Equipopulous redivision of the EU by cultural borders

Maciamo

Veteran member
Admin
Messages
10,022
Reaction score
3,381
Points
113
Location
Lothier
Ethnic group
Italo-celto-germanic
I have found this map of Europe on BigThink. It shows what a European Union with 28 equipopulous member states would look like. But the division is far from arbitrary. I have thought about redividing the EU by considering the cultural, ethnic, linguistic and historical similarities between regions since the late 1990's and this is the best map I have seen so far. It doesn't just make a lot of sense in terms of cultural affinities, but it also manages to balance all regions' populations around 17-18 millions inhabitants. Kuddos to the author, Alasdair Gunn.

The only problem with the proposed regions is that some of them would be multilingual. However that is already the case for many existing member states (Belgium, France, Spain, Italy, Finland), so it is only a minor issue. Besides, some multilingual regions include closely related languages like Catalan and Occitan for the Balearic Coast, or Danish, Swedish and Dutch for the Sealand, or Portuguese and Galician for Finisterre.

Regions that have very different languages, like Italian and Greek for the Mediterranean Union, or German, Slovak, Hungarian and Romanian for Danovia, have nevertheless very strong historic ties and used to be the same country, so putting them back together is not unreasonable. The hardest may be to put Slovenes and Croatians with east Italians within Adriatica, but the Veneto and coastal Croatia also used to be together for 8 centuries during the Venetian Republic.

Even if some region make sense historically, I am not sure many West Poles would be thrilled to reform Prussia with northeast Germany, even with over 400 years of recent shared history.

If Iceland and Norway joined the EU, it would allow for an even better division. Sweden would team up with Norway and Iceland instead of the east Baltic countries.

eGvl9lB.png
 
Last edited:
This is purely hypothetical but worth doing the excercise.
Belgium is a very complicated country with far to many government levels.
They should simply abolish some of these levels and reduce the number of politicians by half or more.
Question is whether the federal level still should exist, i.e. whether Belgium itself shouldn't be abolished.
In that case, which parts of Belgium would remain and what would be their relation to EU?
This is purely hypothetical, because politicians don't want to reduce their numbers by half...
 
Apart from the *equipopulousness it's arbitrary. Ιn Rumelia we would have 4 languages and national identities. One language would be not IE (Turkish), the other three would belong to three separate branches of IE (Romance, Slavic, Hellenic). It would be multiple times worse than Belgium.
 
I would have thought Apulia belongs more with Magna Graecia.
 

This thread has been viewed 6072 times.

Back
Top