I'm not sure what you mean exactly. Possibly our reports are different. I'll try to explain better then. 23andMe (mine is v4) presents the genetic likelihood of eyes color this way:
LIGHTER EYES %, divided into Blue %, Greenish blue %, Green % and Light hazel %;
DARKER EYES %, divided into Dark hazel %, Light brown % and Dark brown %.
If they say you likely have dark-colored eyes and the eyes are light (green, for example), or the opposite, then the report is not correct.
At least they get right my father's eyes color, but Gedmatch missed the three. When it shows brown, it's green. When it shows green, it's brown.
That's it.
Yes, it looks like the new report lists more variants of eye colours than the old one. That makes it difficult to compare the accuracy between Eupedia members. We should specific if we have the old or the new report.