Gulf Arab women

[Sile]

Not too amiable your answer, Sile. Perhaps I mistake it?
here under concerning Phoenician language, from Wikipedia (but I heard of that long ago, long before Wiki)
[--- Phoenician, sometimes identified with Canaanite Hebrew^{[citation needed]}, was a language originally spoken in the coastal (Mediterranean) region then called "Canaan" in Phoenician,Arabic, Greek, and Aramaic, "Phoenicia" in Greek and Latin, and "Pūt" in the Egyptian language. It is a part of the Canaanite subgroup of the Northwest Semitic languages. Other members of the family are Hebrew, Ammonite, Moabite and Edomite. ^[3][4]
The area where Phoenician was spoken includes modern-dayLebanon, coastal Syria, coastal northern Israel, parts of Cyprus and, at least as a prestige language, some adjacent areas of Anatolia.^[5]It was also spoken in the area of Phoenician colonization along the coasts of the southwestern Mediterranean Sea, including those of modern Tunisia, Morocco, Libya and Algeria as well as Malta, the west of Sicily, Sardinia, Corsica, the Balearic Islands and southernmost Spain.___]

And modern lebanon was hittite lands speaking Luwian and hittite/hatti languages and both are non-semitic languages ............the creation of phoenicians happened after the disappearance of the hittites...................I cannot see why it is difficult for you to not see bronze-age lebanon and only concentrate on iron-age lebanon

 

[MOESAN]

And modern lebanon was hittite lands speaking Luwian and hittite/hatti languages and both are non-semitic languages ............the creation of phoenicians happened after the disappearance of the hittites...................I cannot see why it is difficult for you to not see bronze-age lebanon and only concentrate on iron-age lebanon

Keep cool, Sile: I have not problem to understand your precise point here.
The first question was the physical aspect of roughly said Arabic lands women. It's the thread. You noticed and I agree that Near-Easterners are not dominantly southern Arabs in genetic makeup. No problem. But you affirmed, the posts are here, that Saui and other Gulf ARabs were not Arabs! I proved you the opposite. Now, under the linguistic definition, the mix of N-Neareasterns and Peninsula Arabs is not the same everywhere: OK!
My last post in this question here.

 

[Sile]

Keep cool, Sile: I have not problem to understand your precise point here.
The first question was the physical aspect of roughly said Arabic lands women. It's the thread. You noticed and I agree that Near-Easterners are not dominantly southern Arabs in genetic makeup. No problem. But you affirmed, the posts are here, that Saui and other Gulf ARabs were not Arabs! I proved you the opposite. Now, under the linguistic definition, the mix of N-Neareasterns and Peninsula Arabs is not the same everywhere: OK!
My last post in this question here.

I think we need to find out what semitic language group entered Lebanon after the collapse of the hittite empire ............did these people speak a semitic language?
did the babylonians of Sumer and the people of Ur speak semitic ?

IIRC , the assyrians came via hatti and mitanni language groups which was not semitic .............or maybe I am wrong

I recall no arabic being mentioned by Roman historians in the levant............if you have a link which states otherwise, please link it

this link and others clearly indicate a persian migration into eastern arabian peninsula

http://bmcgenomics.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12864-015-1233-x

 

[Angela]

OMG...

Semitic languages....

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semitic_languages

"Semitic languages occur in written form from a very early historical date, with East Semitic Akkadian and Eblaitetexts (written in a script adapted from Sumeriancuneiform) appearing from the 29th century BCE and the 25th century BCE in Mesopotamia and the northernLevant respectively. "

The ancient Semitic languages:

 

[MOESAN]

M last post + 1 here!: LOL. just to thank Angela