Fire Haired14
Banned
- Messages
- 2,185
- Reaction score
- 583
- Points
- 0
- Y-DNA haplogroup
- R1b DF27*
- mtDNA haplogroup
- U5b2a2b1
This tree makes the most sense to me.
The most important information i want to give across is.
There's a lot more diversity in West Asia than we thought previously. The idea we had since Laz 2013, that all EEF and modern West Asians derive mostly from the same close-knit "ENF"(UHG+Basal Eurasian) population doesn't make sense anymore.
According to D-stats EEF is slightly closer to WHG than to CHG and modern West Asians. Bedouin are equally close to CHG and WHG according to D-stats. F3-drift stats from Jones 2015 showed EEF only has slightly more drift with CHG than with WHG.
IMO, the reason for this is the admixture between UHG+Basal Eurasian occurred a very long time ago. There's differnt types of Basal Eurasian and UHG. The UHG in EEF in particular is very related to European WHGs. I suspect that there was immigration from European Ice age refugees into Anatolia which can explain such admixture in EEF.
Mystery Eurasian contributing to proto-MA1 and proto-Dai is supported by.
(Kostienki WHG/MA1; Dai/Onge Chimp)<0
(Kostienki WHG/MA1; Ust-Ishim Chimp)=0
Kostienki and proto-MA1 in same Western branch is supported by
(Ust-Ishim/East Asian MA1; Kostenki Chimp)<0
(Ust-Ishim/East Asian Kostenki; MA1 Chimp)<0
proto-MA1 and proto-Kostienki admixture in WHG is supported by.
(Kostienki WHG; MA1 Chimp)<0
(MA1 WHG; Kostienki Chimp)<0
Basal Eurasian admixture in CHG and EEF is supported by.
(CHG/EEF MA1; Ust-Ishim Chimp)<0
(CHG/EEF Kostenki; Ust-Ishim Chimp)<0
WHG admixture in CHG and EEF is supported by.
(MA1 WHG; CHG/EEF Chimp)<0
(Kostenki WHG; CHG/EEF Chimp)<0
MA1-related admixture in CHG is supported by.
((EEF WHG; Ust-Ishim Chimp)-(CHG WHG; Ust-Ishim Chimp))+(EEF CHG; MA1 Chimp)<0
(WHG EHG; CHG Chimp)<0
(MA1 WHG; CHG Chimp)<(MA1 WHG; Armenian Chimp)<(MA1 WHG; EEF Chimp)
(EEF CHG; MA1 Chimp)<0
WHG admixture more related to European WHGs(Loschbour, Bichon) in EEF than in CHG is supported by.
F3(Kotais EEF; WHG)=.1+(Very significantly more drift)
(((EEF WHG; Ust-Ishim Chimp)-(CHG WHG; Ust-Ishim Chimp))+(Mbuti CHG; EuroWHG Chimp))-(Mbuti EEF; EuroWHG Chimp)=0.025+(pretty significant).
The most important information i want to give across is.
There's a lot more diversity in West Asia than we thought previously. The idea we had since Laz 2013, that all EEF and modern West Asians derive mostly from the same close-knit "ENF"(UHG+Basal Eurasian) population doesn't make sense anymore.
According to D-stats EEF is slightly closer to WHG than to CHG and modern West Asians. Bedouin are equally close to CHG and WHG according to D-stats. F3-drift stats from Jones 2015 showed EEF only has slightly more drift with CHG than with WHG.
IMO, the reason for this is the admixture between UHG+Basal Eurasian occurred a very long time ago. There's differnt types of Basal Eurasian and UHG. The UHG in EEF in particular is very related to European WHGs. I suspect that there was immigration from European Ice age refugees into Anatolia which can explain such admixture in EEF.
Mystery Eurasian contributing to proto-MA1 and proto-Dai is supported by.
(Kostienki WHG/MA1; Dai/Onge Chimp)<0
(Kostienki WHG/MA1; Ust-Ishim Chimp)=0
Kostienki and proto-MA1 in same Western branch is supported by
(Ust-Ishim/East Asian MA1; Kostenki Chimp)<0
(Ust-Ishim/East Asian Kostenki; MA1 Chimp)<0
proto-MA1 and proto-Kostienki admixture in WHG is supported by.
(Kostienki WHG; MA1 Chimp)<0
(MA1 WHG; Kostienki Chimp)<0
Basal Eurasian admixture in CHG and EEF is supported by.
(CHG/EEF MA1; Ust-Ishim Chimp)<0
(CHG/EEF Kostenki; Ust-Ishim Chimp)<0
WHG admixture in CHG and EEF is supported by.
(MA1 WHG; CHG/EEF Chimp)<0
(Kostenki WHG; CHG/EEF Chimp)<0
MA1-related admixture in CHG is supported by.
((EEF WHG; Ust-Ishim Chimp)-(CHG WHG; Ust-Ishim Chimp))+(EEF CHG; MA1 Chimp)<0
(WHG EHG; CHG Chimp)<0
(MA1 WHG; CHG Chimp)<(MA1 WHG; Armenian Chimp)<(MA1 WHG; EEF Chimp)
(EEF CHG; MA1 Chimp)<0
WHG admixture more related to European WHGs(Loschbour, Bichon) in EEF than in CHG is supported by.
F3(Kotais EEF; WHG)=.1+(Very significantly more drift)
(((EEF WHG; Ust-Ishim Chimp)-(CHG WHG; Ust-Ishim Chimp))+(Mbuti CHG; EuroWHG Chimp))-(Mbuti EEF; EuroWHG Chimp)=0.025+(pretty significant).