no...

italic - because Etruscans lived among italic people and probably assimilated many... and because later Etruscans were assimilating in italic people which must have led to some words being incorporated in italian language... Greek - as Greek are their neighbours in both Lydia and in Italy with...

I will answer this as the rest is not worth commenting... Does this mean that now you admit Slavs origin from Serians, but still need to defend line of Serians not being same as Cimmerians? your problem is that you want linguistic proof for everything... and you cannot have that without...

a possible interpretation of their tribal name comes from Slavic languages (I do not know Baltic languages, explanation there could be similar) more = sea pomorje = area around sea pomeranians = people who live around sea similar origin of tribal names are common in Slavs e.g. Polanes - comes...

btw. a bit off topic about relation of Cimmerians/Serians to Illyrians... I think that tribes of Serians/Cimmerians had nothing to do with Illyrians... while Serians/Cimmerians were in my opinion I2 + some R1a people, I think that Illyrians probably originally were E-V13 and J2 with some R1b as...

Taranis, can we go to the next sentence in order to see whether the links I have found in the first one were completely accidental or not... Taranis is very systematic, very precise, very conventional and very biased as he is protecting vision of Germanic/Celtic Europe with Slavic intruders...

Horvati means croissant :) and yes Conan the Cimmerian was Serb :) but seriously, I think that Croats tribal name is derived from tribal name of Hurians... Hurians were in my opinion R1a people and some of them ended up turkic (ak+hur = Og+ hur =Ogur = Ugri), some Slavic (Croats and also many...

I am puzzled about R1a and I2a in proto-Serbs, but perhaps when searching for tribal identity I should look in mitohondrial lineages as Serbs tribal name probably origin from queen of Sheba, and we know that Ptolemy records Serboi as living next to Amazones from article about genetic study of...

you should not brag with your ignorance.... thing that Etruscans come from Lydia in Asia minor is much much much better attested than e.g the idea that Indo-Europeans speakers came from Asia to Europe and not other way around... Herodotus http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/ancient/etrucans2.html...

ok, what about Sardis as origin of tribal name Sherdana/Serden... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tyrrhenians for my theory that doesnot change much, as I am convinced that Balkan Serbs (and identity of other Slavs) origin from European branch of I2 (and perhaps R1a) Serians, while sea peoples...

judging by your posts on this and similar topics perhaps you should shut up... if you are not able to understand it, ask Taranis to compare for you the methodology used in my post with the one in starting post... note that I do not claim that Etruscans were proto-Serbs... in fact...

well, I don't know much about linguistics but let me play a bit with words too... "taj" = "that" in Serbian (for masculine nouns) "i ta" = "and that" in Serbian ("ta" = that for feminine nouns) "dom"= home in Slavic (masculine noun) "i" = "and" in Slavic "kuća" = house in Serbian...

again, I am not speaking of Slavic language... I speak of continuity of genetics and tribal name of Zeruiani/Serians/Seres/Siraces/Sarbans/Serboi/Serbs...(probably also Scirri/Scordisci/Serdi) about tribal name Serian very likely to be interchangeble with Cimmerian (while Gomer is wider term)...

you do not read my posts carefully, do you? Gomer was not living in times when Adriatic Veneti are mentioned, but much much earlier.... Gomer was thought to be ancestor of all Germanic people... of haplogroup I people (do not forget that besides I1 also I2b is important marker of Germanic...