I know what you mean, and why you initially guessed Armenian. The eyebrows and eyes, and even the nose to some extent reminded me of the stylized Eastern Orthodox icons, whether Greek or Serbian or Armenian.
http://www.balkantravellers.com/images/stories/peak_season/Serbian_monasteries/guide-opening.jpg
It's just that the jaw is all wrong, and the strong eyebrow ridges of the Orthodox icons as well. Most modern Armenians also have a different type of nose.
And I understand why someone said Egyptian...there is a resemblance in the eyes and eyebrows and nose to the Egyptian art of the Roman period as well, but most Egyptians don't look like that today. The people commemorated in those funerary portraits might have been totally Roman for all we know, or at least heavily admixed with Roman and Greek genomes.
http://www.touregypt.net/images/touregypt/mport22.jpg
So, I think he's European, from somewhere in southern Europe or the southern Balkans.
One of the non-Sicilian actors in this Dolce and Gabbana ad, the one at 1:37, has something of his look, I think.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qh4BLL4i39s
Beautiful Marco Mengoni does as well, although I would never guess Mengoni as anything other than Italian. His face also seems longer and narrower than the second picture of this athlete.
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-82y09TztV...co-mengoni-lessenziale-tour-teatrale-2013.jpg
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-abMZkeJDG_I/UPKDXfnglwI/AAAAAAAABRE/vCmDh3HbmoI/s1600/marcomengoni2.jpg
http://www.sorrisi.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/05/Marco-Mengoni_03.jpg
You can find something of this look in southern France, I think, definitely in terms of overall pigmentation, and you can even find those beautiful, large, lustrous dark eyes, but more rarely I think, and when you do find them, they're often married to either a large, sometimes convex nose, or a too short and blunt one, and the face shape is different...altogether a less gracile vibe to me.
Henri IV
http://static.guim.co.uk/sys-images...92436017010/Henry-IV.-Portrait-of-the-007.jpg
Paul Cezanne
http://www.biography.com/imported/images/Biography/Images/Profiles/C/Paul-Cezanne-9542036-1-402.jpg
http://theredlist.fr/media/database.../paul-cezanne/008_paul-cezanne_theredlist.png
Charles Boyer:
http://themave.com/Boyer/40s/images/allth1.jpg
It shows up in Spain as well and that phenotype is closer than the French ones, I think. Alfonso X of Castile has it, but in a coarser form.
http://los7sabios.com.ar/images_autors/alfonso-x-el-sabio.jpg
And yes, I've been in France often...every time I go to Italy, which is numerous times a year, I wind up going there...it's just a hop and a skip over the border in fact...I often fly to Paris, one of my favorite cities, connect to Marseilles and drive the rest of the way. That, or Milan to Pisa and drive, but that's longer.